[M][T] Host's Revenge Mafia - Page 12

On January 05 2017 03:36 disformation wrote:
real stupid question: does the real scum team even have a nk?
skimmed the op but didnt see info on that...

On January 05 2017 03:47 disformation wrote:
lynching into the coinflips might be super risky too.
the nightactions might rise more questions than answers.

On January 05 2017 03:55 disformation wrote:
wait. if tt has jailkeeped chez, maybe scum tried to kill chez? cause his role looks pretty damn good, if he is what i think?

would explain the unclaimed nuke?

On January 05 2017 02:47 darthfoley wrote:
A Poor Man's Confession


At the end of D1, I was PM'd to inform me that I was now a mafia roleblocker. My teammates were Ticktock and Grackaroni. Grack was the Godfather, TT was goon. This QT is called the House of Brown.

We surmised that Superbia would be a good kill especially if he had a blue role, wouldn't really link back to me, and I was going to claim vigi misshot. I roleblocked Superbia in case he shot/checked me and got saved.

Ticktock used his sleeping bag (according to him, one time jailkeep) on Chez so disformation wouldn't get the seed that would probably let him check Grack. Grack claims to have gotten medicine X. He also claims this medicine makes him show up as mafia, but that he hasn't drank it. Not sure if I believe him regarding the utility of his medicine.

So we thought this was peachy keen. I was going to claim "vigi shooting" Superbia, while the other mafia team was going to shoot town. This would allow both the other mafia team, and the town to be under the assumption that there was still only one mafia team in the game.

However, after the D2 post, we were notified that we had no mafia powers: KP, GF, RB. We weren't even a mafia team. We were just three dudes put in a QT.

So, as it stands, I am in a QT that is still being somewhat used with Grack and TT. According to the hosts, our alignments are what we started with, plus the QT, plus "whatever we may have received" D2.

So either there were two teams of three that individually chose Superbia kill, or Grack/TT are mafia and knew of our plan, notified the other mafia team, etc.

This is partially why I have been trolly and confused. I don't know in which scenario Superbia died. So yea, I wanted to kill Superbia under the assumption that I was mafia. However i'm not mafia. I cannot confirm anything else regarding Grack and TT's alignments

On January 05 2017 05:05 beentheredonethat wrote:
Also note how the active people that are in thread right now are almost the same as EoD1. Slam, Chez, Time Traveler, they all disappeared. This is just bad.

On January 05 2017 05:06 beentheredonethat wrote:

This is such a worthless sentence as there's no way to ever prove that.

"If I was real scum, I would play totally different from how I played all game."
Like, really?

On January 05 2017 05:03 beentheredonethat wrote:
The House of Brown presents: The Curious Case of BTDT?

So, i'll try to keep this succinct.

Here are the original points I will summarize but don't need to show
1. btdt was super inactive all D1
2. mysteriously comes back when he is going to be the lynch, and only then, and gets the lynch off him WHILE successfully mislynching Koshi.


Koshi



He firstly explains that there is no possible way he could accurately catch up. Within the same post, he advocates for Koshi's lynch strongly, appealing to the authority of his previous reads on Koshi--


Yes.
1. I have not read the game as I simply forgot about it.
2. I randomly opened some filters.
3. I saw Koshi had one page of filter. Easiest scumread given that I have a pretty good grip on Koshi's meta.

Would anyone characterize Koshi's D1 play as being in the driving seat of the game? He intentionally made himself NOT in the driving seat, and it got him lynched. The first and second sentence contradict each other; Koshi did not go under the radar D1, he was talked about by ExO, me, Grack, Superbia, etc.


You're trying to paint a contradiction. That would require that I actually had read the game which at this point, I had not done. I had no idea that Exo, you, whoever, talked about Koshi. Also, how could you know that Koshi INTENTIONALLY did not put himself into the driver's seat?







Really? You're confident? Within twenty minutes, BTDT went from randomly diving filters AND it being impossible for him to catch up, into confidently lynching Koshi-- not just any random player.


Of course I am confident! I have hosted three games where Koshi rolled scum as well as town. I have played with him as scum and as town. Reading his one-page filter, I felt absolutely confident that this was scum!Koshi going under the radar. Note how at this point I still hadn't caught up. I mean, what do you expect me to do? I was happy to consolidate on a player I could judge instead of wasting my vote such as others (TiTr) did ALTHOUGH they had read the game.




"Don't lynch LS over Koshi-- that's nuts." Again he reroutes the lynch train onto Koshi, effectively stopping what Grack and I were trying to do (lynch LS > Koshi).


I am not rerouting here. You took that out of context - context being that someone thought about lynching LS and I actively said "don't do that". Why did I say that? Easy - Koshi was inactive and playing to his scum meta, while LS had a filter of multiple pages and felt rather townie. Again, I skimmed. You can't really scumread me for saying wrong things .





Then this??? Like seriously???? + Show Spoiler + Btdt spent an entire hour pre-deadline rerouting the lynch off of him and onto Koshi. This is a really scummy reaction to an already scummy EoD

Why is that a scummy reaction? I was genuinely pissed, mainly towards disformation but also pissed about myself. I had strongly argued for a Koshi lynch and I might have done way better for town then I did D1 if only I had not forgotten about this game. I tried to play the game as good as I could and I was angry about failing at it. Also, I was even more pissed about disformation as I felt like his wishywashy playstyle was detrimental for town.





It's one thing to be wrong about someone. Yea, that happens. It's another thing to wholeheartedly advocate for someone's death after not reading the entire game WHILE using your previous reads on him to bolster your argument

I was not using any "previous reads" on Koshi. I don't know what you are referring to. I applied a solid meta read to Koshi and if you would just put in the effort to check Koshi's past games, you'd instantly see that he was playing 100% to his scum meta of "I chime in every now and then but besides that I stay under the radar and pretend to be lazy town".



+ Show Spoiler +