EPTDevil's Riddle Mafia - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 25 2014 01:39 Promethelax wrote: Would take Dam as town. He was unhappy I hadn't noticed him which is good. Scum generally don't want people to pay attention to them and his post complaining that I hadn't noticed him is quite townie. FWIW Prome, I've been thinking about this post on and off and I'm very twisted on it. I get the read 100%, but a lot of times as mafia when I've put in a bunch of work and think people would read me as super towny geript I get frustrated when people don't read me that way. I can see it working both ways. IDK, maybe I was wrong and it's DP/Vayne. Maybe I was right about Hapa. Maybe my townread on Grack was bad; but at least 2 of my town think Kush looks towny. Idk I feel really lost because I have a townread on someone in each group except for VE/CR. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 03:21 Damdred wrote: @Prom, Yamatos style of townplay has been pretty simple the past 6 games I think i've played with him. Its been mostly a running narrative with his thoughts thrown in. He seems generally invested in the thread at this point, and has some thoughts it seems behind what he is saying, even if they are simplistic and not expounded upon yet they are their. This has been a staple of yamatos town game for awhile now, and while it would be pretty easy to fake this as scum, yamato generally becomes really demotivated pretty fast and just lurks and taunts a bit. Neither of which he is doing here, so i'm town reading him for now if his play degrades then i'll start looking at him again it just looks like town yamato. This is a pretty solid summary. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On August 27 2014 19:07 abuse wrote: meatpudding His reply to my initial first 4 questions satisfies me deeply (no perv intended) He is giving an experienced player vibe, even though this is a newbie game. He seems to be the only person to actually read my posts how I intended them to be read, and does good analysis of the situation. Same as Barakos, even if he turns out to be scum in the end(which I also do not believe to be the case), I think having him along the way will still help town a lot. His posts are logical and have meaning behind them. He does not try to ignore questions and try to negatively push any flaws he sees in others' posts. He asks about them instead of attacking. Also - I do not see him to be the cop, I do see him as town though. This is the only type of thing I really have to fault when comparing the two. He earlyish into D1 (started on p6 and he posted a series of these at p11) that he goes through a bit methodically about reading people. He hasn't really done this at all. He seems really detached in general in comparison. There's a minor townie point for him and his gum comment on me as that type of attitude pervades his newbie filter, but the rest of what he posted seems pretty different actually. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 25 2014 03:40 abuse wrote: You either share your gum with the entire class, or don't chew it in front of everybody. This post was the one that Hapa has quoted for why Abuse is town. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
CR is the safe no one will really fight it lynch. Abuse is an ok lurker lynch, Vayne is too maybe. Kush I could lynch but I doubt the support's there. Damdred is maybe an ok lynch but I think it's too likely that I'm reading him wrong. VE has sorta faded out. Kinda reminds me of when he was mafia in gmarsh's game. The tone thing and reversing Hapa's argument on himself feels a bit bad and there's Hapa's arguments too. Hapa I think was too active to lynch today; I think in the long run lynching abuse makes more sense there. Plus he's been all over the place for me. I still don't see how he ever thought I was mafia and him returning to that read made me feel even more odd about him. DP I think is town but I don't think he's been terribly useful. Kinda in the same boat as Yam. I think Grack's town. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 04:47 Damdred wrote: Geript did you say something to MM in QT that isn't in thread that is making him reverse his stance on oats and myself? I said the same thing I said in thread. Oats' return makes me feel far more comfortable with him as town. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 04:48 Hapahauli wrote: We're still lynching VE. How can you make this post and have read the thread? It's a complete cop-out vote. Put your vote on someone that provides no impact, that everyone abandoned for today, and provides literally no useful information towards finding mafia. Regarding my meta case, DP did bring up a good point about him going after DP in "The Game." So that part of my meta case was wrong - didn't expect to have to go back 20 town games. Regardless, I do not believe town-VE is the type of player that's town-reading MM1 and Damdred so early into the game. That's very, very unlike any of his town games, including "the game." We need to start consolidating. The people voting Damdred and Oats still have not made a case on them and are doing some weird process of elimination thing, which is not an adequate reason to lynch someone. On September 26 2014 03:26 geript wrote: @Prome Here is a link to his only game here; idk if (s)he's played elsewhere. At first glance it seems pretty standard new player flaws and was modkilled N2 (I'm assuming for inactivity but I'll doublecheck). On September 26 2014 03:35 geript wrote: This is the only type of thing I really have to fault when comparing the two. He earlyish into D1 (started on p6 and he posted a series of these at p11) that he goes through a bit methodically about reading people. He hasn't really done this at all. He seems really detached in general in comparison. There's a minor townie point for him and his gum comment on me as that type of attitude pervades his newbie filter, but the rest of what he posted seems pretty different actually. Here's something to look at. Both Prome and I agreed on it. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 05:02 Promethelax wrote: I want to lynch VE. Next day I'd like to look at both abuse and VA both still look scummy to me but I don't have the support to force their lynches today and, honestly, I'm more interested in seeing a VE flip. More people said things about him and he is therefore a more useful flip for town. Who do you want to lynch geript? Honestly I'm really torn between Abuse and VE with a side of CR. Like I think there's almost no way CR is the martyr 3P right now. He's not at all playing like he's going to end with a "win with town" wincon; that's really telling for me. He also spend most of the day doing nothing and the other half of the day pretending he's in some lala world. I don't see him getting any better; i don't think his flip helps with VE, but I think we'll end up lynching him at some point so I'd rather clear him now before he kills a town. On Abuse, I mean half policy half acting differently half I don't trust Hapa. On VE, I don't hate parts of Hapa's case and I've listed my own reasons multiple times. It's just that my ass is itching and I think he'll probly flip town. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 05:18 Promethelax wrote: I had a dream about the balance for this game. It suggested that the 3p has to be anti-town because 10-3 is essentially balanced to begin with. 10-3 with mason pairs is very town favoured, even more so since we know the alignments of the pairs. Since there is a 3p it has to be anti town to make up for the masoning of the players. I've been thinking about that. I'm not sure if HaruRH would think that or if Kita/Fool/Gmarsh/whoever would make that argument. I'm also not sure if they would allow it to be "tried" without a "true 3P." | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 04:55 abuse wrote: What? did you even read any of my posts afterwards? Several times did I mention that I think vayne is scummy. Also - deadline comming up, still no info at all from vayne... So.. you're trying to lynch me because you don't like hapa.. ? What is this. head out of ass please. This really bugs me. It feels very off from where he should be. He's frustrated that people aren't reading his posts and thinks he's mafia and says "head out of ass please" I really feel like this is similar to when I was mafia for the first time in the Game and responded to BH (my mafia partner when he was pressuring me) "Because I didn't think I could use it (pre-used rng)?" Especially after the newbie game he played in I really don't see him not just saying something simple and straight forward like "get your head out of your ass." | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On September 26 2014 05:21 abuse wrote: How on earth is it policy to lynch an activity like mine, and not policy to lynch Vayne. Seriously. Pls do explain, because I sure as hell can't get this in my skull, yet this has been pushed more than once already. Because historically, when Vayne barely plays it's because he's town and doesn't want to be NK'd. We don't have any sort of history like that for you. And no one is giving Vayne a free pass; it's just that there actually are people who look worse. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
##unvote ##vote VisceraEyes | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
| ||
