|
On June 07 2015 14:10 Onegu wrote:+ Show Spoiler +Onegu is another one of those players I can't read well currently. Hes just another policy lynch until he does more things, he can not post much as either alignment but seems to care more as scum but also is more lurky as scum. Sooo just need more time with him. Damdred writes this in his big post. This is after I voted him for no reason. Like if you read my post it just says reasons. Like when ritoky asked me for a filter to read I wrote I rng'd damdred. How does he think I was pushing his lynch at all. Then the only reason he scum reads me is because I didnt push his lynch but voted him. He knows I do this shit all the time. Damdreds reason for scum reading me is complete BS.
So I want to go back to this. You just posted this now.
You are okay with people policy lynching you which Damdred states and then you put Damdred on the scum list?
My issue with that quote is that Damdred says you care more as scum (thus you post more?) but then says you are scum lurker. Which seems contradictory.
If there's another quote that supports this, I get it, but the one you have makes no sense to me.
|
On June 07 2015 14:32 Onegu wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2015 04:31 Shendelzare wrote:
Alright, took more looking at Onegu's filter. Is he trolling or just posting just to post?
Chocolate and Milo being on the same team? really?
Calling Fidei as either blue or scum - why? And why out another blue as town? That really makes no sense when I see no other reason to scumread Fidei from his point of view?
He scumreads VE early on but votes Damdred? That is a jump in logic to me.
Onegu is probably scum.
Moving on to other people... Because here seems to look like you took it serious.
Hence my first line in that quote. I don't think you were trolling at all though with the latter reads I stated - Fidei, VE, Damdred.
|
To add to what I said about Damdred -
My issue with that quote is that Damdred says you care more as scum (thus you post more?) but then says you are scum lurker. Which seems contradictory.
I don't think this alone makes Damdred mafia, but it sounds weird.
|
Oh wait a minute you just said that.
"He knows I do this shit all the time."
Never mind then. That part went over my head.
|
On June 07 2015 14:28 Shendelzare wrote:Chocolate has not explicitly said "policy" or "scum" lynch either way so I could not tell. Show nested quote +On June 07 2015 14:24 Onegu wrote:Onegu seems to have arrived late on the scene but already his posting style is suspicious to me, much too much joking around; while this is normal and understandable at the start of the game, I feel like there is plenty of content to actually address, which he has not done. Can anyone tell me if this is normal posting from Onegu?"
verbal diarrhea which confused me Also I think that was a quote that Choclate used to respond to KS, that was KS's opinion on you I thought, not Chocolates.
I guess does chocolate not know how to format?
Anyway the shit posting post is still his own.
|
Okay, now that is making a little more sense why you don't like Damdred, fine. But what do you think of him after the lynch? He posted some large case or something. Or do you just look at people how they view you and ignore everything else?
|
On June 07 2015 14:37 Shendelzare wrote:
Okay, now that is making a little more sense why you don't like Damdred, fine. But what do you think of him after the lynch? He posted some large case or something. Or do you just look at people how they view you and ignore everything else?
Damdred is capable of making large cases as scum. Him leading the day one lynch is null for him. But yeah for day 2 I am only looking at how people interact with me. Ill read everything and file it away and when there are less players I will go more into other things.
But for now I am confident in the Onegu rule.
|
I looked at the database link ritoky showed me.
Damdred has a decent track record as scum. Particularly a good survivor the later the game goes.
Scott mentioned some "why am I alive" rule. I wonder why it does not seem to apply to him.
|
On June 07 2015 14:42 Onegu wrote:
Damdred is capable of making large cases as scum. Him leading the day one lynch is null for him.
Maybe I need to look into this part more on Damdred. If someone leads a lynch, if he pushed him day one, that's usually a town incident? Assuming he truly believed he had a mafia read? Or was his push on the day one lynch for not great reasons?
I'll look into that if people are worried he's good enough to trick us. I just assume all experience players on this site are good enough around here to play scum, maybe some are better than others though, I don't know.
|
I'm out for a few hours. Gym time and breakfast and that.
|
Just posting this for post-game
Mafia:
Tictock
1 of VE or Onegu
1 of Damdred or Scott
Town:
Kickstart
Ritoky
Nydus
Milo
Sicklucker/shendel
Fidei
Chocolate
|
|
|
I've probably got 1 mafia in my townreads because it's too soon in the game
|
On June 07 2015 15:54 GGTeMpLaR wrote:
Just posting this for post-game
Mafia:
Tictock
1 of VE or Onegu
1 of Damdred or Scott
Town:
Kickstart
Ritoky
Nydus
Milo
Sicklucker/shendel
Fidei
Chocolate
VE and Scott could be mafia because...?
If you already said and I missed it then requote...
|
no thanks I came to play mafia not coach half the game through reading comprehension 500 times.
that was mostly for bragging rights post-game anyways I've had too many bad accusations put against me for pushing on mafia
|
Well as you say if you're wrong on any town I think you're wrong on Chocolate, he looks terrible all around.
Shame that KS didn't claim sooner.
|
shame you guys lynched him when I called him town
now you're lynching me
|
Well to be fair had I actually been around Day 1 I would have switched to Chocolate upon seeing the claim or tried to. KS posting was different but objectively I don't think it made him mafia. From what I read of Day 1 it seemed some people were putting way too much stock on posting style or tone reads and I'm not fully sure if that is just people being bad or mafia.
|
On June 07 2015 16:44 GGTeMpLaR wrote:
shame you guys lynched him when I called him town
now you're lynching me
I think this is the other issue some were having with you. Calling someone town and being right on them doesn't make you town.
Someone being wrong on someone else doesn't make them one alignment or the other.
It's how they get there. I think it was Milo who said you were a video mafia player, right? So maybe that's lost in the way here?
But I think if you can understand why people are getting to where they are on you it might help you sort things out a little better if you are town.
I looked at Tictock's case on you. You are so sure he's mafia. So maybe you can start by showing us the problems in his case on you. Otherwise you'd have to point us in a different direction towards another one of your scumreads.
|
All - just woke up (I'm on UK time). I have to work today, but I'll try to come on at lunch time and answer Scott and Shendel's outstanding questions.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
