EPT[M][T] Secret Hitler, Act I, Take II - Page 32
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On November 06 2018 06:59 raynpelikoneet wrote: Do you seriously think Grackaroni had the thought that he'd backpedal from nominating Conversion? Because i don't think that's a possibility given how strong he implied his read was (i agree Rels was never gonna get nominated most likely). Because if that was the case this would have happened: 1) Grack thinks: "okay i put my scumbuddy Conversion up there" (at least i agreed with his townread on Conversion back then) 2) "Well this is a super terrible thing to do because Rels isn't gonna be nominated anyways so i have to WAIT FOR HAIL MARY AND CROSS FINGERS THAT SOMEONE COMES AND TELLS ME TO NOMINATE SOMEONE ELSE" 3) rayn vouches for prplhz -> "THANK GOD I WOULD HAVE DONE A TERRIBLE MISTAKE FULLY KNOWING I DID ONE IF RAYN DIDNT DO THAT" really kita? really? that's not how mafia plays. On November 01 2018 23:37 kitaman27 wrote: It does seem unlikely that grack would want to pair himself with another facist early on in the game. I did say that it's unlikely in that exact post. Like I said, I wasn't entirely concerned about having the mafia team solved day one to have a scum read on both grack and conversion at the time. I don't think a facist grack necessarily had to anticipate someone else throwing out the prpl read. I think he could have nominated myself or prpl himself, but clearly you think otherwise. Either way, we're trending too far into hypothetical scenarios. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On November 06 2018 07:05 happykrogan wrote: Is it generally a bad Idea to just sheep a good player you think is townie when you are unsure about your own reads? Yes, it's usually fine to sheep another player if you think they are town, as long as you develop reads of your own eventually. That being said, I do find it weird that you seem to lean fascist on Conversion and say that you don't want to read me until tomorrow, yet are planning to pass this one through. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 06 2018 07:19 kitaman27 wrote: Yes, it's usually fine to sheep another player if you think they are town, as long as you develop reads of your own eventually. That being said, I do find it weird that you seem to lean fascist on Conversion and say that you don't want to read me until tomorrow, yet are planning to pass this one through. I decided to simply sheep rayn here, because I thought I had only about 5 minutes until deadline (as I returned to my pc). So I couldn't make a good read on you. Could have probably done it as there is no deadline post there though. I also never felt too confidend about conversion ecxept as I called him a liar, and as we were fighting, but I always returned to a "meh... I don't know" feeling about him pretty fast. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On November 06 2018 07:32 kitaman27 wrote: Do you still think he was lying? If not, why would a town player have motivation to lie in that case? If so, what changed your mind? EBWOP | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 01 2018 18:58 raynpelikoneet wrote: I would agree with you if this was about something that really matters, like if conversion had a scumread on someone and then forgot about it. But i dont think gameplaywise technical things go to that category and if he wants to discuss those things as scum i'd think he'd be sure to keep his story straight (because he can basically have any opinion he wants and it doesnt necessarily make him scum -- thats why this long discussion about technical things sucks, just play the game and make reads, thats priority #1). You'd be surprised how dumb things people can actually do. Some games ago we had a player who didnt know how their role worked, even after they were told to go re-read their role pm.... mainly this post made me unsure first. Rayn is a better player then me and doesn't think it matters so it probably doesn't matter. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 06 2018 07:35 happykrogan wrote: mainly this post made me unsure first. Rayn is a better player then me and doesn't think it matters so it probably doesn't matter. Because I am pretty sure he is town that is. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
| ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Unfortunately, we are close to a majority and there is a discrepancy in votes received between myself and Sentinel. In this case I will default to Sentinels PMs, however, since I have not sighted them, he will need to confirm... | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
[UoN]Sentinel
United States11320 Posts
| ||
|
[UoN]Sentinel
United States11320 Posts
| ||
|
byj
500 Posts
On November 06 2018 03:44 Conversion wrote: why am I or Rels suspicious for flat out ignoring you on getting reads onto people? Did I say that?  | ||
|
byj
500 Posts
On November 06 2018 04:12 happykrogan wrote: You are assuming, that if you vote but not talk mafia will defend you. Or flat out ignore me? :~) The reason for that is, that rels and conversion are easier to push as mafia. Therefore if you are telling the truth, you have to think they are both town, because otherwise mafia wouldn't want to push them. If they wouldn't rather push them then you (because they are also mafia) your logic why mafia would defend you has failed. Therefore you have to think they are town. I hope I made it clearer. Do you think it Scum wouldn't push each other eventually? I find it highly likely that at least 1 of them would have to be town, but not enough to vote for them ofc | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Rather than speaking in riddles, any chance that you could tell us what you do think? | ||
|
byj
500 Posts
On November 06 2018 08:27 byj wrote: Do you think it Scum wouldn't push each other eventually? I find it highly likely that at least 1 of them (Rels, Conv) would have to be town, but not enough to vote for them ofc On November 05 2018 20:05 byj wrote: Especially now in hindsight that Rels and Conversation seem to be easy to push as Scum instead (doesn't mean I think they're innocent either, they flatout ignored what I did =\). In case you missed it  | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
byj
500 Posts
| ||
| ||
