A Classy Game of Mafia - Page 7

On March 07 2024 10:40 DarthPunk wrote:
Also Do you have any other scum reads dmb?

On March 07 2024 10:41 DarthPunk wrote:


Why am I exhausting when we have barely interacted?

On March 07 2024 10:42 Jealous wrote:

So does that mean that all of the following have to be town?
Vivax (13), raynpelikoneet (3), Oatsmaster (1), Koshi (1)


Maybe this is a DP thing, or maybe I'm different from most, or maybe I'm just stupid... But how much evidence can DP have to name reasons for why he is not mafia when we're what, 16 hours into D1? Maybe the volume they put out... but still, let's have a thought experiment:

What arguments would you have for your own innocence at this point in the game?


I made an error out the gate (not catching that Alakaslam cop-claimed) and I didn't get my head bit off for it by anyone. It was corrected and we kept it moving. So, I think this point is overblown. If you're not scum, "mistakes" don't magically make you scum, IMO. The mistake itself has to be AI.


If it wasn't his meta already then I could see this being potentially being true/AI, but because you say that it is his meta... I don't get your point here?


Please clarify your logic here, too.

On March 07 2024 10:42 Jealous wrote:

So does that mean that all of the following have to be town?
Vivax (13), raynpelikoneet (3), Oatsmaster (1), Koshi (1)


Maybe this is a DP thing, or maybe I'm different from most, or maybe I'm just stupid... But how much evidence can DP have to name reasons for why he is not mafia when we're what, 16 hours into D1? Maybe the volume they put out... but still, let's have a thought experiment:

What arguments would you have for your own innocence at this point in the game?


I made an error out the gate (not catching that Alakaslam cop-claimed) and I didn't get my head bit off for it by anyone. It was corrected and we kept it moving. So, I think this point is overblown. If you're not scum, "mistakes" don't magically make you scum, IMO. The mistake itself has to be AI.


If it wasn't his meta already then I could see this being potentially being true/AI, but because you say that it is his meta... I don't get your point here?


Please clarify your logic here, too.

On March 07 2024 10:53 die_meatbaby wrote:


I could also see a scum slam claiming for blue. I would believe if slam is scum he would do something like that it is just not in vivax meta. He is not doeing that. To much fear. To much paranoir for that shit as mafia

On March 07 2024 10:53 JacobStrangelove wrote:
No I get why not lynching VE early I think everyone gets that, why do you then later say to lynch town VE later?

On March 07 2024 10:37 DarthPunk wrote:
Dmb is that the whole list of reasons why you are convinced I am mafia?

On March 07 2024 10:58 JacobStrangelove wrote:




Okay let me break it down, You said don't lynch VE early.

This makes sense.


you then say lynch TOWN VE later.

??? why would we lynch town ve later?

Lynching SCUM VE would make sense.

On March 07 2024 11:00 die_meatbaby wrote:


sorry mistake happens.

On March 07 2024 11:01 Jealous wrote:

Okay, I can believe that you believe this 👍


This I am having a much harder time following.

If I understand correctly you say that you wouldn't argue with DP regardless of your alignment, then you say you would not do it as mafia, and then you say you would do it as town?

Perhaps this will be easier, allow me to rephrase:

In this specific game, what can you point to as being reasons for why you are town by the 16 hour mark?

I'm just struggling to understand what your ideal response from DP would be here. If someone put me on the spot like that, frankly I'd just be like:



The way you responded to it is "let them play, then lynch them because they are an active townie," which doesn't make much sense to me as "compassion"? As Jacob said above, that almost sounds like a scumslip, but I am sure I must be misunderstanding something or you misspoke.

On March 07 2024 11:10 Jealous wrote:

I think that both are NAI. I wouldn't even call Koshi's "mistake" that. As someone else told you, I consider "if" and "when" to almost colloquially interchangeable in that context.

DMB's mistake reads as far more damning to me but there are mitigating factors and I think that even some as seemingly erratic as them wouldn't have brought it up just to slip up like that, IMO.

I'm more concerned about the fact that most of what they wrote that wasn't a mistake felt pretty weak to me. This is their best case on their strongest scum read, and now they are too lazy to stick around, because "I don't wanna be town I wanna be mafia"? That's hella weak IMO.

I can see a genuine town doing that, I guess, kinda like how we have people who didn't vote and aren't posting for various reasons. However, I also see it as sufficient reason to keep them on my lynch list, because mafia isn't precluded from claiming laziness after flailing under some light pressure.

On March 07 2024 11:59 Alakaslam wrote:
JSL IDK

Dang who else

On March 07 2024 12:10 iamperfection wrote:

are you serious

On March 07 2024 12:11 Alakaslam wrote:
Hi

Oats

I take everything back

When you are mafia, you have to take what you can get

Redcheck Oatsmaster

Even mafia didn't believe my claim. Or they just... had a better blue shot. Props to mafia team.

On March 07 2024 12:20 JacobStrangelove wrote:
Okay for now this means DMB looks better until we get a result from Oats.

On March 07 2024 12:29 Oatsmaster wrote:

It’s way too dumb to be real she asked the same question like 5 times cmon now

On March 07 2024 12:29 Vivax wrote:
I suspect she got instructed to fake dumbtell.
Which means the mafia is in dumpster fire mode.

On March 07 2024 12:40 Vivax wrote:
New theory:

The mafia is slam, Oats, DMB, Rels, marv

Slam gave up D1. Rels is too busy. Oats did his best but can‘t contain all that info leaking out of dmb in the thread and wants to kill her. Slam told him not to and is avenging dmb by fakeclaiming cop to fake a redcheck on his teammate.

Marv is in shambles and just wants to spend a bit of time with Palmar.

On March 07 2024 12:49 Jealous wrote:

New theory:

The mafia is Vivax, Koshi, Slam, JSL, and DP

They go max try-hard master mafia player mode to make themselves appear town and elect Vivax as mayor. Then they claim as many roles as they feel they can get away with knowing that there are so many roles available that they might just get away with a couple of them and thus look even more town. Then they guide us to mislynches, "reveal" townies like Oats as scum, and eventually get the most insane mafia victory of all time, making town look like a bunch of idiots. Their names are engraved on a golden plaque and the TL Mafia section is closed down. JAT and CC get canonized as saints.

/s