EPTAre you thinking this is the case here then?
I'm super confused as to how people's first reactions to a cc situation is "both of them are town"
Newbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 37
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Calix
3379 Posts
Are you thinking this is the case here then? I'm super confused as to how people's first reactions to a cc situation is "both of them are town" | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:26 ika42 wrote: I want to see a game where it has happened here on this site Look up any game with Raynpelikoneet. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:26 Calix wrote: Are you thinking this is the case here then? I'm super confused as to how people's first reactions to a cc situation is "both of them are town" I believe so, yes. | ||
|
Vivax
21978 Posts
| ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
Are their mutiple games where this has happeend? has it happened with you and anohter player? what about BTDT? One game does not make it sufficent to be invaild | ||
|
Vivax
21978 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:25 Vivax wrote: So saying that darthfoley's read on ika looks forced equivals telling darthfoley to back off ika? What the hell is wrong with people's logic in this game? Squishyyyyyyyy | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
Fake ccs are extremely rare on our site. | ||
|
Onegu
United States9699 Posts
On January 08 2017 05:09 darthfoley wrote: I'm still having trouble wrapping my mind around why people think his vote on Onegu is scummy. I've pointed it out before but I feel like New scum would be very worried about not getting attention on them, and an early vote does the opposite. Also @ everyone scum reading him for the weekend comment, KSC did LITERALLY the same thing but many people including you, btdt, are town reading him. I don't get why the same action is providing two different conclusions for two different players You are wrong here by the way. New scum want to look useful. Making a vote on someone is a easy way to do that. But his reason was I was suspicious and he just left it at that. He didnt give reasons just that I was suspicious. TBH I think he was told by his scummates he needed to say his vote was pressure because that is the only reason to make that vote. But it isnt what he said to start. | ||
|
beentheredonethat
2934 Posts
| ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:31 beentheredonethat wrote: I will not be around at deadline as it is 01:00AM in the morning for me. Already saying this. These guys will 100% lynch you tomorrow if you don't un-claim. And I think rightfully so. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:29 Vivax wrote: Ika why don't you take at face value that it simply happened? I've seen fake cop claims, fake vigilante claims from VTs. Do you really need us to take you by the hand and lead you to where it happened? Are we all mafia lying to you? Becasue the face vaule of both are town who are either VT/VT or Doc/VT is so bad that i would be more willing to accept it if it was 2 newbies doing it. Both players are considered veterans so if they are doing what you think is happening (town/town) i question their skills as players becasue the single idea of doing so is so anti-town and so time wasting and annoying and pissoffy that i would bar them from playing any games of mine and most likely policy lynch them in any game i play with them. Its not a protown move and is litarly greifing at best. now im droping this subject untill one flips/post game becasue its going to get into the line of this Ban discussions: Please wait until this game is over to talk about modkills and bans resulting from this game. and im not going there. so if you would be kind to drop it for now we can save it for post game now i got stuff to do and im not going to be here for EOD | ||
|
Vivax
21978 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:31 Calix wrote: I think ika/ SW and myself are having the same culture shock tbh. Fake ccs are extremely rare on our site. I would trust BTDT to do such a thing cause he's 1) In two games, 2) His play is pretty f*ing weird this game and I don't know if he's a tilting town or rolled scum and sees no hope of winning or something. I'm just ignoring the claims cause Grack imo is simply town, claim or not, and mafia will sort it out for us at night cause they'd be stupid not to kill a doctor. As with most discussion around claims for lynching, it's mostly useless. I prefer sticking to the old plan and lynching Kelsier for his initial comment on the game and not being around as someone who is capable of caring as town. | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:31 Calix wrote: I think ika/ SW and myself are having the same culture shock tbh. Fake ccs are extremely rare on our site. Your right, its more about those "scum slips"  | ||
|
Kmatt
United States1019 Posts
My shtick with Grace's nonsense wasn't that he had a feel/gut read on Vivax being town (as you said I had posted the same earlier), but that he claimed to have built this substantial case, hid it from the thread, had that stupid argument, postee his "evidence" of the read and only at the very end backtracked to say it was and gut read as null along. That's what got my goat, running circles only to conclude he made 90% of this case up. | ||
|
Vivax
21978 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:33 ika42 wrote: Becasue the face vaule of both are town who are either VT/VT or Doc/VT is so bad that i would be more willing to accept it if it was 2 newbies doing it. Both players are considered veterans so if they are doing what you think is happening (town/town) i question their skills as players becasue the single idea of doing so is so anti-town and so time wasting and annoying and pissoffy that i would bar them from playing any games of mine and most likely policy lynch them in any game i play with them. Its not a protown move and is litarly greifing at best. now im droping this subject untill one flips/post game becasue its going to get into the line of this and im not going there. so if you would be kind to drop it for now we can save it for post game now i got stuff to do and im not going to be here for EOD I think you are overrating the veteran thingy. Calix has played not even a year here and is considered veteran. What I want to say is that veteran in this game only means that someone has played mroe than three newbie games, not necessarily that he's a mafia professional. | ||
|
Onegu
United States9699 Posts
On January 08 2017 05:44 SilverWolf77 wrote: I voted for Grackaroni in the vote thread-this is just an FYI post to let everyone know where my vote is. If you'd prefer I vote here as well going forward, I can do that. Not sure how everyone does this. It is common for people to vote in both threads, not doing so will make people say you are ninja voting and trying to hide your intentions. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:35 Kmatt wrote: Alright every time I go back to start reading 4 pages get tacked on the end (I'm on post 621 as of this reply) so I'm just going to take a moment to answer DF from earlier. My shtick with Grace's nonsense wasn't that he had a feel/gut read on Vivax being town (as you said I had posted the same earlier), but that he claimed to have built this substantial case, hid it from the thread, had that stupid argument, postee his "evidence" of the read and only at the very end backtracked to say it was and gut read as null along. That's what got my goat, running circles only to conclude he made 90% of this case up. Where did I claim that I had a substantial case for Vivax being town? | ||
|
ika42
260 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:36 Vivax wrote: I think you are overrating the veteran thingy. Calix has played not even a year here and is considered veteran. What I want to say is that veteran in this game only means that someone has played mroe than three newbie games, not necessarily that he's a mafia professional. maybe so. but doesnt change what i will say/how i feel about it | ||
|
Calix
3379 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:34 Vivax wrote: I would trust BTDT to do such a thing cause he's 1) In two games, 2) His play is pretty f*ing weird this game and I don't know if he's a tilting town or rolled scum and sees no hope of winning or something. I'm just ignoring the claims cause Grack imo is simply town, claim or not, and mafia will sort it out for us at night cause they'd be stupid not to kill a doctor. As with most discussion around claims for lynching, it's mostly useless. I prefer sticking to the old plan and lynching Kelsier for his initial comment on the game and not being around as someone who is capable of caring as town. No. One of them has to die because they'll cause too much disruption re: WIFOM. Scum has RBer so they'll just claim that's why they were left alive and time will be wasted on discussing whether they're town or scum fake-claiming and blah blah blah. I'd rather clear shit up right now. | ||
|
Onegu
United States9699 Posts
On January 08 2017 06:17 Vivax wrote: I refuse to believe Grack is mafia. But I didn't have high expectations in a newbie game. You are free to lynch the wrong guys how you please. Not going to lie. That is bad claim timing from either alignment. He wasnt in the vote lead and I think votes were moving away from him... | ||
| ||
