|
His case on HtS. Same thing here as above. HtS was asked to give a read on someone. She did, yet your mom somehow turns this into "you fabricated a read because you needed to give one". It is at least as likely that HtS gave the read as town because SHE WAS ASKED TO!! She answered a question "what do you think my alignment is". Why is it impossible this is the case here? That -- for a vet player -- should be at worst a null-tell.
im going to take this out of rayns case on me to further cementate my point.
a town hts had to say she couldnt tell based on her previous post. but cause she worded it like something worthy of consideration when it wasnt (for the purpose of looking scumhunty: it led to an exaggeration), she was forced to give FF a read.
On March 03 2015 08:06 Half the Sky wrote:This is quite interesting. We either have a scum player not happy at his alignment or a townie that is just bored of being town...
On March 03 2015 08:12 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On March 03 2015 08:08 Fecalfeast wrote:
Well, are you going to make a conclusion on that or just ping me for no reason? That was the first impression I got just reading that. Impulse. Thinking through it harder I'm inclined to say you're town, because if I recall right, you don't seem to be someone who is too enthusiastic or posts a whole lot when he's town.
first of all, a scum player not happy about his alignment will never post about it in the thread like ff did, its just awful logic to even consider it, and scummy play to post about it along with the other side of the medal.
then, the argument used in the second post doesnt connect to the previous post at all. it takes any legitimacy she could have had to post the first post. what does a scum do in this case? throw first post into the trash and try again with something new that appeases the guys attacking you. this is my observation of her second post.
i dont think it has to do with gender that somebody will try to force a read out of himself cause asked. in her situation i would have said "look at it yourself, does it look like i know how to read FF cause of it?". might be a mistake to relate this to "what would i do", but i feel confident in having landed a hit on scum here cause of the lack of confidence and adaptation to the wishes of others while under threat, which is part of scum agenda in order to not get killed. The latter by the way is something tubesock looks also guilty of.
|
On March 04 2015 04:15 IAmRobik wrote:Show nested quote +On March 04 2015 04:14 your mom wrote:On March 04 2015 04:13 IAmRobik wrote:On March 04 2015 03:53 your mom wrote:On March 04 2015 03:48 Tubesock wrote:On March 04 2015 03:38 rsoultin wrote:
Tube, I'd rather hear your reads. Your idea wasn't terrible, but the longer you hide behind that list, the more townie points you're losing. Rayn, Toad, Geript are pretty obvious towns. You're town too, although I feel like Eden would scum you for having a low emote to post ratio. You have been interacting quite a bit. Mocsta is town for his zealousness going against Epiphany. I think Epiphany is town too because he reminds me of Jarjar stubbornly holding onto his equation (device and how to shoot plan). Keirathi, Sandroba, Robik (until a just a moment ago), Sicklucker haven't done anything. I'm scumming them for that. I have a tinfoil hat theory on how to read Sicklucker, so if a couple pieces fall together for him I could town him. Rereading Your Mom, I don't really see anything, but reading Rayn's cases and arguments I'm basically sold he's/she's mafia. Rayn is pretty convincing and I'm strongly townreading him. inclined to agree on toad, too early for rayn to be obvious, didnt really see geript shining town, in fact i should take a look at him, why is geript obvious town? WHEN THE FUCK DID YOU HAVE RAYN IN YOUR TOWN PILE?!?!? literally a few posts before that one So you moved him from town to "too early to read" to "not town" in the matter of 5 posts?
i put the caveat in there that i will keep that read subject to change cause we are dealing with rayn, not some newb scum, ive seen him do some shit as scum, being a disruptive influence but still townread for effort playing a big part in it.
Read my posts more carefully then try again.
|
|
|
oh shit i already have three times the filter i had in my scum game.
points of smartness to the guy who uncovers my identity now.
On March 04 2015 04:20 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On March 04 2015 04:06 raynpelikoneet wrote:
your mom - kill with fire right fucking now
sandroba
kita
batsnacks
i don't know about the rest but somewhere between
Onegu/Koshi/Slam/Sepulchre/Damdred/Robert. My order: Koshi--Bitch plz Onegu--I'm actually really glad you brought him up. I had kinda forgotten about him. That's actually quite telling. Sandroba-- I think there's better ways of finding his alignment but probably not a bad shot Your Mom--Maybe rayn is right. Maybe rayn is crazy. Those are the only people I really agree with. Robik is kinda tbd but his townlist is pretty solid for the most part I think. Slam's town. I remember thinking Damdred was town.
what are the better ways of finding sandrobas alignment? you talk like its something concrete, lets hear it.
|
On March 04 2015 04:25 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On March 04 2015 04:18 raynpelikoneet wrote:
ehh are you saying he is not mafia because of your meta read?
well that does not work out, he usually steers lynches as town aswell. No like, D1 Bugs made a case on Greymist because GM was busy and he could get him lynched. But like, throughout the game Kita was in and out picking and poking. Like it's not because he's pushing lynches. It's because of like how he's posting. Like as mafia I remember reading him and bugs after that game like 8-10 times trying to figure out what I could improve. Like it's more that his posts don't seem idk directional. Like there's not a clear purpose or agenda that he's trying to make. Rather that he's just try to make points. Like that's what I remember thinking and that's what I find very towny about him.
like
|
hrum...
we just got out of a game where FF was so happy to be town lol we were convinced he may be 3p...so that's a strange read from HtS regardless
|
geript, can i shoot hts? i don't wanna have to read her
|
I'm back.
Here's where I stand doing some more filter diving.
Kita - Inclined to scumread him atm. From Carol, I do recall him being a low-count high content poster, his first few posts are on mechanics and his opinion on your mom doesn't say anything new of substance that others had not touched on already.
Koshi - from modding Horn where he was scum, he'd pop in and try to stay lighthearted but had some trouble emulating his town game and I recall marv calling him out early on. I'm inclined to BOD him given his real life schedule atm, so I don't think he's a good shot for today.
Right now, I'd say my top shots would be YM, Kita, and anyone else in the forgettables list, like Onegu, Bats, Oats (I even forgot he was in the game).
|
Ok so basically it boils down to 1 simple thing. Syllogism is in this game. There's literally no one in the world that has ever or will ever read Sandroba as well as Syllogism. So if we leave Sandro alive N1 and he doesn't receive a power, then we auto lynch him. If he does receive a power, we evaluate both his use of it and what power was given. Like it's complete win/win.
|
On March 04 2015 04:32 raynpelikoneet wrote:
why am i drunk your mom?
i feel like i want to scumread you for certain things (looking at your early filter it just looks like you throw out scumreads like candy that doesnt stick), then again i just thought "maybe hes just going haywire again" and want to assume youre just being stupid in your conclusion on me. so when i read the last post where you advocate a shot on me, i just felt a surge of omgus and thought youre playing too dumb to be town, posted "out of the townpile", when the surge was losing steam i reconsidered and limited myself to call you dumb, wording it differently as a potshot.
|
On March 04 2015 04:34 IAmRobik wrote:
geript, can i shoot hts? i don't wanna have to read her
no.
|
On March 04 2015 04:37 Half the Sky wrote:
I'm back.
Here's where I stand doing some more filter diving.
Kita - Inclined to scumread him atm. From Carol, I do recall him being a low-count high content poster, his first few posts are on mechanics and his opinion on your mom doesn't say anything new of substance that others had not touched on already.
Koshi - from modding Horn where he was scum, he'd pop in and try to stay lighthearted but had some trouble emulating his town game and I recall marv calling him out early on. I'm inclined to BOD him given his real life schedule atm, so I don't think he's a good shot for today.
Right now, I'd say my top shots would be YM, Kita, and anyone else in the forgettables list, like Onegu, Bats, Oats (I even forgot he was in the game).
im in the forgettables list?
|
On March 04 2015 04:34 rsoultin wrote:
hrum...
we just got out of a game where FF was so happy to be town lol we were convinced he may be 3p...so that's a strange read from HtS regardless
are you the other knight in shining armor?
will you be my sancho panza?
|
I'm actually really feeling an Onegu shot is the best strategically.
|
After re-reading, here's who I'd have on my no-shot list: LS, Tube, Slam, Rasputin, Toad, Epiphany, geript, Rayn, and Robik.
Sicklucker is someone I'd expect some more activity from, but when he entered, he seemed town.
The same went for FF.
|
realistically speaking, the only guy being so brazen about killing hts is me.
with a grain of tinfoil, i will say that the red guys dont want her dead.
|
On March 04 2015 04:39 geript wrote:
I'm actually really feeling an Onegu shot is the best strategically.
fuck you we are shooting your mom.
|
Keirathi and Kurumi, I have not played with either as much - does anyone know if they are low-count posters or not?
|
On March 04 2015 04:39 your mom wrote:Show nested quote +On March 04 2015 04:34 rsoultin wrote:
hrum...
we just got out of a game where FF was so happy to be town lol we were convinced he may be 3p...so that's a strange read from HtS regardless are you the other knight in shining armor? will you be my sancho panza?
o.0 lol i'm not sure what you're asking? are you the nutso don Quixote or something?
|
On March 04 2015 04:41 Half the Sky wrote:
Keirathi and Kurumi, I have not played with either as much - does anyone know if they are low-count posters or not?
both are probably town.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
