[M][N] Murder on the Cruise Trip Mafia - Page 131

On October 10 2016 02:15 Grackaroni wrote:

Why does that matter?

On October 10 2016 02:17 justanothertownie wrote:

It matters because palmar had more reason to do shit.

He is complaining now but did he do anything about either lynch? No. And he WAS around. He said the superbia lynch is alright and now everyone suddenly is a retard.

On October 10 2016 02:16 Grackaroni wrote:

Sounds good to me. But you've been pushing Oatsmaster recently for making verbal salad when Oatsmaster is known for doing this.

On October 08 2016 05:14 Palmar wrote:

it isn't dull, it's correct.

You lack confidence, that points to you being mafia, but fuck it let's pretend you're not for a little bit for the sake of moving the game forward.

By lack of confidence, I mean your ridiculous emphasis on getting me to answer some completely tangential questions you have no need for to determine my alignment.

But if you must, the explanation is very simple. I wasn't very much around, I didn't think bats was scum and I'm not mafia. I tried to push for a Calix lynch, which I've now decided was retarded. At the deadline I was mad and only barely paying attention to the thread. I did explain my reasoning for voting HF, but in hindsight I was just being a moron and failed to catch what is a fairly obvious joke. I got mad and voted him.

Essentially, I got trolled.

Of course he started posting like a townie and making sense again, so I came around, also realizing that I was just being stupid. Someone said during that time that HF was scummy for pulling the "it was just a joke" defense, but whatever.

On October 10 2016 02:19 justanothertownie wrote:

It wasn't verbal salad. It was straight up making up shit. Read it again if you didn't understood it. He couldn't even name the smallest reason for me to be mafia. It was pathetic.
If you call me mafia for scumreading him then explain to me how he can be town.

On October 10 2016 02:18 Grackaroni wrote:

And he could have just not shown up at all rather than show up at the last minute to dispute the lynch and he would have attracted far less attention.

On October 10 2016 02:20 Grackaroni wrote:

He's saying that you are mafia because he thinks that there needs to be an active mafia player pushing people away from Scott/Damdred. It's not likely to be Calix, so that pretty much leaves you.

On October 10 2016 02:21 justanothertownie wrote:

Sure, but he still was the counterwagon so not showing up would be pretty dangerous, don't you agree? If he appears at the last minute as mafia people will not believe him.

On October 10 2016 02:26 Grackaroni wrote:

I didn't really consider Palmar the counterwagon, but sure, let's go there. Mafia! Palmar sees the lynch train headed to town! Superbia guided by JAT and Calix. "Oh my god, I'm so nervous about being lynched!" Proclaims mafia! Palmar. He decides to show up before the lynch to proclaim, "Superbia is town! Let's lynch somebody else!" After he said that he disappeared because now he was clearly safe from the lynch.

Do you really believe this shit? Showing up and telling people not to lynch somebody is dangerous for him. This is the second time he has endangered himself by doing this.

On October 10 2016 02:24 justanothertownie wrote:
Like, I am perfectly ok with palmar and marv fighting it out and lynching the loser but I won't let you tell me that I am mafia for not townreading palmar or mafiareading oatsmaster.
That is pure bullshit.

On October 10 2016 02:29 Grackaroni wrote:

I'm probably going to write a case on Koshi later for calling me mafia and then backing off really badly.

I'm suspicious of you because you are reading the game completely opposite of me and you are the one who is putting in the effort to make sure that my townreads/myself get killed.

I actually liked that you followed through with your meta read on Superbia earlier, but the disparity in our reads is going to have to change at some point if my read is going to change.

On October 10 2016 02:32 Grackaroni wrote:
Also NU was accusing me of buddying Marv for your dick joke earlier. This is why we don't make jokes JAT!

I'm really glad I'm not Calix because having an argument with NU every 15 pages must be pretty miserable.

On October 10 2016 02:31 justanothertownie wrote:

Or maybe you are just wrong and I am right? Yes, I was wrong on superbia. Shit happens. But you can't tell me I didn't have really good reasons to suspect him or that he was obvious town.

On October 09 2016 19:24 justanothertownie wrote:
Oats is probably mafia.

Can anyone tell me how the green and the red can go together in the mindset of a townie?


If you thought he could have easily flipped mafia then how on earth is it scummy for me to push his lynch? Or why would the lynch not happen without scum intervention? It doesn't make the slightest bit of sense. If you don't even think damdred is mafia then why would scum need to intervene to get the lynch off of him and onto someone else?
These 2 posts alone are full with contradictions.

The Palmar point is alright though. He had no business being right on superbia there after calling himself an acceptable lynch just before. And he also never moved his vote away from me or tried to convince anyone to lynch who he wants to be lynched.
You cannot complain afterwards if you didn't do anything about the lynch while you were clearly around at times.

On October 10 2016 02:46 Grackaroni wrote:

This is the point that Oats is making in his post:

He feels that without scum intervention Damdred or Scott would have been the lynch, and you were the only one (besides Koshi actually, Oats missed that) who bothered to put in the groundwork for a lynch that wasn't Damdred/Scott.