On August 28 2014 03:12 KelsierSC wrote:Alright for my first point I want to analyse Xata d2.
You all know my reasons for suspecting him D1. He had no committment to any reads, then sheeped a read on rayn, then tried to force town to lynch yamato. Finally voted on Robik to save himself. Like a lot of the play was inconsistent with logic and felt scummy.
So N1 & D2 I want to bring a few things to light.
His main arguments for being town . He voted on Robik, this is not a good argument, it was him or Robik of course he switches to save himself. This has been explained to him multiple times, the fact he clings to this defence is scummy.
The other argument is this weird meta read from Hapa, again I don't put much stock into the read.
Large filter - Ok it is large but a lot of it is just repetition or confused nonsense, I don't like this play at all. I think it is scummy.
I had a re read of D2 and a few things jumped out to me.
Early on he had the same idea as me to lynch between VA and Onegu. But then he did some things I don't like. I pointed out my analysis of the VA claim and said he was genuine and a few other people were coming to that opinion. Pressure was building on Hapa and he said
Show nested quote +On August 26 2014 22:10 Xatalos wrote:
Yeah it's possible that it's legit. It's a good point that he could have claimed something more sensible like checking rayn instead. Maybe we should just lynch Onegu and wait a bit more with VA.
I think we just lynch VA or Onegu today. They both didn't do anything actually helpful during D1, didn't care about the lynch and voted for something random. Onegu hasn't still even catched up with the thread. VA's claim could potentially be real, so I think Onegu may be the better choice.
Show nested quote +On August 27 2014 07:36 Xatalos wrote:
Nah, I think it's just safer to lynch VA overall. I'm going to be so sad if Hapa flips town.
##Unvote
##Vote VayneAuthority
Like at this stage in the game, it was clear VA was real, most of the thread thought so I don't think this was the right lynch at all. It seems he wants to try and force the lynch onto VA
So he did vote on Hapa at the end, but it was fairly obvious Hapa had given up, furthermore he wanted to try and not lynch Hapa but I didn't really see any justification for it. VA was the safe lynch, why? I also considered this possibility but I had some mathematical (though incorrect) reasoning behind it.
The point for Xata is that he had to just go along with town D2 because he had a lot of heat on him D1. I don't see any original ideas from Xata he just seemed to sheep along with the popular opinion.
This is the impression I got
"VA isn't real lynch him... oh maybe VA is real lets get Onu, oh maybe VA, ok lets get Hapa."Just nothing original at all and just sheeping the top town.
I still read Xata as scum.
Also GB reads him as town so he is almost definitely mafia.I still need to decide on WoS and Dama.
LOL.
If you're not mafia, I won't play for a month. If he is mafia, I won't play for 2 months. If I am wrong on both of you, I won't play the game until the end of the year.
If I am right on both of you, I'll spam your inbox until you request a ban on me or I will in every game you in just to fuck up with you.
EPT
