Names Are Hard mini mafia - Page 47

Damdred

15669 Posts

June 09 2016 19:31 GMT

#921

I just wasn't here Palmar idk why that makes me an asshole.

Oh well, anyway I will leave a read list in case I die tonight.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

June 09 2016 19:46 GMT

#922

On June 10 2016 03:07 wherebugsgo wrote:
I am like...98% sure VE is scum. Kill him.
95% sure Kelsier is also scum after a couple rereads. Kill him too.

The last one is the most difficult but there's a good chance it's Palmar. If it's not Palmar then probably Tumble. From there down the list who knows, very far down probably LS or Chezinu but I doubt it.

hey bugs I'm not opposed kelsier being scum but I'm no sure why he would be. cam you explain that read to me?

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 19:47 GMT

#923

Damdred, I am paranoid of LS again.

What is it that is making him town again?

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 09 2016 20:15 GMT

#924

I honestly still a bit upset about the events of EoD outing both of our blues and lynching a townie but idk maybe VE is a decent lynch. He hasn't done a whole lot as far I remember and his reaction seemed odd?

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 20:24 GMT

#925

On June 08 2016 23:33 Rels wrote:
Tomahawk is so scum. He got pressured by one guy, took the time to write one bad post to defend himself and OMGUS attack me then went to sleep immediately afterwards without doing anything else. Again, classical newbie scum. Everything he does is newb scum indicative.

Show nested quote +

On June 08 2016 14:27 Kwahamot wrote:

On June 08 2016 07:06 Rels wrote:

On June 08 2016 07:02 Shapelog wrote:
Moving on

On June 07 2016 12:46 Kwahamot wrote:
Hey guys, this is an introduction. Excited to play with you all!

Anyways Day 1 is really annoying cause I don't have the experience to have reads on all you guys from fluffy posts but I'm leaning town on Shapelog and sicklucker.

Shapelog because he dictated the pace of the game so far. And for sicklucker, I can understand his thought process in calling out Shapelog but so far it's hard to make a good case but it's only been 6 hours.

What Introduction? Or is the introduction "Excited to play with you all!"?

anyways,

First off, how much mafia experience do you have? I just want to know. As of making reads (and catching scum) look at the numerous guides in the forum. They give a nice outline on what to do, even if they are a bit out of date.

So moving onto my second question, is anyone standing out to you for any reason at all?

+ Show Spoiler [funny point] +

it's hard to make a good case but it's only been 6 hours

Funny enough, this is exactly (or close too) what SL said.

##Vote Kwahamot
Prepared first post shows a difficulty to enter the thread.
The "newbie" excuse is typical of newbie scum.
Random reads are random and are looking like he wanted to fill up his post with "serious" stuff.

Well how should I put this.. This is a response post! Responding to both Shapelog's original response and Rels' claim.

I just wanted to bless the thread with some dry humor. The introduction is the introduction. I made that post and prepared it and I'm making this post right now because I've had a busy start to the game and I wanted to get my thoughts down in one go but I'll address my small portions of inactivity next time.

I've briefly skimmed the analysis pinned to be able to make a few day 1 calls. The "excuse" was to put things into perspective perhaps some of you guys expect me to immediately fit like a puzzle into this game. I don't think my reads were all that random by the way and I don't think I'd be helping if I talked about the weather as opposed to my "serious" stuff. At least we're talking about me now right? I think the facilitation of discussion makes your case of being town much stronger actually.

On June 08 2016 07:21 Rels wrote:

On June 08 2016 07:17 Koshi wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:36 Rels wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:34 Shapelog wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:32 Rels wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:31 Shapelog wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:29 Rels wrote:

On June 07 2016 06:26 Shapelog wrote:
[quote]
That's nice,

Why don't we talk so I can gather a read on you, and you can stop me spamming?

Is it a serious offer ?

Yes. I'm serious.
I find your lack of faith most disturbing.

Then yes please

Anything stick out to you? I know it's super early, but wonder if you spot anything.

Ls is likely town
Ksc is maybe town for seeing this right now

this one. always more likely a townie makes a posts in which he townreads somebody for thinking the same. just looks like a solid post.

I was reluctant to comply to your demands but because you are doing things I did as a token of good will. Now that I did it and saw how brilliant my read is I am even happy I did it.

PS: your read on kawadude is premature so don't push it too hard because it could very well be completely wrong.

Brillant indeed p:
My read on tomhahawk might be early but it is quite good. First posts are very revelative for newbies

On to my main point and the overdue response to Shapelog, Rels, I believe you are reading backwards. Although I did claim that I don't have the experience to read you guys in the game, I never said I was a newbie and I think you would be fishing a little bit.

But just after in your post you say "amount of mafia experience? well some amount I guess mostly offline. I lurked a few threads but never really followed one actively", so you're a newbie correct ?

Show nested quote +

I thought you just said "I think the facilitation of discussion makes your case of being town much stronger actually." ?

I actually wished I saw this, Becuase the bold was the only part I understood.

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 20:25 GMT

#926

Wait, last sentance.

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 20:28 GMT

#927

On June 10 2016 05:15 LightningStrike wrote:
I honestly still a bit upset about the events of EoD outing both of our blues and lynching a townie but idk maybe VE is a decent lynch. He hasn't done a whole lot as far I remember and his reaction seemed odd?

Why don't you check and see?

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 09 2016 20:44 GMT

#928

On June 10 2016 05:28 Shapelog wrote:

Show nested quote +

Why don't you check and see?

He haven't done much in terms of pushing but his reaction oh I missed lynch seemed forced to me. Plus his palmar read flipping 180 seemed odd too because palmar haven't posted between his scumread on him and then saying he's town. Just very odd it could make him scum.

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 09 2016 20:46 GMT

#929

Or at least palmar didn't post much or not at all between those timing.

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

June 09 2016 20:53 GMT

#930

hum might wanna hurry up with that read list dandred. also one on ls. I think the way i town read ls is by how annoying hes being. and hes being really fucking annoying

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

June 09 2016 20:53 GMT

#931

oh wait no that was rstoulin

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 09 2016 20:54 GMT

#932

On June 10 2016 05:53 sicklucker wrote:
oh wait no that was rstoulin

Jesus you confusing me with Tina how sad can that be

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

June 09 2016 20:56 GMT

#933

Just to tell you how upset I was about the EoD stuff: I pretty decided to just focus on leveling up my agility on old school runescape to calm myself down and if any of you had lpayed runescape at all you know how long and boring agility is to level upcurrently half way to 60 agility started from 56 last night).

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

June 09 2016 20:56 GMT

#934

I dont think rels pushing the newb with conviction is townie koshi.

1. He was arguing over 1 post. The rest of the posts he looked good for were about calling me stupid which is easy to do when you think im stupid
2. he got his lynch
3. he was wrong and got an easy mislynch

This is literraly how rels plays mafia. GOing back to my first game with rels where we were mafia together he was very good at yelling at town and looking townie. Even I was confused

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

June 09 2016 20:57 GMT

#935

Well lets see who dies

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 20:57 GMT

#936

Shapelog's reads. WGB and SL most likely will not get done due to time. Are in right spot thou

Confirm town (unless CC)

Damdred, pretty self explanatory.

Towny boys

Koshi, Breaking the promise to not be emotional seems to be his town meta now a days

Town leans

LS, While I think he is town now, to ever one still alive by day 3, relook at him. I am kinda still a bit paranoid from Cell about him, and by day 3 it should be obvlouis what alignment he is.

I am mostly sheeping other people on this one. I am getting a iffy feeling from reading some of his EoD posts, but I might just be biased,

Tumble: If I had to say anything off of the bat, is that if he is scum, he is prob. going to very activity and eager to play scum, due to his want of a scum meta. Also Pay very close attention if he starts, for any reason, quoting any scum games of his in a defense.

This is mainly because
A) the games are old,
B) he as scum would quote it since it will give him prob. a instant town read, due to activity points alone.
C) He told me (as town) to not use them in another game, for exactly point A.

IF you do meta Tumble, do also note he is becoming increasingly more posty as town.

However, that is it for meta. I am afraid no one really knows what he will do as scum, because he hasn't really rolled scum ever since his first game (he replaced one time, but it was for a game deciding lynch)

He's beening cocky, which is what he usually acts like as town.

Moving into posts in this game from him

I actually found the reason why he was with Palmar's unexplained reads and I can buy it. It isn't the greatest, but it is ok explanation.

His read on Damdred was as follow:
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 08 2016 11:05 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

copying that thing kelsier said, why do you care about my damdred scumread more than my you scumread

re: damdred read
feels
re: palmar read
I agree with him so clearly he's leading us to the d1 scum lynch
also feels

On June 09 2016 03:49 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

damdred I can't believe you'd ever sheep koshi to hit scum
isn't palmar your designated shepherd

On June 09 2016 03:50 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

damdred wtf are you doing
- deciding to sheep rels
- not going after either of his solid scumreads
- voting me, town god, of all people

Which kinda was weak compared to everyone else's read at the time (most people, including me, had him as sus due to the jokeness, how he was acting, his posts etc.) but eh, it was on his catch up.

Palmar read has moved from lightly green to Null. fine on that. I thought the read was stronger than that, but Palmar was just barely on his town section in his list post.

Nothing else really stands out from him to me other than,

On June 09 2016 10:41 Tumblewood wrote:
wow mafia is really easy and I'm really good

Which i am going to laugh if he is scum, and this was him showing off.

Right now, Town lean. Will relook after if I can.

Rels:
Shitfight + certain posts + Sheep. Going to look at scum meta if I have time for some things. For now sheeping.

Null (no order)

Palmar: His latest posts are ok, and are actually the best posts I ever saw from him in any games I played with him. Depending on posting, might or not be lynch tomorrow.

Chez (would kill btw): Chez is.....Mixed. Chez (i am guessing) came to the same conclusion me and Rels did about Kwah early on, but that is all I really have been able to make out on Chez.

Ways to improve Chez: Tar and feather his arse and make dance around as a chicken for town's enjoyment.
Ways to improve Chez's read: RnR

SL:
Need to read more of filter and ponder, cannot due to time

WBG: Maybe should be town lean region. Case on me was decent, tho some of it was off. HE has rebounded from what I thought of him eariler, and his style seems to be pick 1 person, work on them.(mostly)

Need to read more of filter and ponder, cannot due to time

Scum
Kel: Was liking him till he dispersed. I actually have a really big problem with the post right after the lynch,

On June 09 2016 06:05 KelsierSC wrote:
I thought I had an hour , apologies to all players and host

Alright I am sorry. Ok, the post it self isn't the prob. but it is the timing of the post that bother's me the most.

This is 5 mins after deadline, Kel thought he had a hour after the deadline for what he thought was the deadline. Now, you would think he would be able to spend some time in the thread just catching up, or posting or what not. But his next post is 13 hours later.

On June 09 2016 18:45 KelsierSC wrote:
Not going to be able to do anything today.

I'll be able to give more input tomorrow.

My problem here is that, IMO, he should of at least been on for a while and been able to comment on some things (anything) about the lynch or what not because he thought the dead line was a hour later, and thus would be on during (or at least a part of) said thought dead line.

Ik that is kinda nickpicky, but he abstance is kinda questionable.

Other than that, Koshi really picked apart the reason's I liked him. Could def. be scum

VE: I just filtered him, and It actually might be unlikely that him and Kel would be a team. Due to how he was actually quick to call Kel scum.

On June 08 2016 08:00 VisceraEyes wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't really know what Palmar has done frequently as town, though I think he HAS done it as town in recent games I've played with him. It's not enough for me to say I think he's mafia for it, that's for sure. I'd expect more of an agenda actually.

I'm now willing to add Shapelog to the townpile and Koshi probably too, though I disagree with his read on Kelsier. I still like killing Kelsier right now, though some of the more potent lurkers are totally gaining on him for my ire.

The thing I don't like about Kelsier is how he went from joking around to super srs in one post. Like it's around a period of no one really socializing and everyone kinda getting to business (at least that's what I remember from last night's skim) and what he's posted today hasn't really done much for me the way it has Koshi. Not really sure what's smart about what Kelsier has said that Koshi likes.

Anyway, that's what I gots people. Still voting for Kelsier, until the shenannies start happening and people start making actual reasoned accusations. Mine is feels. Deals wit it.

However, that Idea was dropped and never picked up ever again so it actually isn't as strong as I thought. He actually did town read Kel so nvm.

His other Scum candidate was TW, and I actually do not like the reasoning looking back.

On June 08 2016 16:43 VisceraEyes wrote:

Show nested quote +

Like how has Palmar done any more than me? Seriously though, I've given reads on people, explained them to the best of my ability AND been able to answer questions (mostly, I hear ya Bugs)

That fact alone makes me suspect that ALL of these reads are fabricated and meaningless.

##Vote: Tumblewood

Reads OMGUS off towards me, quite ironic also that Tumble's read on Palmar was feels + same reads, and VE wanted to read off of feels, and VE gets pissed off at Feels read.

It also was kinda misrepresented in a way, because tumble just said that VE didn't do anything of note (memorable) not that he did less than Palmar.

Wasn't here for the ignoring part of the lynch. Was mellow afterwards about claims.

Really do not like him.

Would lynch: Anybody below or in Null, following order of scummyness

Shapelog

United States5185 Posts

June 09 2016 20:59 GMT

#937

On June 10 2016 05:56 LightningStrike wrote:
Just to tell you how upset I was about the EoD stuff: I pretty decided to just focus on leveling up my agility on old school runescape to calm myself down and if any of you had lpayed runescape at all you know how long and boring agility is to level upcurrently half way to 60 agility started from 56 last night).

Lookes like your upsetness was
*puts glasses on*
Runed