Newbie Student Mafia XXIII - Page 9

On September 29 2016 05:26 Tictock wrote:


To be fair I did read your WoT, or most of it. I just thought the majority of it was crap.

The reads feel a bit off, like Rels should be much more obv town based on his pressure on Lunatic. I obv disagree about Skynx.

The whole team thing is just bad imo. I'd probably be willing to write it off as a bad approach but the way you use the team stuff to throw out DYH feels off to me.

On September 29 2016 05:26 Calix wrote:


Who cares about finding the entire scum team on D2? lol. I have tried that before and it's a really bad idea. Just means the scum will be on their guard and making sure their interactions are like "kk this is how we're going to fuck with the associations lul" and means people get stuck in a tunnel of confirmation bias. I'd know all about that.

tl;dr: No, I don't need to read it to know it's bad and you're bad for doing that.

On September 29 2016 05:31 Rels wrote:

I was the one who started the wagon. Not by vote but by pressuring Lunatic into giving up.

On September 29 2016 05:32 Calix wrote:
DYH/ Stutters would make a lot of sense given that they have done nothing the entire game, have zero thread presence, etc. This would explain how the scum didn't try to save Lunatic or divert attention elsewhere, because none of them have the influence/ staying power to pull that off.

On September 29 2016 05:34 DoYouHas wrote:
Ok, here we go.

First off

Rels - This is town Rels, it may be meta, it may be whatever, but if he ends up being mafia he gets a hearty handshake from me because this feels exactly like town Rels. Strongest read I have in the game.

Calix - Everyone already agrees on this one, never lynch, maybe MAYBE take a harder look if he is alive lategame.

On September 29 2016 05:47 Calix wrote:
Seeing Xatalos/ Skynx bicker is making me smirk from how childish you both are.

In all seriousness though, save it for later pls. Nobody wants your bitch-slapping right now when DYH is in the house.

On September 29 2016 05:44 Xatalos wrote:
Do you really think DanelerH pushed Lunatic off the cliff for no real reason?

On September 29 2016 05:53 DoYouHas wrote:
ptmc - The crazy effort in analyzing the game is major town points from me. The way he addressed my response to Rels' case also showed that he is reading carefully and thinking critically. So long as he doesn't drop off hard I'm thinking he is town.

Xata - I liked him from the first hours of the game when he interacted with Calix. Calix stuck around and mixed things up even when he had been given an out, Xata recognized this and gave him a townread for it. I agreed with the read and I liked that he mentioned it as it would be an easy thing to let slide to keep options open. He also seems to be trying to solve the game and I might be biased towards him as he is one of the few who is toying with scenarios that don't involve me being scum.

On September 29 2016 06:20 Jealous wrote:
So I get to the lab and it's closed due to an emergency, thanks for calling me guys! Love commuting! <3 At least now I can stick around until EoD.


Although I've heard others say it isn't recommended too, I also have had a good experience with doing this in D4. However, I feel that there is a time and place, and this was not it. The broadness of your findings are a testament to this.


Then why are you posting reads that are outdated instead of updating your information?

@Calix: #gotem

On September 29 2016 06:22 DoYouHas wrote:
Is it likely? not really. Dane's aggression on Luna seems pretty genuine.

Is it outside the realm? no. Especially if Stutters is town.

On September 29 2016 06:23 Calix wrote:
How is typing them out two at a time relevant to anything? Is this going anywhere?

I'd rather leave the DYH-answering-questions thing until he's finished with his thoughts. Don't want to distract him too much from saying something first.

On September 29 2016 06:48 Jealous wrote:
I petition that if DYH is scum, and Stutters doesn't vote, that the game ends here and we get all the trophies.

On September 29 2016 06:48 DoYouHas wrote:


Let's be honest here, I'm not turning this train on me around. There is too much information to be gained and too much has happened/not happened to and from me to not go through with the lynch.

So I'm going to put my vote on the person I think is most likely to flip scum. Stutters is possible scum but I still trust my gut reads from early in the game. If I end up being wrong, so be it, but I think Scott is more likely.