What's the point of blindly trusting thread instead of pushing any of your own reads that others share.

Or you obviously got up to the point in the thread where I had my case, or you were lurking and saw me push you. So you wasted your time instead of catching up.

so yesh

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 19 2015 20:45 GMT

#749

On October 20 2015 05:36 KelsierSC wrote:

Show nested quote +

I guess I would like some kind of concise and clear train of thought that makes this happen.

So you don't really play the game to start with then you say you managed to catch up with the whole thread. After that you say shining is scum for his opening post and ff is scum for giving his list of reads. Then you decide that I was the biggest scum of the game but rather than actually having a reason you then go and dig back through my filter trying to find things to call me scummy for, you take almost each post I do and call me mafia, which you now admit were all bad reasons. After I dispute all those reasons you just disappear. But this was all an attempt to make it seem like you were contributing?

You don't say anything about moosy even though he was the biggest spammer who you didnt't like.

You then return around deadline time to shove a vote on scott.

Perhaps you can see why i'm "confused" and i'd probably ask why I shouldn't lynch you.

hey look...its like you read my case!

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 18:40 GMT

#788

Hi I should probably put together a list in case I die or something.

I feel like several things still indicate that ever since is scum, the way the votes piled on town Scott makes it seem a bit strange. The promise of activity but almost none since along with some associative things heavily shows that ever is scum.

If we have a vigilante I would shoot eversonce for information on how wagons were formed and why people went where.

Lone probably looks the absolute worst out of everything yesterday. He asks me to explain my case because he's considering it and just throws a vote with a stupid reason and afks(?) that's just not town behavior at all.

SL and moos are probably the most likely in the third position. I'm leaning more towards moos because of his misrepresentation of the case on ever since and going along with boxer instead of pushing anything else. And then just not being helpful at all to town after that.

Sl still has a chance with a wasted vote, but I don't think that's as telling as others do.

If I die in pretty sure that shining is town and shouldn't be lynched. Kelsier is town even if I'm annoyed at him for not going with the stronger case during the night.

Rels I think is town as well, the way he pushed his case makes me feel that way.

Be back around deadline if anyone has any questions.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 20:03 GMT

#811

Lm wasn't a bad shot at all good ml target taken off the board.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 20:54 GMT

#886

So I think sl is probably town no matter what as well as rels.

So that makes things a little easier one sec.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 21:16 GMT

#893

To me there's a really small pool we have to pick from,

Vonthin
Moos
Ever
GB
Boxer
FF
Shining

I pretty much hard town read shining, while some say he's not emotional there seems to be some emotion in his posts even if hes not angry. He seem happy at points and jokes, anger should be put out of discussion since I know he's trying to stop raging. Also his catch up posts I liked and he cared about ever not answering him. I only see town in him really.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 21:28 GMT

#900

Hit enter to soon I'll finish up

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 21:37 GMT

#903

So that leaves me with a pool of six people and three of them are scum.

Gb is the next person I would eliminate from the lynch list. She has been looking for scum it seems, initially it looks like she is also trying to get me to look at alternatives when early when I was interacting about moos. Some of it I disagree with but her reaction to ff voting Scott was interesting as scum has little motivation to jump on and off if Scott is scum.

This leaves us with a lynch pool of ever, Vonthin, fecal, boxer, moos.

This is where the game gets really difficult for me.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 21:46 GMT

#904

Tired of sending stuff in to early.

The easiest answer is von is the disinterested scum at this juncture with how he came in voted left little on the table and seems to not care. But this could come just as easily from town it seems (lonemeow) as it could from scum. So I would probably suggest not lynching von today and looking elsewhere. However if von is scum it's highly probable that eversince is town.

The second easiest thing (and what I think we should do) is lynch moos. He didn't really care who got lynched yesterday as evidenced by not really pushing his preference of boxer past a point and then saying well I'll just sheep onto Scott who his top scum read was in. This is highly suspicious and his other play during the game seems scum indicative and his pushing off of ever will shed light on her alignment if he flips scum.

I've said plenty about ever before now so just read my case. But there is a direct possibility that it was a town v town wagon and scum just didn't care where votes went.

I'm not sure about fecal or boxer I have t read more.

But that's where I am atm

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 20 2015 22:41 GMT

#908

Its worth mentioning that ever could be town here as well.

If we had two wagons that were led by town it is highly likely mafia didn't care where votes fell. Which could be the case with lone being the hammer vote basically on Scott.

I have to think a hit about it. But it's worth considering...

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 21 2015 01:21 GMT

#912

I'm not really town reading ever since I just think its worth considering and looking at the reason the vote d1 felt so apathetic was because both wagons were town.

Ever can still be scum and I think has a decent chance of flipping but moos probably has the best chance st this point.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 21 2015 04:09 GMT

#921

So von and sicklucker are super dumb telling I think is the phase.

Which is sorta good because I want to eliminate von from the pool now.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 21 2015 14:55 GMT

#931

I find it curious that boxer is continuously trying to push doubt on me? This is at least the third or fourth time he has done so.

Anyway those are my read and i'm sticking to them, really sure that shining is town. Less sure about GB but gb isn't worth a lynch today in any case.

Eversince might still be worth a lynch but moos is just the better lynch.

1) He isn't doing anything today at all
2) He voted with his biggest scum read and misrepresented my case for no reason

The lynch list is currently small honestly

On October 20 2015 05:00 Blazinghand wrote:

Day 1 Vote Count

scott31337 (7): KelsierSC, Rels, boxerfred, MoosyDoosy, ~~GlowingBear~~, Fecalfeast, Eversince, Lonemeow
Eversince (5): FarahBlackwing, The Shining, scott31337, Vonthin, GlowingBear
LoneMeow (1): [green]sicklucker[green], ~~boxerfred~~

Not voted (0):

Currently, scott31337 is set to be lynched. Day 1 ends at Monday, Oct 19 8:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00) in .

Voting is mandatory! Voting is done here in this thread. PM the hosts if the vote count is not correct.

Those are my reads i'm going to say that glowingbear does have some interesting things, like the vote/unvote of scott to put them ahead for lynch then moving vote to waste it then back to ever after another vote is on ever.

So in that regard if ever is scum its more likely that GB is scum here.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 21 2015 15:16 GMT

#934

Already have given my reasoning on town reading shining.

And yes this is my first mafia game.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 21 2015 15:24 GMT

#936

After my initial question(about busses) I looked up terms/items to have a better understanding of some things so I didn't clutter the thread and asked questions. That's where I got the terms dumb tells/omgus and a few others.