i am waffling so hard right now
do not lunch: me, eden, chairman kosher, palmiform, harubear

harubear has moved up into my town circle cuz everything they say feels really genuine to me.
the same kind of thing has me waffling on bunnies (i hate that there's no good portmanteau of your names btw)

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:30 GMT

#1535

On July 13 2014 20:30 marvellosity wrote:
all caught up. kinda weird game. GK and sinani are being totally carried by their better halves.

Palmar (as per above) and Stratiform look ok to me (stratiform's reads post kinda had everywhere about where i'd expect, didn't seem fabricate-y).

Robik/Exo look ok I guess.

rayn/slendy, koshi/cr, bunnies/poof.
rayn/slendy look worse to me simply by virtue of the fact i'm going off haru/glowingbear, and if we take that out of their filter they've done next to nothing.
koshi especially will have all day 2 to look town, if he's town he'll be able to do it, if he's mafia he probably won't. sit and see.
bunnies is being dragged way down by poofter, who has little redeeming about his play. hate the lazy palmar/me comment that i pointed out. the points OK made about bunnies on the last page are pretty valid as well.

marv can you explain to me why this makes sense?

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:33 GMT

#1537

i'll clarify a bit
i don't see why you should exclude raynman's case on harubear at all, especially when they originated the second one (the first one being originated by palmar i think)
and jsut cause you're no longer on them doesn't invalidate their contribution

so i'm not sure what's going on here sounds like a weird reason

like i would totally understand "he's scumreading my townread, that's weird"
but i dont understand "he's scumreading someone i no longer scumread, if i remove his scumread from what he's said then he looks bad"

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:40 GMT

#1539

ur gonna hate me slender
but what it really comes down to is ~vibes~
i can just feel earnestness and trying to answer everything and be completely open pouring out of their posts
so even though i may not agree with everything they write i still feel as if they're being completely open and honest about a thought process that seems really townie to me

so i think theyre town

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:49 GMT

#1544

i have no idea about robik's meta unfortunately
i'll have to read ExO, i had robik town for most of day 1 so i had ExO town by extension

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:57 GMT

#1546

605 - i remember having similar misgivings about this post where i felt like all the reads he gave were null
but it was pretty early on so i don't put that much weight on it
1091 - don't really see this as fencesitting tbh

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:58 GMT

#1548

oops pressed enter too fast
overall i could lunch them... i actually think what eden said earlier about robik greenlighting the slamroot lynch then whining about it holds a lot of water and i'm not very convinced by robik's "Back the fuck off" defense

still some people said hes not a heavy d1 poster so on d2 i expect tidings

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 01:59 GMT

#1549

firebats
firebats everywhere

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 02:01 GMT

#1553

oh look

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 02:02 GMT

#1554

maybe there's more water in the harubear case than i thought

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 02:07 GMT

#1559

On July 14 2014 11:05 Eden1892 wrote:
fuck it

##VOTE: TheD

pls explain

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 02:15 GMT

#1562

is dat slamroot

ok no seriously pls explain

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 02:56 GMT

#1576

i agree with my other head on rayn more or less (he did give marv a town read way back)
on slenderman i disagree though, i think hes done ok

which is why im waffly on raynman

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 03:07 GMT

#1578

tell me about koshi. i have a town read on him atm.

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 03:28 GMT

#1581

i rather like his catchup one-liners, and his play is different from what i remember from normal mini lvi.

is what i was going to say but after checking his filter he's only got three pages and marv said he's typically a high volume poster in normal mini lvi's postgame.
so maybe not let me check

OnceKing

United States939 Posts

July 14 2014 03:50 GMT

#1586

okay i have pleasantly reorganized all of my opinions on players into the following list feel free to ask me any questions

town - frauds, eden+gk, harubear
posting things/memorable - robik, bunnies, slenderman
not posting things/unmemorable - exo, chairman koshi, rayn, poof

teams that make me waffly - bunnies/poof, robik/exo, slender/rayn

on my first readthrough i got a distinct impression of koshi being town from his one liners on catching up. because marv wrote in normal mini lvi's postgame that koshi's a high volume poster as town, when i first read the posts i automatically assumed that koshi was being higher volume.

however it turns out that koshi is far from being high volume this game. his filter is only 3 pages and there's not that much in there -- he's called lots of people town and agreed with stuff but hasn't called anyone scum.
CR's filter is less than one page long, and has only the stratiform case, and this statement:

Bunnies is mafia. Her cases before the flip were a little too interesting.

there's no explanation of how they're interesting. i don't even know what 'interesting' means in this context.
##Vote: Team GoodCopBadCop