EPTOn May 06 2020 04:40 GlowingBear wrote:
That's not the impression I had. Are you sure this was the current votes in thread and no vote was cast on him?
There were no votes in between the vote count and the post I linked. We are talking about Day 2, right?Show nested quote +
On May 05 2020 15:35 Trfel wrote:
And here is the votecount at the time:
Conclusion
Two thread leaders (Koshi and Vivax) townread GlowingBear well before Jockmcplop confirmed his townread on GlowingBear. Therefore I don't believe that GlowingBear's reason to townread Jockmcplop is valid (even if GlowingBear is town).
GlowingBear, thoughts?
On May 05 2020 15:02 GlowingBear wrote:
If it wasn't for Shockey being lynched, jock would be, no? That's how I remember it.
Now, if this is the case, consider these assumptions:
mafia!jock is getting some votes on him. mafia!jock sees that town!Trfel posted a case on town!GB.
Why would mafia!jock defend town!GB when himself is piling votes? It doesn't make sense from a mafia perspective. Also, even if mafia!jock takes the path of defending me to get towncred, why didn't any other mafia agree with your case to throw suspicions on me?
My answer is that every name up for the lynch was fine for mafia. Which implies jock is town.
Is it fair to assume that Day 2 only really started Sunday evening PDT (when raynpelikoneet returned, Vivax voted off of raynpelikoneet, people started coming back to the thread, it was more than just me and Vivax playing the game, etc.)? Before then I'd say it's too hard to say who was going to be lynched. However, Jockmcplop defended GlowingBear before then, making this a lot harder... Here is where Jockmcplop first says he still townreads GlowingBear on Day 2.On May 05 2020 14:53 Trfel wrote:
And I'm sorry, I read through Jockmcplop's filter, I don't really see what you are saying. You said, day 2 he townread you when he could have scumread you? But I don't understand why that makes him town?
First, he wasn't up for lynch. I don't believe he was strongly pushed that day, though I guess I could double check this. Given that ShoCkeyy was town, there was never much risk of mafia getting lynched. And second, I was the only person who tried to push you Day 2, I wouldn't call that a viable wagon at all.
On May 05 2020 14:47 GlowingBear wrote:
I suck at acting though
Haha, I bet I'd be worse ^^On May 05 2020 14:42 Trfel wrote:
Also, impressive! That's super cool
On May 05 2020 14:41 GlowingBear wrote:
I do almost everything in theater, I've been an actor, playwright, producer, you name it. But mainly, stage director. It's a second career as I don't earn almost anything with it rofl.
The only reason I have to believe slam COULD be mafia is his wishy washiness, his lack of involvement in decisive moments. He being upset with shockey being lynch felt way too forced, he didn't seem to carry that much about what was happening during the day. But that's all.
You know, those are good reasons. Better than mine. Fair enough.On May 05 2020 14:36 Trfel wrote:
The more I think about it, the more your team does make sense. In some ways it makes more sense than my team. For example, I think it's weird putting you and Jockmcplop as mafia together, given how you went after Jockmcplop's joke vote so solidly and for so long. And I don't have many good reasons for Alakaslam to be mafia besides POE
But for some reason it still feels like it has to be right.
On May 05 2020 14:27 GlowingBear wrote:
I didn't had time because I started working with theater too. And when you're in rehearsals, it's impossible to play mafia. But anyway, let's see what happens after this coronavirus stuff. Maybe I keep playing. Thanks for that good to know I'm welcome. Know that this is reciprocal.
If I may, what kind of involvement with theater? And thanks, I really do appreciate it On May 05 2020 14:23 Trfel wrote:
[quote]Unfortunately mine is clinical, I've been in therapy and psychiatry for years and even a hospital stay from it What do you mean by the black dog stuff?
I only came back because of the virus too, honestly I've been enjoying it though. Fun game, fun people Even once this ends, consider coming back every once in a while! It'd be too bad if you stopped permanently. Though I guess everyone does eventually...
Haha, sounds good ^^ But paranoia is so much fun!
[quote]Unfortunately mine is clinical, I've been in therapy and psychiatry for years and even a hospital stay from it
What do you mean by the black dog stuff?I only came back because of the virus too, honestly I've been enjoying it though. Fun game, fun people
Even once this ends, consider coming back every once in a while! It'd be too bad if you stopped permanently. Though I guess everyone does eventually...Haha, sounds good ^^ But paranoia is so much fun!
I didn't had time because I started working with theater too. And when you're in rehearsals, it's impossible to play mafia. But anyway, let's see what happens after this coronavirus stuff. Maybe I keep playing. Thanks for that
good to know I'm welcome. Know that this is reciprocal.The more I think about it, the more your team does make sense. In some ways it makes more sense than my team. For example, I think it's weird putting you and Jockmcplop as mafia together, given how you went after Jockmcplop's joke vote so solidly and for so long. And I don't have many good reasons for Alakaslam to be mafia besides POE
But for some reason it still feels like it has to be right.I do almost everything in theater, I've been an actor, playwright, producer, you name it. But mainly, stage director. It's a second career as I don't earn almost anything with it rofl.
The only reason I have to believe slam COULD be mafia is his wishy washiness, his lack of involvement in decisive moments. He being upset with shockey being lynch felt way too forced, he didn't seem to carry that much about what was happening during the day. But that's all.
Also, impressive! That's super cool
I suck at acting though
And I'm sorry, I read through Jockmcplop's filter, I don't really see what you are saying. You said, day 2 he townread you when he could have scumread you? But I don't understand why that makes him town?
First, he wasn't up for lynch. I don't believe he was strongly pushed that day, though I guess I could double check this. Given that ShoCkeyy was town, there was never much risk of mafia getting lynched. And second, I was the only person who tried to push you Day 2, I wouldn't call that a viable wagon at all.
If it wasn't for Shockey being lynched, jock would be, no? That's how I remember it.
Now, if this is the case, consider these assumptions:
mafia!jock is getting some votes on him. mafia!jock sees that town!Trfel posted a case on town!GB.
Why would mafia!jock defend town!GB when himself is piling votes? It doesn't make sense from a mafia perspective. Also, even if mafia!jock takes the path of defending me to get towncred, why didn't any other mafia agree with your case to throw suspicions on me?
My answer is that every name up for the lynch was fine for mafia. Which implies jock is town.
And here is the votecount at the time:
On May 02 2020 23:14 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
ShoCkeyy: (1) Koshi
GlowingBear: (1) Trfel
raynpelikoneet: (0)Alakaslam
Trfel: (0)Alakaslam
Not Voting:
Chezinu, ShoCkeyy, Grackaroni, Vivax, Alakaslam, Jockmcplop, raynpelikoneet, GlowingBear
Again, not helpful. Vivax was townreading GlowingBear at this time though, for not voting to save himself at the end of Day 1. Koshi also called GlowingBear town well before this. I'm not sure what raynpelikoneet thought.Day 2 - BRRRR.MONEY COUNT
Votes:
Votes:
ShoCkeyy: (1) Koshi
GlowingBear: (1) Trfel
raynpelikoneet: (0)
Trfel: (0)
Not Voting:
Chezinu, ShoCkeyy, Grackaroni, Vivax, Alakaslam, Jockmcplop, raynpelikoneet, GlowingBear
ShoCkeyy is set to be lynched with 1 vote.
until End of Day
Conclusion
Two thread leaders (Koshi and Vivax) townread GlowingBear well before Jockmcplop confirmed his townread on GlowingBear. Therefore I don't believe that GlowingBear's reason to townread Jockmcplop is valid (even if GlowingBear is town).
GlowingBear, thoughts?
That's not the impression I had. Are you sure this was the current votes in thread and no vote was cast on him?
