Pick Your Power: Intriguing

On January 13 2016 23:15 Half the Sky wrote:
Welcome back Superbia <3

And you resolved to not be waffleboy after Dark Tournament hehe xD

On January 19 2016 08:54 Onegu wrote:
1.1 is mine. I have surgery and wont be around to change the numbers. So get off it.

On January 19 2016 09:20 Koshi wrote:
4 mafia? Why not go for 7? They got 2 kp and some roles they can use. medic is always stronger in mafia hands in a setup like this anyway.

tbh. It is maybe fair if there are more mafia in this game. Just more fun to play such a big themed game if you can coordinate.

Fuck me. I am going to see if there is a role that can make a QT and I will make my own mafia faction.

On January 19 2016 09:28 Koshi wrote:

I hope you got me as scum. Otherwise you are already 50% wrong.

On January 19 2016 09:48 Keirathi wrote:
Kita: I had Watson as one of the more powerful roles. At least medium tier? Doc with the upside of getting all the cop checks when moriarty or holmes dies assuming they breadcrumbed.

On January 19 2016 09:56 Keirathi wrote:

Wat.

Why would he claim day 2? Yea, it can tell sherlock/moriarty their sanity, but it also denies him the chance to save more people and the sanity information can always be given out later or even after one or both of the others dies.

It's a really strong role. No need to neuter it on day 2 for no reason :\

On January 19 2016 09:54 Koshi wrote:
Maybe it is better to distribute roles based on picks tbh. Dreamflower should never be picked as town. It is not good enough imo and mafia will NEVER pick it. If somebody picks it he is auto town

On January 20 2016 02:02 CopCake wrote:
Sorry for not being super active :/ I found out on monday I had a new project which is I wanted to be out but I feel it would be pretty disrespectful to just leave like that.

I promise that when I get out of work I will do my best!

On January 20 2016 02:13 sicklucker wrote:


your right palmar is probably scum but im a nice guy

On January 20 2016 02:23 Damdred wrote:
Super why the postering on dreamflowet and then backing out?

On January 20 2016 02:21 Keirathi wrote:

He literally hasn't said anything except what numbers he was picking and that he was going to shoot me if I pick 1,1 with him.

I don't trust him enough to give him 1,1 for free, but I'm curious if he'll have the cojones to actually shoot me.

On January 20 2016 02:27 sicklucker wrote:


cannot compute

On January 20 2016 02:34 Damdred wrote:
Well

atleadt I think SL is town now.

Kei is basically confirmed town though

On January 20 2016 02:36 sicklucker wrote:


if you pick a role thats already been picked you become vt. its not my first rodeo

On January 20 2016 02:37 Rels wrote:

No read the OP again
Probably means you're town (=

On January 20 2016 02:40 Rels wrote:

Again, dumbtells almost always comes from townies

On January 20 2016 02:47 Damdred wrote:
Its half and half for SL dumbtells are a thing though.

Kei
Rels
Suoer
Geript
Koshi
SL
tt to a lesser extent

are my town pool currently the rest haven't caused me to remember them

On January 20 2016 04:25 Rels wrote:

Superbia why did you say dumbtelling is not town indicative for SL here ?



Damdred same question concernening this post ?

On January 20 2016 09:09 Palmar wrote:
Everyone above me needs to claim the role they're taking.

On January 20 2016 09:20 Palmar wrote:

??

On January 20 2016 09:22 Palmar wrote:

this always happens

On January 20 2016 09:26 Palmar wrote:

Do you have anything to back that up because I really cba playing around dumb suspicions this game.

On January 20 2016 09:32 Palmar wrote:

yeah please don't apply some dumb expectations to me, I play in huge amount of variety of ways all the way from completely inactive to super active, from trolling to serious.

I can be meta read, but only by looking at why and how I'm doing the things I'm doing, not what I am doing.

This game I'm trying to organize town I think. That feels like a thing I want to do now.

On January 20 2016 09:28 Palmar wrote:


The following players need to be assigned roles due to alignment:

ceph
vivax
disfo
fecal
alot
vayne
shining
glowingbear

On January 20 2016 09:39 Palmar wrote:
are faction kp roleblockable?

On January 20 2016 09:38 Superbia wrote:
Maybe add +breshke and +copcake to the list.

On January 20 2016 09:40 Breshke wrote:


hmm?

On January 20 2016 09:42 Palmar wrote:
I don't really want you picking dreamflower superbia

On January 20 2016 09:44 Breshke wrote:


Why?

On January 20 2016 09:49 Palmar wrote:
How certain are we keirathi is town? (I'm going to filter him right now, answer while I do it pls).

On January 20 2016 09:51 Breshke wrote:


No I didn't even remember any of alots posts until I just went and looked then.

However why does mafia VA use his pick to overlap with someone and announces it to the thread.

On January 20 2016 09:57 Fecalfeast wrote:

mnehh I don't know how much I trust you thinking you can read me that easily still

On January 20 2016 22:13 Palmar wrote:
The guy who makes the mayor election seems like a good role too, it helps protect town leaders etc.

On January 20 2016 22:17 Rels wrote:

Hehe p: I like that idea. kita and keir are probably town though, kita for helping with the tier list, and keir for tryharding; neither of which scum wants to do, 'cause they're likely NK now.

On January 20 2016 22:17 Rels wrote:
Superbia what do you think of Breshke ?

On January 20 2016 22:17 Superbia wrote:


Yeah but if they KP gambler other investigative/KP/Prot roles are fine.

On January 20 2016 22:19 Superbia wrote:


safe*

On January 20 2016 23:34 kitaman27 wrote:
Since Dr. Sy N. Tist seems to be flying under the radar I've decided to go with him at 10 so nobody overlap with me please. Tracker that can do other stuff is pretty useful, especially with the mafia kp working the way they do. Thank you kindly :D

On January 20 2016 23:41 Superbia wrote:


Good. You are 100% Spybotting n1 then. This also frames everyone so alignments will be inversed (I believe).

Moreover I'm not sold on giving Breshke the Watson role. There's more than enough bullshit roles that can invert alignments or targets (dr sy n tist being one of them) so blame can always be shifted. Regardless of breshke's actual alignment. Watson needs to be 99% reliable.

On January 20 2016 23:44 kitaman27 wrote:


yep yep, I'll also claim during the night if I do choose to frame and then I'll show up on any watchers and stuff (I'm assuming I visit every player) to confirm no tomfoolery.

On January 20 2016 22:09 Superbia wrote:
Yo real quick before I get back to work:

Gambler is the most hilarious badass role ever that we need to have in the game. Here's the plan:

1. Give gambler to some midling town-lean like kita/obi or maybe keir.
2. We pick a list of 2-3 possible mafia/lurk/bad-town that are not primary lynch candidates for d1 (like Vivax/Alot/Breshke or something, lots to pick from tbh).
2.5) Gambler RNGs a target within this list.
3. We will force these 2 or 3 to vote outside of the primary wagons.
4. The entire list is forced to either: a) Play good town (if they're town) or b) Bus their partners (if they're mafia) due to how the role works (if they vote for mafia they live and we know who was mafia after gambler claims their target, or they die).

On January 20 2016 23:51 kitaman27 wrote:


This seems solid. For number three, I think it is important that we tell them exactly who to pick. If we leave it up to them then they can pick a townie of their choice to kill and try to justify it. Since those 2-3 players don't know if they were actually targeted, they can't move their vote off a mafia at end of day if they know they're caught.

Another option we have is to force the strongest scum suspect to be the gambler. If town feels that the gambler is still mafia by the end of day one, we force the gambler target to vote for the gambler, killing them both. Otherwise, we pick the target for the gambler voter. If either player refuses to follow through, we policy lynch since the final vote count will show the +0 and +2. I think I kinda like my version better. Thoughts?

On January 20 2016 10:10 Palmar wrote:
1. Keirathi - Protective or investigative.
2. Superbia - CPRDoc
3. ObiWanShinobi - Investigative
4. Rels - Investigative or KP.
5. Palmar - Investigative or protective.
6. geript - Hardest time deciding tbh. I think investigative.
7. Breshke - Straight up protective, Doctor would be great.
8. Koshi - Protective or investigative. No shennanie weird role. Straight up something like Kitaman27 to check for a scummy role.
9. Cephiro - One of my primary lynch atm so don't really want to waste dreamflower.
10. kitaman27 - Don't mind him picking dr. sy n. tist as long as he always uses his spybot d1. No excuses/questions.
11. Vivax - prime dreamflower target else something that absolutely cannot hurt town.
12. Tictock - Gambler targeting 11/15/16/17/18/19/22 (and who is not dreamflower).
13. disformation - prot mayb investigative
14. Fecalfeast - prot
15. Damdred - prot
16. AlotSomuch - One of my primary lynch atm so don't really want to waste dreamflower.
17. VayneAuthority - One of my primary lynch atm so don't really want to waste dreamflower.
18. The Shining - check/maybe dreamflower
19. Onegu - check/maybe prot
20. Sicklucker - Investigative.
21. Copcake - check/maybe prot
22. GlowingBear - prot/maybe dreamflower

On January 21 2016 03:23 Koshi wrote:
These are all the roles I would probably enjoy. I want do not want to be given 1 role but a selection of many roles with many people. Some roles really suck if mafia knows that I got them.

Hero
Dr. Sy N. Tist (to not use it, and I might die early, anybody who dies early should take this I guess)
Sherlock Holmes
Professor Moriarty
Captain Malcolm Reynolds
Dr. House
Werner Von Braun
Dimensional Lemming
Ezio Auditorie
Tommy the Fireman
The Arrow

On January 21 2016 08:09 Palmar wrote:

Because I trust him more than other people.

He'll shoot whoever I tell him to.

On January 21 2016 08:16 Fecalfeast wrote:
I'd rather be cooperative than get a gun but I do want a gun lol

On January 21 2016 08:19 Palmar wrote:
Also CPR doc is not a strictly town role. It's fantastic for mafia )))

On January 21 2016 08:41 Damdred wrote:
Nope I have my role picked in either lynch me or suffer the consequences for the fear mongering

On January 21 2016 08:46 kitaman27 wrote:






Who here thinks these three statements could possibly follow a logical sequence from a town Palmar? It's impossible.

EBWOP the second quote should be under palmar's name not mine.

On January 21 2016 08:46 kitaman27 wrote:
super, does what I'm saying make sense to you?

On January 21 2016 08:52 kitaman27 wrote:


Pick 8, 10, and 15 should not be thrown away simply to verify that a player picked their roles.

I suggested they be replaced by three very powerful roles that include watching abilities, parity cop, tracking, and protection. Then Palmar calls me mafia for "undermining his plan". It's so illogical that it's ridiculous.

On January 21 2016 08:54 Palmar wrote:
I should just stick with my earlier plan of picking puppeteer so I have someone friendly and smart to talk to.

On January 21 2016 09:20 disformation wrote:
It appears to be that Mr. Holmes judgment has been become clouded due to increased stress during the previous days.
+ Show Spoiler +

Should I reveal my medical notes on Professor Moriarty as, well?

On January 22 2016 02:05 GlowingBear wrote:


Why?

On January 22 2016 02:22 disformation wrote:
Well, someone has moriarity cause I got his sanity (or lack thereof).

On January 22 2016 02:22 GlowingBear wrote:


I didn't

On January 22 2016 02:21 kitaman27 wrote:


I've asked three or four times now for a response while being ignored, which probably points to yes. Out reads are pretty close though, so maybe I'm focusing too much on the single "undermined my plan" post from him. If he is town, he will probably be dead soon anyways so ideally it gets fixed by itself, but there is a high percentage chance that I alignment check him tonight.

On January 22 2016 02:31 JudgeJudy wrote:


Would you mind pointing me to the post you are refering to? I'm not seeing any list that includes Moriarty in Palmar's filter aside from the "plan", which you claim to have not seen.

On January 22 2016 06:47 sicklucker wrote:
Actually I was thinking of making some plays with my claim by claiming tommy the fireman or something(my original choice)
but If i die or something we would lose this valuable information so ill just hard claim my role now.

Im a mysterious challenged (acualy a nice role I was not lying about that)

I checked Knight Artorias, the Abysswalker he is in play mafia has him

On January 22 2016 06:52 sicklucker wrote:
Then why are you guys yelling at me? Im the most clearly town read player in the game. Even in palmars plan I had permission to do whatever I liked. I considered faking a role that absorbs kp so I didnt get nked. But I didnt even do that..

On January 22 2016 06:54 Rels wrote:
OK. Alot claimed to have kita. We let him use it, if he lies about it we kill him. Simple.
We need to track roleblockers to be sure they're not blocking him if we're doing that, so he cannot lie about that.

On January 22 2016 06:58 sicklucker wrote:


tt claimed... like 1 page ago

On January 22 2016 07:08 Rels wrote:

Yep. So let's just say trackers should track roleblockers / watchers should watch alot. No more precision, there cannot be a million busdrivers.

On January 22 2016 07:28 AlotSomuch wrote:
Oh. No I hadn't caught up all the way yet. My understanding of my role is it is a one use, cannot be bus-driven, if I pick abysswalker I will be told who has the role unless I am killed or roleblocked. So a watcher on me would net us a scum in any situation, wouldn't it?

On January 22 2016 07:32 Cephiro wrote:
I'm also willing to work with both and/or only one mafia to eliminate you evenly or one-sidedly.

Feel free to rat your buddies.

On January 22 2016 07:34 sicklucker wrote:


what story?

On January 22 2016 07:36 sicklucker wrote:
so basically im the mayor tormorow and i pick the lynch because no ones dumb enough to vote me (i hope). So because of this I wont be talking about my reads too much to avoid roleblocks

On January 22 2016 07:37 Rels wrote:

(=
If you're scum I'm going to be really mad.

On January 22 2016 07:38 Rels wrote:

Cool. That's 1 mysterious challenger role claimed, and it's a easily verifyable power.

On January 22 2016 07:41 CopCake wrote:



This is so confusing

what do you mean with "other team" ?

On January 22 2016 07:42 sicklucker wrote:
ill do as i see fit. also your being so bad for forcing me to claim. theres 4 other c who didnt claim yet now they cant acidently choose y role.


SOOO SOO BAD im salty asaik

On January 22 2016 07:44 CopCake wrote:


No I mean, you are sure that a mafia team has that power

why?

On January 22 2016 07:44 sicklucker wrote:
in because i challenge super to a duel

On January 22 2016 07:48 Rels wrote:
Alright gonna play one game of HOTS then sleep. Make TT answer my question pretty please if he is not back before I leave

On January 22 2016 07:48 Superbia wrote:
Also copcake what Challenger role did you get?

On January 22 2016 07:59 Fecalfeast wrote:

alot's thought proccess

why?

On January 22 2016 08:01 kitaman27 wrote:
If someone ended up with Pick their Power Picker from Mysterious Challenger, they should totally grab the gambler by the way.

On January 22 2016 08:17 CopCake wrote:
Do I really have to claim sup?

On January 22 2016 08:18 Fecalfeast wrote:

Well if you think about it all the way through like that... I'm not really thinking about teams tbh it's all scum to me

On January 22 2016 08:36 AlotSomuch wrote:


So... I have my suspicion, but I want you to elaborate on why you don't think it's worth using a watcher to find out whether (A) I am scum (B) finding scum who try to roleblock me or (C) find out which scum took the dang busdriver role?

On January 22 2016 08:59 AlotSomuch wrote:
Actually a very different reasoning than I was expecting; I thought you were going to go with a "other people are more valuable" part of it, and I was going to counter that at this point my result is a guaranteed scum or I am, because there is 0 town reason to take that role, so either a scum took it, I lie about my result in which case I am scum, or SL(I think?) lied about it already being taken, in which case he is scum. There is no such guarantee that our cops (assuming they aren't mafia themselves) will actually find scum today or tomorrow or before they are killed. I do see what you are saying about only having to worry about 3 possible people that would want to block it though. I find it a little weird your lack of interest in a guaranteed scum find though in favor of maybes...

On January 22 2016 09:21 AlotSomuch wrote:
Actually, If all actions used on me are driven...then they'd role block/kill who ever the watcher was moved to. And the watcher would see it.

On January 22 2016 09:28 CopCake wrote:
I have played with alot before and I think it is pretty obvious because I said "You are my fave" and posted a pic with pandas.

On January 23 2016 00:28 kitaman27 wrote:
Dimensional Lemming
"You may not knowingly cause there to be a majority of mafia players in either the main game thread or the new game thread."

I wonder if we can use this as like a pseudo dt check if we include Vivax and two of the scummiest players.

On January 23 2016 08:16 sicklucker wrote:
so who do I kill tomorrow im taking suggestions

On January 24 2016 08:49 VayneAuthority wrote:


why do you think mafia stacked with you 0o and why did you shoot me in the first place lol

On January 24 2016 08:51 Palmar wrote:
do we want to kill VA?