|
So, apart from all that:
Breshke is town.
Eden is town.
Marv is town.
LS and batsnacks are probably town.
rsoultin is mafia.
gg
|
On February 08 2015 00:05 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On February 07 2015 22:48 justanothertownie wrote:On February 07 2015 12:45 rsoultin wrote:
^ Like, I have no good reason to believe jat is town, and he should be the lynch, but I keep coming back to that and going meh. I have a reason to not lynch jat. But let's lynch him anyways. Seems legit. On February 07 2015 12:47 Eden1892 wrote:On February 07 2015 12:43 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, so forgive me for going back into WIFOM land, but I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around a scum koshi and a scum jat pushing hard for breshke not to shoot...but no rb and no kill. That just makes no sense to me -_- ...if they have no rb then they would very obviously want us not to shoot. Lol It would be stranger if they were mafia and pushing for Breshke to shoot with no rb. As it is this makes perfect sense. They don't want us shooting so they argue for us not to shoot because that's the only way we don't shoot If I was mafia with Koshi and we had no rb then we would kill Breshke. What kind of nonsense is this?
Interesting how you take my post that actually says I have no good reason to believe you're town and then construe it as I have a good reason not to lynch you. You think it's any more likely for a Koshi/HF team to leave Bresh alive than you and Koshi? It makes no sense for any player in this game to do that! "I keep coming back to that" good reason to townread me. Yes, it is more likely for a Koshi/HF team to do this since it was pretty likely that Breshke would shoot me or Koshi. And yes, it doesn't make much sense for anyone to do this but the only possible explanation I see is that they were gambling on Breshke shooting me.
Give me a good reason to townread you, then. What have you really done all game? I mean, seriously? Cause this NK speculation stuff makes 0 sense for anyone as mafia. I can use that lovely WIFOM to try to clear myself, too. Like, why in the world as mafia would I keep insisting Breshke shoot either me or my scum partner, if we're not going to RB or kill him?
This is nonsense. No mafia team is going to sit around with their thumb up their ass and go 'well, hehe, there's a 50/50 chance breshke shoots town so let's roll the dice and hope he kills jat'. Such a dumb argument.
|
On February 08 2015 00:12 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:05 justanothertownie wrote:On February 08 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On February 07 2015 22:48 justanothertownie wrote:On February 07 2015 12:45 rsoultin wrote:
^ Like, I have no good reason to believe jat is town, and he should be the lynch, but I keep coming back to that and going meh. I have a reason to not lynch jat. But let's lynch him anyways. Seems legit. On February 07 2015 12:47 Eden1892 wrote:On February 07 2015 12:43 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, so forgive me for going back into WIFOM land, but I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around a scum koshi and a scum jat pushing hard for breshke not to shoot...but no rb and no kill. That just makes no sense to me -_- ...if they have no rb then they would very obviously want us not to shoot. Lol It would be stranger if they were mafia and pushing for Breshke to shoot with no rb. As it is this makes perfect sense. They don't want us shooting so they argue for us not to shoot because that's the only way we don't shoot If I was mafia with Koshi and we had no rb then we would kill Breshke. What kind of nonsense is this?
Interesting how you take my post that actually says I have no good reason to believe you're town and then construe it as I have a good reason not to lynch you. You think it's any more likely for a Koshi/HF team to leave Bresh alive than you and Koshi? It makes no sense for any player in this game to do that! "I keep coming back to that" good reason to townread me. Yes, it is more likely for a Koshi/HF team to do this since it was pretty likely that Breshke would shoot me or Koshi. And yes, it doesn't make much sense for anyone to do this but the only possible explanation I see is that they were gambling on Breshke shooting me. Give me a good reason to townread you, then. What have you really done all game? I mean, seriously? Cause this NK speculation stuff makes 0 sense for anyone as mafia. I can use that lovely WIFOM to try to clear myself, too. Like, why in the world as mafia would I keep insisting Breshke shoot either me or my scum partner, if we're not going to RB or kill him? This is nonsense. No mafia team is going to sit around with their thumb up their ass and go 'well, hehe, there's a 50/50 chance breshke shoots town so let's roll the dice and hope he kills jat'. Such a dumb argument.
I love how you just keep attacking me for nonsense but completely ignore the huge case on HF.
|
On February 08 2015 00:14 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:12 rsoultin wrote:On February 08 2015 00:05 justanothertownie wrote:On February 08 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On February 07 2015 22:48 justanothertownie wrote:On February 07 2015 12:45 rsoultin wrote:
^ Like, I have no good reason to believe jat is town, and he should be the lynch, but I keep coming back to that and going meh. I have a reason to not lynch jat. But let's lynch him anyways. Seems legit. On February 07 2015 12:47 Eden1892 wrote:On February 07 2015 12:43 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, so forgive me for going back into WIFOM land, but I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around a scum koshi and a scum jat pushing hard for breshke not to shoot...but no rb and no kill. That just makes no sense to me -_- ...if they have no rb then they would very obviously want us not to shoot. Lol It would be stranger if they were mafia and pushing for Breshke to shoot with no rb. As it is this makes perfect sense. They don't want us shooting so they argue for us not to shoot because that's the only way we don't shoot If I was mafia with Koshi and we had no rb then we would kill Breshke. What kind of nonsense is this?
Interesting how you take my post that actually says I have no good reason to believe you're town and then construe it as I have a good reason not to lynch you. You think it's any more likely for a Koshi/HF team to leave Bresh alive than you and Koshi? It makes no sense for any player in this game to do that! "I keep coming back to that" good reason to townread me. Yes, it is more likely for a Koshi/HF team to do this since it was pretty likely that Breshke would shoot me or Koshi. And yes, it doesn't make much sense for anyone to do this but the only possible explanation I see is that they were gambling on Breshke shooting me. Give me a good reason to townread you, then. What have you really done all game? I mean, seriously? Cause this NK speculation stuff makes 0 sense for anyone as mafia. I can use that lovely WIFOM to try to clear myself, too. Like, why in the world as mafia would I keep insisting Breshke shoot either me or my scum partner, if we're not going to RB or kill him? This is nonsense. No mafia team is going to sit around with their thumb up their ass and go 'well, hehe, there's a 50/50 chance breshke shoots town so let's roll the dice and hope he kills jat'. Such a dumb argument. I love how you just keep attacking me for nonsense but completely ignore the huge case on HF.
You've already responded to my thoughts on your huge "case". Nice try.
All you're even saying is that I was his scumread and he didn't push me at EoD when there were what? Three, four other wagons? That case is so flimsy it's hilarious. Good job making it look huge with all the quotes, though. 
|
On February 08 2015 00:16 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:14 justanothertownie wrote:On February 08 2015 00:12 rsoultin wrote:On February 08 2015 00:05 justanothertownie wrote:On February 08 2015 00:01 rsoultin wrote:On February 07 2015 22:48 justanothertownie wrote:On February 07 2015 12:45 rsoultin wrote:
^ Like, I have no good reason to believe jat is town, and he should be the lynch, but I keep coming back to that and going meh. I have a reason to not lynch jat. But let's lynch him anyways. Seems legit. On February 07 2015 12:47 Eden1892 wrote:On February 07 2015 12:43 rsoultin wrote:
Okay, so forgive me for going back into WIFOM land, but I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around a scum koshi and a scum jat pushing hard for breshke not to shoot...but no rb and no kill. That just makes no sense to me -_- ...if they have no rb then they would very obviously want us not to shoot. Lol It would be stranger if they were mafia and pushing for Breshke to shoot with no rb. As it is this makes perfect sense. They don't want us shooting so they argue for us not to shoot because that's the only way we don't shoot If I was mafia with Koshi and we had no rb then we would kill Breshke. What kind of nonsense is this?
Interesting how you take my post that actually says I have no good reason to believe you're town and then construe it as I have a good reason not to lynch you. You think it's any more likely for a Koshi/HF team to leave Bresh alive than you and Koshi? It makes no sense for any player in this game to do that! "I keep coming back to that" good reason to townread me. Yes, it is more likely for a Koshi/HF team to do this since it was pretty likely that Breshke would shoot me or Koshi. And yes, it doesn't make much sense for anyone to do this but the only possible explanation I see is that they were gambling on Breshke shooting me. Give me a good reason to townread you, then. What have you really done all game? I mean, seriously? Cause this NK speculation stuff makes 0 sense for anyone as mafia. I can use that lovely WIFOM to try to clear myself, too. Like, why in the world as mafia would I keep insisting Breshke shoot either me or my scum partner, if we're not going to RB or kill him? This is nonsense. No mafia team is going to sit around with their thumb up their ass and go 'well, hehe, there's a 50/50 chance breshke shoots town so let's roll the dice and hope he kills jat'. Such a dumb argument. I love how you just keep attacking me for nonsense but completely ignore the huge case on HF. You've already responded to my thoughts on your huge "case". Nice try. All you're even saying is that I was his scumread and he didn't push me at EoD when there were what? Three, four other wagons? That case is so flimsy it's hilarious. Good job making it look huge with all the quotes, though.
"All you're even saying"... lol
HF/rsoultin final answer.
|
|
|
Marv, Eden if you mislynch me when I just gave you the scumteam I will rage at you so hard.
|
Hold on. I didn't see the second part of your case.
|
Okay, jat.
On February 06 2015 07:53 justanothertownie wrote:
Let's just kill SL.
On February 06 2015 07:54 justanothertownie wrote:or maybe Onegu? I don't know 
So what were your much better reasons to kill SL again?
|
This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes.
On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him.
You can also have a look at damdreds case on him.
|
On February 08 2015 00:33 justanothertownie wrote:This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes. Show nested quote +On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. You can also have a look at damdreds case on him.
Sure, I saw that, but I also see Marv (I believe) making the exact same argument for Damdred about pushing SL then not caring where the lynch goes. You don't even mention Onegu again. That says why you voted SL, but not why you had such better reasons to.
And that case Damdred made on him was made the night before. I should know; it's why I went through SL's town games and chose to push SL myself.
|
On February 08 2015 00:45 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:33 justanothertownie wrote:This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes. On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. You can also have a look at damdreds case on him. Sure, I saw that, but I also see Marv (I believe) making the exact same argument for Damdred about pushing SL then not caring where the lynch goes. You don't even mention Onegu again. That says why you voted SL, but not why you had such better reasons to.
And that case Damdred made on him was made the night before. I should know; it's why I went through SL's town games and chose to push SL myself.
What is the bolded even supposed to say? Ridiculous.
So what if marv made that argument about damdred? I didn't think damdred was scum and I also said that multiple times. And wtf does it matter when damdred made his case?
|
On February 08 2015 00:50 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:45 rsoultin wrote:On February 08 2015 00:33 justanothertownie wrote:This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes. On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. You can also have a look at damdreds case on him. Sure, I saw that, but I also see Marv (I believe) making the exact same argument for Damdred about pushing SL then not caring where the lynch goes. You don't even mention Onegu again. That says why you voted SL, but not why you had such better reasons to.
And that case Damdred made on him was made the night before. I should know; it's why I went through SL's town games and chose to push SL myself. What is the bolded even supposed to say? Ridiculous. So what if marv made that argument about damdred? I didn't think damdred was scum and I also said that multiple times. And wtf does it matter when damdred made his case?
You were waffling on SL and Onegu long after Damdred made his case, so that can't be why. Keep up.
|
On February 08 2015 00:51 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:50 justanothertownie wrote:On February 08 2015 00:45 rsoultin wrote:On February 08 2015 00:33 justanothertownie wrote:This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes. On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. You can also have a look at damdreds case on him. Sure, I saw that, but I also see Marv (I believe) making the exact same argument for Damdred about pushing SL then not caring where the lynch goes. You don't even mention Onegu again. That says why you voted SL, but not why you had such better reasons to.
And that case Damdred made on him was made the night before. I should know; it's why I went through SL's town games and chose to push SL myself. What is the bolded even supposed to say? Ridiculous. So what if marv made that argument about damdred? I didn't think damdred was scum and I also said that multiple times. And wtf does it matter when damdred made his case? You were waffling on SL and Onegu long after Damdred made his case, so that can't be why. Keep up.
This post makes no sense.
|
On February 07 2015 23:51 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 06 2015 08:51 Holyflare wrote:
pretty sure a town jat would have switched to onegu when I was pushing for it Then we have this reasoning for scumreading me which makes no sense in the first place since I had more reasons to scumread SL than Onegu but even if we ignore this - why would I as scum make myself look bad by not following town marv and HF around (which I have done as scum before) if all lynch targets are town anyways and I could just switch as often as I want?
I asked you why you had so many more reasons to pursue the SL lynch, and you tell me to look at Damdred's case? When well after he posted his case you clearly weren't sure on whether the lynch should be SL or Onegu?
This really isn't that hard to follow, jat -_-
|
On February 08 2015 00:57 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2015 23:51 justanothertownie wrote:On February 06 2015 08:51 Holyflare wrote:
pretty sure a town jat would have switched to onegu when I was pushing for it Then we have this reasoning for scumreading me which makes no sense in the first place since I had more reasons to scumread SL than Onegu but even if we ignore this - why would I as scum make myself look bad by not following town marv and HF around (which I have done as scum before) if all lynch targets are town anyways and I could just switch as often as I want? I asked you why you had so many more reasons to pursue the SL lynch, and you tell me to look at Damdred's case? When well after he posted his case you clearly weren't sure on whether the lynch should be SL or Onegu? This really isn't that hard to follow, jat -_-
It makes 0 sense. Damdred posted a case. There are reasons to lynch SL in that case. SL acts extremely scummy at eod. I decided that I have more reasons to lynch him than Onegu. It does not matter in the slightest if Damdred posted his case right at deadline or a hundred years ago.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
##Unvote
##Vote: Holyflare
let's make it interesting
NB: all this does is reflect my vast uncertainty. Will probably make an informed decision when I get round to reading Koshi meta and deciding about rsoultin.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
I kinda agree with jat, i don't think a jat/bats team makes that much sense to me. dunno, we got over a day, so a lot of time to muse on it
|
On February 08 2015 00:50 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2015 00:45 rsoultin wrote:On February 08 2015 00:33 justanothertownie wrote:This is literally the next post in my filter. No way you don't see this when you post those quotes. On February 06 2015 07:57 justanothertownie wrote:
SL is here but doesn't care in the slightest about who gets lynched as long as it isn't him. You can also have a look at damdreds case on him. Sure, I saw that, but I also see Marv (I believe) making the exact same argument for Damdred about pushing SL then not caring where the lynch goes. You don't even mention Onegu again. That says why you voted SL, but not why you had such better reasons to.
And that case Damdred made on him was made the night before. I should know; it's why I went through SL's town games and chose to push SL myself. What is the bolded even supposed to say? Ridiculous. So what if marv made that argument about damdred? I didn't think damdred was scum and I also said that multiple times. And wtf does it matter when damdred made his case?
So here's what I just don't get. And maybe I'm just dumb or something, but where in all that rigamarole were you so much more certain that SL was scum than Onegu, when it's clear you thought Damdred was town and voting Onegu would keep Damdred from being lynched?
If I have a townread up for lynch I'm going to try to make sure he doesn't die, especially when I have no reason to townread the other two wagons. In fact, that is almost always my play on Day 1 because I rarely have a strong scumread, and even when I do people usually don't listen to me.
|
On February 08 2015 01:04 marvellosity wrote:
I kinda agree with jat, i don't think a jat/bats team makes that much sense to me. dunno, we got over a day, so a lot of time to muse on it
What about it doesn't make sense?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
