Imperial Mafia - Page 158

On January 04 2015 07:57 ritoky wrote:
whole crapload of pages behind,

##vote: sicklucker

unless i see anything as i catch up that makes him not pretty much automatic mafia

On January 04 2015 07:52 sicklucker wrote:


His eod vote. If gerits town robiks 100% town no reason to make that switch in a two town race bad players see that as scummy . Even if gerits not town its not that likely robik would throw in that preemptive vote to keep his partner from getting hammered because no one wanted to change at the time but it is possible just alot less likely.

Robik can be confirmed with a gerit flip so we never kill robik before him anyway.

Marv was the first to defend me so I give him mad town points hes been pretty useful regardless of his filter size.
The one problem I have with him is I feel him and palmer are always mafia together and palmers looking like shit.

On January 04 2015 07:50 Damdred wrote:


I disagree with this pretty much entirely. Piling up votes on someone minutes into a day favor mafia especially, they can hide their votes without participating it gives town the incentive to not really look at anything else that is going on, (lazy aspect of town) this leads to complacency.

we probably will disagree with each other, but an afk lynch is a bad lynch 100% of the time.

On January 04 2015 07:52 sicklucker wrote:


His eod vote. If gerits town robiks 100% town no reason to make that switch in a two town race bad players see that as scummy . Even if gerits not town its not that likely robik would throw in that preemptive vote to keep his partner from getting hammered because no one wanted to change at the time but it is possible just alot less likely.

Robik can be confirmed with a gerit flip so we never kill robik before him anyway.

Marv was the first to defend me so I give him mad town points hes been pretty useful regardless of his filter size.
The one problem I have with him is I feel him and palmer are always mafia together and palmers looking like shit.

On January 04 2015 07:53 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Geript - Vivax
sicklucker
damdred - glowingbear

Is my best guess atm. Sorted by confidence of read in tiers

On January 04 2015 08:00 sicklucker wrote:


@dandred na I think if robiks scum in a two town race he leaves his vote on thechyz 10/10 times

On January 04 2015 08:01 justanothertownie wrote:

How is it an afk lynch though? Not that this argument impresses me in any way.

Nothing in this post makes any fucking sense. If geript is town Robik is most certainly not 100 % town. What is this retarded logic. Robik is not confirmed regardless of geripts flip. Marv was not very useful at all and there is no reason why Palmar and Marv should be tied together.

So Robik is town?

On January 04 2015 07:59 Artanis[Xp] wrote:

Hmmm. It could be for exactly this argument, but you're right. If Geript is green that does help clear Robik a bit, but I wouldn't say he's confirmed town for it. I missed JAT in your town list though and he went above and beyond the call of duty by organizing a switch onto Bats. Do you also consider him cleared if Geript flips green?

On January 04 2015 08:04 sicklucker wrote:


Ya pretty much. Geript can you step it up dawg?

On January 04 2015 08:04 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I could list plenty of people I'm unsure of. If you want my town reads its you, marv, artanis.

Sicklucker forgot about geript again now that the heat is on his other teammate

On January 04 2015 08:04 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I could list plenty of people I'm unsure of. If you want my town reads its you, marv, artanis.

Sicklucker forgot about geript again now that the heat is on his other teammate

On January 04 2015 08:06 sicklucker wrote:
Well I dont think it clears jat actually. He could just be setting up the next mislynch so no. He honestly didnt give it much effort it was eden and others that lead bats to getting kill. He kind of just had a thowaway vote on bats seeing what sticks which makes him pretty scummy if gerit is. And the fact he doesint want to see a gerit flip

On January 04 2015 08:05 geript wrote:
Also the vet mafia is either Palmer or DrH. I've been waffling on Marv. Still am in many regards. His D2 play is far more in line w/ his town play so I think I'm just going to ignore D1 due to NYE. Granted, I'll catch heat for thinking DrH is mafia or potentially so, but I think everyone's ignoring how he's acting and thinking. There's agenda behind each post he makes. He's either trying to make it unfun for other people (a tactic he approves of as mafia), he's trying to line up lynches multiple lynches down the road, he tries to bury any sort of productive discussion. As town he's tunnely and generally a pretentious asshole, but he also stops to think at points. He really hasn't considered anyone's reads or points critically. He's one of the most logical players (read LID and his push on Prome as an example) but he's in no way done my that this game.

On January 03 2015 13:55 Eden1892 wrote:
OK, verdict is in.

I think sicklucker is town. I don't want to kill him today, maybe ever.

Yes it's derpy as hell that he says he changed his vote off geript to batsnacks because he "wasn't confident" in the read on geript, even though he has multiple posts that basically say geript is definitely mafia. But:

(1) His story on his four town reads is completely consistent and held up despite direct questioning. He had explicitly townread three of them and implicitly townread a fourth well before he justified his vote switch by sheeping his townreads.
(2) Sheeping one's townreads off of a vote you like to another wagon late is definitely something a townie would do, and seems like something a townie is more likely to do than a mafia, because a mafia would be worried about how bad "sheep townreads onto a town flip" would look afterwards.
(3) The stars had to have aligned colossally for sicklucker to be mafia and be able to make any kind of strategic switch to kill batsnacks with the rationale that he sheeped his four most consistent town reads. You can't make this up.