EPTvotes palmar because of some bs off hand comment and he's "definitely mafia"
no follow up on kita read, no questioning of palmar, just kill palmar plz
[M] Mafia For Busy People - Page 11
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
votes palmar because of some bs off hand comment and he's "definitely mafia" no follow up on kita read, no questioning of palmar, just kill palmar plz | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:16 kitaman27 wrote: At least fuba is consistent for favoring a Palmar vote over rayn. What did you even mean grack when you said "That's why I'm not switching."? That looks really sketchy. Yes, it's consistent, sure. The strength of his read is way TOO sure that Rayn is town over a point I don't think he ever can possibly think. He simultaneously says that his read isn't that strong and won't last till late game (which gives him an out) but goes to such great lengths to defend Rayn that it's absurd. He even said "What's so bad about not wanting a mislynch?" Too blatant. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
| ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
you're just as bad as kita. damned if you do, damned if you don't. what, so i am the only one voting kita and then you would say why i wasted my vote. we dont even know rayn alignment and you are shitting on everyone. GTFO. the only post i have somewhat respect for is #201. keep that up pls. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9856 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:22 Mocsta wrote: right HF. keep being big mommy and berating everyone. you're just as bad as kita. damned if you do, damned if you don't. what, so i am the only one voting kita and then you would say why i wasted my vote. we dont even know rayn alignment and you are shitting on everyone. GTFO. the only post i have somewhat respect for is #201. keep that up pls. +1 to this. Down with the haters! | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9856 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:16 kitaman27 wrote: At least fuba is consistent for favoring a Palmar vote over rayn. What did you even mean grack when you said "That's why I'm not switching."? That looks really sketchy. I wasn't really crazy about either of the lynches so I said that anticipating criticism of Rayn being lynched over Palmar and me throwing away my vote instead of voting a main wagon. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
You say that the mafia team is kita, plus 1 of Palmar and rayn, but a kita + rayn scumteam makes no sense in any stretch of the imagination. Do you still even view that as a possibility because you never even come close to showing a willingness to vote him? I'm not twisted your words, you're up in arms about a joke post 9 minutes into the game. Suggesting that I'm mafia for putting too much effort into a joke post is silly. As for the rayn stuff, he had a 24 hour chance to call Palmar mafia but didn't until Palmar threw out a vote and then he went full omgus. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:22 Mocsta wrote: right HF. keep being big mommy and berating everyone. you're just as bad as kita. damned if you do, damned if you don't. what, so i am the only one voting kita and then you would say why i wasted my vote. we dont even know rayn alignment and you are shitting on everyone. GTFO. the only post i have somewhat respect for is #201. keep that up pls. I am not berating everyone. I am berating specifically the people that have had no opinion or an exaggerated opinion of someone (such as yourself) and have done something that is scummy. Your kita case was extremely poor and not in a townie way. It's not that you misinterpreted anything, it's that you have taken specifically non-scummy posts and tried to misconstrue them to be scummy actions. Not only that but if your case is against kitamin and that he is mafia then naturally your vote would always be siding WITH rayn but never ever do you cite that rayn has a case against kita or that it's a good point in his favour. Instead, you just say meek things like "Oh, palmar had a lightly scummy post against kita... that's bad" and "rayn is ride or die with his reads, no scum would do that!" The above are just basic mafia faux pas that I see quite consistently. You're not thinking from a perspective about finding people that agree with you and narrowing things down, you're seeing the black and white and trying to blend in with what you think SHOULD be said. Then there's Grack. He's afkd the majority of the game (I mean, who hasn't?) but he returns and says that he'd rather vote rayn than palmar after literally just voting iamperfection. + Show Spoiler [grack filter] + On June 11 2018 01:02 Grackaroni wrote: I don't actually. I was just matching shit post for shit post. I don't have any reads atm, but I haven't read the new Rayn stuff yet. Superbia is on the list because he made the shit post. Palmar because he makes me laugh and I find his name funny, so I like to include Palmar in lists. On June 11 2018 01:35 Grackaroni wrote: Weird thing to me - Rayn is making a lot of smiley faces this game. I think this calls for some meta-investigations. On June 11 2018 01:38 Grackaroni wrote: After a thorough skimming of 3 filters, my conclusion is that Rayn makes a lot of smiley faces. Carry on folks. On June 11 2018 02:05 Grackaroni wrote: I think I'm going to go with a Koshi vote though I don't feel too strongly about it. The only person I like so far is Fuba. On June 11 2018 02:18 Grackaroni wrote: Nope I honestly can't decide. Instead I think I'll just attach my vote directly behind wherever Fuba's vote goes. Think carefully Mr. Fuba. I am counting on you. On June 11 2018 07:48 Grackaroni wrote: It's SHENNANNY time people On June 11 2018 07:50 Grackaroni wrote: I voted perfect. On June 11 2018 07:58 Grackaroni wrote: I'd rather lynch rayn than Palmar. That's why I'm not switching. On June 11 2018 07:58 Grackaroni wrote: Thought I'm not sure what Rayn is. On June 11 2018 08:06 Grackaroni wrote: err uhh... Yeah that one's on me. On June 11 2018 08:31 Grackaroni wrote: I wasn't really crazy about either of the lynches so I said that anticipating criticism of Rayn being lynched over Palmar and me throwing away my vote instead of voting a main wagon. His justification is that he was "pre-empting" rayn being lynched and him not being on the wagon. So, he thought rayn was actually being lynched and he was ALREADY pre-justifying not killing rayn. For what reason does he ever need to post that other than him caring about how he looks? He's literally at 0 content, likes the guy that has hard defended rayn (even though 90% of grack's filter is "digging" about rayn's meta (can you even call that one post digging?) and he wanted to lynch rayn (so why does he like fuba when fuba is definitely not the fuba of last game? who actually knows?). | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:31 Grackaroni wrote: I wasn't really crazy about either of the lynches so I said that anticipating criticism of Rayn being lynched over Palmar and me throwing away my vote instead of voting a main wagon. Anticipating criticism? How do you know he wasn't going to flip mafia? For what it's worth a rayn + grack scum team doesn't make a ton of sense in my opinion based on the earlier plea from rayn. meh guess we'll see where the night shot goes and go from there. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9856 Posts
I don't think my actions are very mafia-ish. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9856 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:31 Grackaroni wrote: I wasn't really crazy about either of the lynches On June 11 2018 01:13 Grackaroni wrote: No I don't think so I would expect my filter to piss him off. Why wasn't rayn's seemingly fake town read on you enough to feel stronger that he was mafia? Like I said earlier, he went out of his way to call you town at a point in the game where you hadn't even really said anything. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:36 Holyflare wrote: I am not berating everyone. I am berating specifically the people that have had no opinion or an exaggerated opinion of someone (such as yourself) and have done something that is scummy. Your kita case was extremely poor and not in a townie way. It's not that you misinterpreted anything, it's that you have taken specifically non-scummy posts and tried to misconstrue them to be scummy actions. Not only that but if your case is against kitamin and that he is mafia then naturally your vote would always be siding WITH rayn but never ever do you cite that rayn has a case against kita or that it's a good point in his favour. Instead, you just say meek things like "Oh, palmar had a lightly scummy post against kita... that's bad" and "rayn is ride or die with his reads, no scum would do that!" The above are just basic mafia faux pas that I see quite consistently. You're not thinking from a perspective about finding people that agree with you and narrowing things down, you're seeing the black and white and trying to blend in with what you think SHOULD be said. Then there's Grack. He's afkd the majority of the game (I mean, who hasn't?) but he returns and says that he'd rather vote rayn than palmar after literally just voting iamperfection. + Show Spoiler [grack filter] + On June 11 2018 01:02 Grackaroni wrote: I don't actually. I was just matching shit post for shit post. I don't have any reads atm, but I haven't read the new Rayn stuff yet. Superbia is on the list because he made the shit post. Palmar because he makes me laugh and I find his name funny, so I like to include Palmar in lists. On June 11 2018 01:35 Grackaroni wrote: Weird thing to me - Rayn is making a lot of smiley faces this game. I think this calls for some meta-investigations. On June 11 2018 01:38 Grackaroni wrote: After a thorough skimming of 3 filters, my conclusion is that Rayn makes a lot of smiley faces. Carry on folks. On June 11 2018 02:05 Grackaroni wrote: I think I'm going to go with a Koshi vote though I don't feel too strongly about it. The only person I like so far is Fuba. On June 11 2018 02:18 Grackaroni wrote: Nope I honestly can't decide. Instead I think I'll just attach my vote directly behind wherever Fuba's vote goes. Think carefully Mr. Fuba. I am counting on you. On June 11 2018 07:48 Grackaroni wrote: It's SHENNANNY time people On June 11 2018 07:50 Grackaroni wrote: I voted perfect. On June 11 2018 07:58 Grackaroni wrote: I'd rather lynch rayn than Palmar. That's why I'm not switching. On June 11 2018 07:58 Grackaroni wrote: Thought I'm not sure what Rayn is. On June 11 2018 08:06 Grackaroni wrote: err uhh... Yeah that one's on me. On June 11 2018 08:31 Grackaroni wrote: I wasn't really crazy about either of the lynches so I said that anticipating criticism of Rayn being lynched over Palmar and me throwing away my vote instead of voting a main wagon. His justification is that he was "pre-empting" rayn being lynched and him not being on the wagon. So, he thought rayn was actually being lynched and he was ALREADY pre-justifying not killing rayn. For what reason does he ever need to post that other than him caring about how he looks? He's literally at 0 content, likes the guy that has hard defended rayn (even though 90% of grack's filter is "digging" about rayn's meta (can you even call that one post digging?) and he wanted to lynch rayn (so why does he like fuba when fuba is definitely not the fuba of last game? who actually knows?). Ah, and the other player I was "berating" was Fuba, who has called Rayn town for talking in absolutes but when questioned on how he formed this read and contradicted his formation of this read with actual evidence the read shifts to simply "oh, he's just town anyway". On June 11 2018 01:55 fuba wrote: I overestimated the amount of time I'd have to play this morning :/ Still don't think rayn is scum. Nor Kita. Wary of voting palmar this early cuz if he's town he could solve the game, but I guess that applies to half the people in this game. My HF vote was a joke, but I'm not sure about him atm either (don't really have a read of him). I'd probably be up for voting most of the other people on the list tho :/ To elaborate somewhat on rayn - I think his reactions after being voted are pretty townie, and I tend to find absolutes when defending yourself to be a townie trait. Like "there's no way that's a scum tell because I said it and I'm town". Won't hold up over the course of the game, but for now it's enough for me to town read him. Left his reasoning super open to back off of it later. When contradicted with actual evidence of someone doing something that he town read rayn for as mafia he just says: On June 11 2018 05:12 fuba wrote: Did you? I don't recall. Guess there's something else about rayn that makes me feel that way. *Shrugs* Guess he has another reason to town read rayn instead? His whole principle for calling someone town has just been contradicted and it's "oh, guess it must be something else that I've never mentioned, whoops!". Yet, when other people vote rayn his whole world of reasoning because even MORE flimsy??? On June 11 2018 01:57 fuba wrote: Though having just seen the vote count - that's a lot of pretty good players on one person... Unless they're all scum (or even 2/3 of them are scum) I could just be wrong :S 90% of Fuba's filter is defending rayn based on flimsy argumentation. He even flip flops on this read based on absolutely nothing but then goes straight back to "I think rayn is town, I should defend this mislynch." It doesn't make the slightest bit of sense and reads very forced. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9856 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:42 kitaman27 wrote: Why wasn't rayn's seemingly fake town read on you enough to feel stronger that he was mafia? Like I said earlier, he went out of his way to call you town at a point in the game where you hadn't even really said anything. lol idk what to say I bungled it. I didn't feel like town was going to lynch mafia today based on how the day went. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
i have discussed rayns kita read. In fact, theres probably 3-4 posts between me + rayn on it. how have I misconstrued anything? for someone that is talking about finding information to narrow things down, you are doing a heck of job of predetermining outcomes. secondly. regarding mafia faux pas, and its converse = town mentality. The only person in my opinion that has actively tried to narrow down things beyond early game is rayn. your #1 target. Since the palmar flip, you can paint your posts in whatever colours you want. The facts remain. You have demonstrated zero disposition to reconsider rayn content. You have demonstrated zero disposition to consider people outside rayn. You have demonstrated disposition towards berating those that did not vote rayn. There is too little content in the game to be tunneled. I find this scummy. #207 is outright stupid. Why should i be focused on team pairings. Associations is always POST FLIP. I thought kita was meant to be an analytical player? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
like fuba to me reads like a feeler rather than a thinker. Why would you hold him to the same cold hard logical disposition of an introverted thinker? in my opinion, a feeler is more likely to cotton onto other arguments to join bandwagons, rather than put up blank positions that people like you can instantly shit on. Happy to be proven wrong from a meta dive if you can point in the right direction. i suspect im not far off the mark though. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On June 11 2018 08:51 Mocsta wrote: #208 regarding me is highly superficial i have discussed rayns kita read. In fact, theres probably 3-4 posts between me + rayn on it. how have I misconstrued anything? for someone that is talking about finding information to narrow things down, you are doing a heck of job of predetermining outcomes. secondly. regarding mafia faux pas, and its converse = town mentality. The only person in my opinion that has actively tried to narrow down things beyond early game is rayn. your #1 target. Since the palmar flip, you can paint your posts in whatever colours you want. The facts remain. You have demonstrated zero disposition to reconsider rayn content. You have demonstrated zero disposition to consider people outside rayn. You have demonstrated disposition towards berating those that did not vote rayn. There is too little content in the game to be tunneled. I find this scummy. #207 is outright stupid. Why should i be focused on team pairings. Associations is always POST FLIP. I thought kita was meant to be an analytical player? How have you misconstrued anything? Let's get started then: On June 09 2018 20:30 Mocsta wrote: Y so srs hf? Lemme give you top tip kita is mafia for going to the effort of splitting kelsier post into mini quotes BiG job right thurr.. and for what??? You call kita mafia for a blatantly joke post based on a pre-game post of Keliser's. You always talked about damned if you do, damned if you don't but you don't give any credit that a town Kita could just want to have fun by taking the piss out of a pre-game non-alignment determining kelsier post. On June 09 2018 23:33 Mocsta wrote: Lol. Koshi calling rels town ?!?!? Koshi has only called Rels mafia and will forever likely call Rels mafia. On June 10 2018 00:08 Mocsta wrote: Yo ksc Keep belittling your own posts bro Supa townie, amirite Keliser has not belittled his own posts at any point in this game. + Show Spoiler [this whole misconstrued case] + On June 11 2018 07:31 Mocsta wrote: try hard vote. its parsed to meaningless fluff the content and appear more "analytical" that what it is mafia know the most info day1 and when coupled with our level of play leads this towards a town tell. intentional twisting from kita. mafia!kitamin presenting a damned if you do, damned if you dont argument. its a core facet of the game to confront ppl hunting you. kitamin calls this scummy on the pretense of 3-4 others pressuring.. well fuck me, thats about as standard play as you can get.. why is this now leaning?? scum!kita.. thats why + future point. acknowledges slender is a friend of rayn. Is actively hunting rayn, so i suspect should be asking for rayn for feedback if slender posts content On June 11 2018 08:22 Mocsta wrote: right HF. keep being big mommy and berating everyone. you're just as bad as kita. damned if you do, damned if you don't. what, so i am the only one voting kita and then you would say why i wasted my vote. we dont even know rayn alignment and you are shitting on everyone. GTFO. the only post i have somewhat respect for is #201. keep that up pls. Saying I'm berating people when in fact I'm actually making cases and points on people but you try and bypass that and misconstrue it into berating when we don't know what rayn flipped. Thing is, we know that Palmar flipped town so even if Rayn flips town then pointing out people that have bad logic or reasoning for their votes is what we should be doing. On June 11 2018 08:51 Mocsta wrote: #208 regarding me is highly superficial i have discussed rayns kita read. In fact, theres probably 3-4 posts between me + rayn on it. how have I misconstrued anything? for someone that is talking about finding information to narrow things down, you are doing a heck of job of predetermining outcomes. secondly. regarding mafia faux pas, and its converse = town mentality. The only person in my opinion that has actively tried to narrow down things beyond early game is rayn. your #1 target. Since the palmar flip, you can paint your posts in whatever colours you want. The facts remain. You have demonstrated zero disposition to reconsider rayn content. You have demonstrated zero disposition to consider people outside rayn. You have demonstrated disposition towards berating those that did not vote rayn. There is too little content in the game to be tunneled. I find this scummy. #207 is outright stupid. Why should i be focused on team pairings. Associations is always POST FLIP. I thought kita was meant to be an analytical player? This entire post is also incredibly misconstrued. I have considered rayn's content and I find it extremely lacking and I mean EXTREMELY. He made a case on kita that made him "definitely mafiaa", that went nowhere and he forgot all about it or certainly didn't want to push it over a palmar read that's based off of one post and shit. He voted Palmar who he knows can't play on a weekend based on absolutely 0 content and said it was a definitive scum read based on nothing. He town read Grack who has posted absolute drivel. He likes Kelsier and Superbia who have also posted absolute drivel. He only really started playing after I called him out and he gained like 4 votes. He berated people at the start of the game for not playing. I have absolutely considered other people outside of rayn which is why I've just been posting about yourself, Grack and Fuba for the past hour. What a terrible thing to write, I can't actually understand how you even think that's correct. I am not berating anyone. I am calling out bad patterns and filters and it just so happens they are people that haven't voted rayn. Voting rayn or not voting rayn means nothing to me in this context since the things I have called these people out for are: A) Nothing to do with them voting rayn. B) Everything to do with their filters and how they have acted with regards to the game. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
stop trying so much and you might see the forest instead of the trees. i didnt mention kita joke post when i was seeking consolidation on him towards EoD. koshi said his first vote would be on town. He voted rels. THis is why i commented, is koshi declaring rels a town read? kelsier belittled his own contribution by claiming it was subject to a skim read. definition of "berate" 100% applies to you. "scold or criticize (someone) angrily." experience says its normally scum that like to shit on player straight after a lynch. In my opinion, you have only considered people outside of rayn in the past hour because you didnt get the lynch you wanted and are now trying to bully those that opposed the o-so-mighty HF. Clearly the next point is conjecture, but i dare surmise that of those you are berating, none were your second lynch option prior to EoD. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On June 11 2018 09:42 Mocsta wrote: #217 stop trying so much and you might see the forest instead of the trees. i didnt mention kita joke post when i was seeking consolidation on him towards EoD. koshi said his first vote would be on town. He voted rels. THis is why i commented, is koshi declaring rels a town read? kelsier belittled his own contribution by claiming it was subject to a skim read. definition of "berate" 100% applies to you. "scold or criticize (someone) angrily." experience says its normally scum that like to shit on player straight after a lynch. In my opinion, you have only considered people outside of rayn in the past hour because you didnt get the lynch you wanted and are now trying to bully those that opposed the o-so-mighty HF. Clearly the next point is conjecture, but i dare surmise that of those you are berating, none were your second lynch option prior to EoD. Your whole beginnings of voting kita are that he called you mafia. He called you mafia because you did some misconstruing of his joke post. You also make this line in your case: mafia know the most info day1 and when coupled with our level of play leads this towards a town tell. intentional twisting from kita. Rels point is fine. Impossible to surmise if this is correct when looking at your filter because you don't adequately explain half the things you write or quote a post to have context to it. Kelsier point is whatever. Fine. Different opinions on belittling. You are confusing berating with renewed vigour. Also your last point is patently false because I've already talked about fuba before. The last two people (you and grack) are because of shady deadline posts that made me look at you (and also because I didn't care about playing until deadline). Of course I'm going to look at people that pushed a town lynch over someone I think was a good lynch and could well be mafia. | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
| ||
| ||
