On January 18 2015 22:00 Artanis[Xp] wrote: GB, I felt the biggest problem you and Vivax had was that you tended to forget everything that made someone town when you investigated why someone was scum. It happened with both Palmar and Kelsier. Kelsier was universally townread earlier in the game and that was because he was clearly pushing the right things. When you two went back and digged into the start of the game, you had a theory that you wanted to prove rather than check if it was correct. When you're looking to prove someone is scum rather than find out their alignment, you can always find something to incriminate them. Don't lose sight of the bigger picture.
Yeah, I have a problem of forgetting things. I should keep notes of important things :/
On January 19 2015 03:32 IAmRobik wrote: I'm upset. I called out the play and then just tr'ed all the scum. Vivax, I'm disappointed in you though. You played that one day so poorly
On January 18 2015 21:49 GlowingBear wrote: Eden, if everyone reads more and post less, the thread will be empty
I think the players needs to know their potentials and work with them. Some players are very good at analysing and others are good to keep pushing the thread forward. If they work together with their potentials they will be able to get through the game.
Lol no it won't. What kind of false dichotomy is that? I guarantee town would have been fine if we had only had 7000 posts instead of 10000. Or 6000. That's silly to suggest otherwise.
Especially since so much of it was bad witch hunts.
On January 18 2015 21:49 GlowingBear wrote: Eden, if everyone reads more and post less, the thread will be empty
I think the players needs to know their potentials and work with them. Some players are very good at analysing and others are good to keep pushing the thread forward. If they work together with their potentials they will be able to get through the game.
Lol no it won't. What kind of false dichotomy is that? I guarantee town would have been fine if we had only had 7000 posts instead of 10000. Or 6000. That's silly to suggest otherwise.
Especially since so much of it was bad witch hunts.
Vivax tin foil hat theories are best theories. He totally nailed me by association of Kelsier.
EPT
