So moosydoosy claimed mafia unprompted and then glowing bear tries to cover foe it.

That doesn't make any sense I think both of you are mafia now. It makes no sense logically for that to happen.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 17 2015 21:06 GMT

#206

Moos is pretty obvious scum and I don't see any logical point in you trying to joke with him unless you are trying to cover for some form of slip of the tongue.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 17 2015 21:15 GMT

#213

I disagree he has no logical reasoning in that point in the thread to make that sort of joke at all, it came out of no where to a point.

He wasn't promoted and townies should have no reason to claim scum by accident or not. And by your own logic or lack thereof if no mafia would ever claim mafia in the thread then all people who do so would be instantly read town.

So only dumb mafia wouldn't take advantage of that.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 14:36 GMT

#337

Hi, I'm sitting around reading the game and Idk if I should just post things in a list? I'll try that and see how it goes.

I'm pretty convinced at this juncture that lone is town a bit. Or at least worth keeping around for another day. There seems to be some form of curiosity and pushing in the questions that he is asking. And when pointed to the database(great tool btw) it looks remarkably different from the other games where they have rolled scum.

I also now think that glowingbear is more than likely town. She just seems to be trying to help the thread in a decent direction and trying to give her reads in a concise fashion. I think she is town.

I think my no st controversial read here is shining. I think he's town, just from general knowledge and looking at other games (his last scum game especially) the posts don't seem longish/boring and have a flair and really playful. While it's worth noting it's preliminary I think there's a good shot at him being town.

Any questions just ask and I'll try to answer.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 15:19 GMT

#342

I think moos is probably scum I'm not overly confident in that but his filter is pretty useless. The thing that gives me the most pause is his moments talking about the vt claim.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 17:34 GMT

#355

To moosydoosy

I've looked at several of your games over the past little while to attempt to get a hold of where you are and if I'm wrong there are a few things I need you to talk about.

1) in your past town games you generally have a good bit of banter with the rest of the town at points you go against a somewhat thread sentiments early and stick your head out in disagreement against town leaders (rels can fit here). But you lack a hard scum read in your town games early. Why are you so sure so early with no interactions that you generally thrive on.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 17:50 GMT

#364

Why did you dodge the question I asked, its perfectly reasonable. You are way to sure on boxer without much interaction or postng at all. I don't care if you think my idea of you not having hard suck reads is right or wrong answer my question.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:01 GMT

#373

We aren't even 20 pages into a game and you have a rock solid scum read on someone who,has barely posted at all on something that is flimsy at best.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:08 GMT

#383

I've given what reads I have at the moment.

In no way have I said you aren't supposed to have scum reads and trying to color my question in that light is questionable at best.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:18 GMT

#388

You know what you just said doesn't negate anything I've said right?

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:25 GMT

#394

Like I said before the reasoning you are using to hard scum read boxer is flimsy and doesn't lend itself to be as strong as you are making it. Nor is what you are saying negating what I'm saying.

Now I'm,not saying he can't be scum but your reasoning is poor and all I wanted was you to explain why you read him so hard so early when part of your read comes from what's the phrase omgus

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:29 GMT

#395

However I'll end this here and move on.

I think kelsier is,most likely town. If he was scum a good plan would be to let moos and myself spam up the thread when we can't see eye to eye. But he interjects to try to get us back on a different path. I see good town motivation and his dogged questioning and prodding seems to come from town.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 18:36 GMT

#397

Curiosity and wanting to draw people to answer questions typically comes more from town than scum. While it's possible kelsier is playing excellent as scum I understand it's hard to keep up that level of play so I don't see why I should feel less confident in,my read

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 20:13 GMT

#410

On October 19 2015 04:55 Eversince wrote:
Also there is so much wrong with what Fecal just did. Just nooo.

Why not explain a bit more?

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 20:33 GMT

#427

I don't see his questioning of moos to be a fight, at worst it was a cordial misunderstanding at best it was pressure.

And I don't see how basically halfway through today when people are making reads you can call ff out on that? If we were coming up on the eod and he was decrying a lynch I'd agree to an extent but he's clearly giving a read. Albeit one that has little apparent reasoning but one I agree with.

FarahBlackwing

270 Posts

October 18 2015 20:38 GMT

#429

On October 19 2015 04:38 Fecalfeast wrote:
Ksc is town ir I'll eat my hat. Farah seems towny to me but newbs posting at all get on my good side. Not liking sicklucker tbh, he's going to say i always scum him but i feel it for real this time.

Gb is not making me praise him but I'd call him null atm. There was another newbie who posted a shitty list that keeps getting quoted i didn't like that list.

I'm in bed on my phone and don't feel like filtering at all

Town:
Ksc
Fatah

Null
GB

Scum
Sl
The other newb