Newbie Mini Mafia LIV - Page 5
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
Robik is top town for pretty obvious reasons. OK is top town for same reasons as last time. On March 30 2014 02:33 sqrtofneg1 wrote: OnceKing is currently my top town. He was the first one to vote me this day, and that creates a lot of attention. I doubt that mafia want that to happen to them. That leaves Val + LT as mafia team. LT looks a bit more safe because he kept on telling me to stop talking about doctor last night. Which leaves you top mafia. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
Eden is the most contributing player currently. He is a prime target for the night kill, but what happens if he gets killed? 1. Robik and I look guilty, because we're the ones most under suspicion by Eden. 2. We lose the most contributing player. 3. He gets confirmed town. What if RJ gets killed? 1. He gets confirmed town. 2. We lose an analyst. So logically, Eden was the better save. But what if Eden is mafia? Then mafia would probably kill RJ. But what if RJ was mafia? Then mafia would possibly kill Eden. Why? Because Eden's on the wrong track atm, he's chasing town, and mafia knows that, and probably will leave him be, to get a town kill next day. If neither Eden and RJ are mafia, I thought the kill will be RJ. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
On April 01 2014 09:49 Valenius wrote: I'll take another look in the morning, but my initial impressions are that you're lying out of your ass. Tolkien, i still want a yes/no as to whether you're doctor. I understand where you're coming from. Because I'm the only one who's ever been roleblocked, there's no evidence other than my word that it is setup A. Which means that even if everyone else says they're not doctor, it doesn't automatically make me doctor. But you guys will have to believe me. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
OnceKing is town. He's the one who brought up policy first thing. He's been thinking I'm scum from pretty much Day 1, and he's been asking me questions and pressuring me. Valenius is mafia. Due to process of elimination. LordTolkien is town. He did the scum trap thingy. He kept on telling me not to talk about doctor last night. IAmRobik is mafia. Due to process of elimination. And also, normally, he doesn't doubt himself that much, he's really aggressive. This game, however, he's a bit less than that. On March 27 2014 06:00 IAmRobik wrote: What's confusing? I think he's town and i'm prolly just being paranoid that he could be mafia. + Show Spoiler + On March 28 2014 01:05 IAmRobik wrote: So, I don't remember discussing pixalated at all, so I decided I'm gonna read his filter. This makes me think that pixalated will be bringing up how he perceives people would play based off of the previous newbie game. Will keep reading his filter and see if he brings any of this up: Pixalated makes a reasonable point here, but he doesn't really take a stance on OK. He's very wishy washy with his "conclusion": I guess I can see how Pixalated would perceive Valenius's post this way, but as I explained, it had to do with the way that he approached OK's lynch all lurkers sentiments. Maybe I was just tunnely regarding OK earlier which was what made me think that this post was towny. But Valenius makes a long post later which I found town, so I'm cool with him anyway: I like that he takes a stance on me here. It's perfectly fine for him to not like me, especially if he thinks that OK is leading town in the right direction...having said that, it's kinda weird too, because he said earlier that it's easy to look like you're contributing without actually contributing if you're talkinga bout policy...so maybe he doesn't exactly agree with OK? idk: Pixalated definitely taking stances on people. If LT is mafia, pixalated is almost certainly town for this post: This is really weird for me. Pixalated casually mentions a scum read on Cavalinho a couple posts earlier, but his main focus is LT. He then makes another 2 posts that have somethign to do with LT and then boom, he votes for Cavalinho, sheeping Eden: So, I think he's letting LT off the hook really quickly here. Nothing that LT said has really answered Pixalated's questions, and if it has, it's as if Pixalated just takes his word for it at face value. I retract my earlier statement that they can't be mafia together. I expect him to follow up on this. Will see if he does (same goes for bringing up the previous newbie game, which I haven't seen him do yet) I guess it's a bit hypocritical of me to bring this up, but from everything Pixalated is writing it seems that LT is his biggest scum read (his personal biggest scum read, not the one he sheeped off of Eden), but he refuses to vote him: Conclusions: Pixalated might be scum here. He kinda takes stances on people, but he keeps flipping back and forth. It seems throughout the day that LT is his biggest scum read, but he ends up just sheeping Eden regarding Cav. He keeps pressuring LT but never ends up voting him. Another thing that he does, is make statements like "valeniusa nd sqrt need to post more" and "i read the previous game, but he does nothing with those. He doesn't pressure valenius or sqrt to post more, he doesn't call them out for it again, even though they posted a bit after I guess. But like, I'd expect something along the lines of "hey, so and so posted more, and I guess I like what he's said so I'm gonna lean town on him" or something like that, but he doesn't do it. He also doesn't make inferences from the previous game, which I'd assume he's make if he read it. This makes me think that at times he's just posting for the sake of posting. On April 01 2014 07:45 IAmRobik wrote: If you're doing what I think you're doing, then I approve. Otherwise, I'm kinda nervous about the implications. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
On April 01 2014 10:18 IAmRobik wrote: Don't do that to me sqrt. 1) Don't POE me 2) It's not even right 3) I obv doubt myself when my top scum read turns out to be town Here's an example from Heavyweight Champ game where I was town (link below for reference): http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/446774-world-heavyweight-championship-mafia-ii?page=47#921 Just cause I doubt myself doesn't make me scum. Doubting myself is natural cause I'm town and I need to reevaluate things as new information is brought forward. Looking at that game's filter, I've reconsidered. What's POE? | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
On April 01 2014 11:26 OnceKing wrote: "W-well m-m-maybe they KNEW I was m-medic!" Please. If they knew you were medic, why wouldn't they just shoot you? There would be nothing stopping that! In fact the entire situation that Robik is backing your claim suddenly makes it evident this is a poorly thought out gambit by the scum team to try to win ASAP. You two were even RJ's scum reads, so you guys shot him to prevent him from pushing any further -- the logic here is clear and simple unlike your huge mess. None of your actions match what a real doctor would do -- a real doctor is town and plays like town, not scum (which is what you've played like). They probably kept me alive for a pretty easy mislynch. Which is where we're headed to. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
One of you are town. Two of you are mafia. (assuming that Robik is town, which I'm willing to go with him till the end) One of you are making a mistake. Two of you are on the verge of victory. Reconsider. #Vote LordTolkien | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
On April 01 2014 17:03 Valenius wrote: As it stands now. ##Vote: sqrtofneg1 Sqrt, why did you try and save robik last night? Because he seemed like the most logical kill, plus I couldn't save RJ cause I already saved him. I had OK as my night save for most of the time, and then I switched last hour because Robik has a town reputation, and because he hasn't tunneled me, and if mafia kill him, everyone would mislynch me the next day for an easy win. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
On March 31 2014 06:16 Valenius wrote: If town lynch sqrt, and neither him or pix are mafia, we lose. Makes me think he's town now. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
Robik is town 1. Mafia are Val + OK. 2. Mafia are OK + LT. 3. Mafia are Val + LT. Robik is mafia 4. We lose. I say it's OK + LT. | ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
| ||
sqrtofneg1
Canada1158 Posts
Joke stage: LT votes OK because "my renewed ok scum sense is tingling". This is just to get a vote on the other mafia, so that if someone does a vote analysis, it looks better for them. OK returns the favour later on. On March 27 2014 06:27 OnceKing wrote: Yeah actually I agree. I'm not going to wait around for LT to keep dodging the question. ##VOTE: Lord Tolkien. Come make me move it. On March 27 2014 04:46 OnceKing wrote: You're my partner because you're Lord Tolkien! This is strange. Also, who were the 2 people who switched onto the Cav wagon last minute to get him lynched? It was OK and LT. They switched after the cop claim, to get a cop kill. OK and LT scum team; that's the scum team that makes the most sense, and it's the scum team that only makes sense. | ||
| ||