Well questions

are you town? - Yes
how long have you played mafia? - About three games? I've been playing on not this site.
do you play elsewhere and if so where? - Yes, on GPRO.net
What is your typical play style? I normally play very analytical, using logic and information posted
how do you scumhunt/townhunt? I find contradictions in the player via keeping careful notes on everyone
do you know anyone here that you can read very well? nope, first game on the site

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 03:51 GMT

#154

About to go do a re read through, because Onegu hasn't posted anything of note since the game started (by of note, I mean anything I took note on)

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 04:11 GMT

#155

yeah Onegu seems suspicious, so

##vote Onegu

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 06:32 GMT

#165

The hell is a zj?

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 21:46 GMT

#276

I thought I voted for Onegu, is the page 10 vote count wrong or did I or did I format it wrong?

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 22:32 GMT

#280

Okay, so after catching up, I have a few things to respond on.

First, as to why I am not more active, is that I have not a whole lot of time to play mafia during the week, so what I am doing is catching up, responding to everything I feel needs a response, giving my reads, then getting back off. You may flame me for this, but unless it's the weekend this will be how I play. I do have a life you know, but mafia is a lot of fun (which is why I wanted to play it).

As to why I voted Onegu (asked three times, by my count), he has made a claim (with the first post of the game) and then posted a non informative post. That's all he has done. I wanted to see what happens if he gets a bit of pressure on him, but after this amount of time I feel that he is just inactive.

On to my reads, Kmatt feels very much a scummy player to me becuase he is posting quite a bit now, but it doesn't feel like he is accomplishing anything. DarthFoley seems waaaay too defensive, so that seems odd, but I'll keep looking at him so I can get a more solid read. Vivax and MichaelEhrmantraut seem a bit off. Nothing suspicious, but just a bit not quite correct to me. This is more of a gut read than anything else, so I'll be doing a reread (probably today) for just them to see what's up.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 22:37 GMT

#281

Oh, a vote on me! Well, my entrance was terrible, I do admit, but I did address why I did not follow up on Onegu (I just voted to see if he was here, apparently not). I also admit that I am not the most active right now, that's just due to real life. Just read my post here, but the TLDR is REAL LIFE limits my weekday activity.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 06 2017 22:43 GMT

#286

Oh I'm definately going to switch my vote, I'm just torn as to who. As soon as I can finish my read throughs, I'll post again about my reads. One more note, tommorrow I won't be online until about 2 hours before the deadline. I am sorry about this, but real life takes up a lot of my time.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 21:04 GMT

#672

Onegu, my vote on you was to try and spur you into action. If I said, "Oh I'm voting Onegu to see if he'll be active" then it's not a good pressure vote.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 21:21 GMT

#706

On January 07 2017 13:08 reps)squishy wrote:

Show nested quote +

Grack are you trying to cause conflict deliberately. This looks like a scum thing to do because it causes disorder and chaos. Instead of trying to get leads it devolves into a huge argument over burden of proof. I argue to any townie please do not fall into this trap.

This is an excellent point, one that I hadn't considered. I'll keep reading with this in mind.

Also update on a few reads, Vivax and Michael seem off to me still, but I can't put my finger on it.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 22:10 GMT

#778

well I think that since Grackaroni was Counter Claimed I best put my vote on him. Shame as I was leaning town on him.

##Vote Grackaroni

And yes I'll be much more active now that it is the weekend.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 22:12 GMT

#779

Well that seems rather sorted. is Instalynch a thing on this site?

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 22:16 GMT

#786

Thank you, good to know.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 22:19 GMT

#789

And I was town reading Grack mostly because I didn't notice anything overly suspicious other than creating confusion. This isn't something that I normally lynch people for.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 22:48 GMT

#808

Michael, your posts just seem.... off, in a way. I can't put my finger on it, but you seem wrong to me.

Also Grack, it was mostly a gut feeling more than anything else. You were playing stupidly, but it was a town sort of stupidity.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 07 2017 23:08 GMT

#812

It's almost entirely gut feel, but okay..

so with B0stonSC bandwagon-ing onto someone's scum-read of me, when all I have done is posted thrice.

This feels super defensive and is wrong. I wasn't bandwagoning, I was just saying you felt off.

1. no
2. back in the day
3. no
4. ?
5. ?
6. nope

This, while not inharently AI, seems weird to me. I don't know you well enough to use this as a meta read, jokingly saying "oh I'm scum" to throw people off. I don't know you well enough, but this has happened in one of the games of mafia I've played. People just assumed the guy was Town only because he had been playing for a long while, and jokingly said "oh I'm scum." when asked during day 1.

So nothing that is a good case, but just a bit of explanation for my gut feeling.

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 08 2017 00:35 GMT

#839

Why not post your tinfoil theory now?

B0stonSC

United States59 Posts

January 09 2017 21:55 GMT

#1067

Okay Everyone right now I'm super torn. I feel that BTDT should be lynched, because he was a total idiot. However, I also think that is a waste of a lynch when the Scum team is (in my humble opinion) ME and KSC (don't know who the third is). But if I say, "oh let's not lynch BTDT" and he turns out to be scum, then I'll look bad, and will probably get lynched next. This is just what I feel the best play is for us, not lynching BTDT just yet. But since most of you seem to disagree with me, I don't think I'll be changing any minds.

1 2 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh