|
On February 28 2014 19:06 Xatalos wrote:
1) A real cop check
2) A fake cop check
3) A town flip
Maybe not all of those, but at least 2 of them. Each one of them is helpful overall.
1 and 2 we wont know until we lynch and if we lynch scum then we pretty much win anyway so thats useless.
3) Is the townie gonna be me or Syl? No?
So basically the information you want to get is useless. Good job Xata.
|
On February 28 2014 19:18 Xatalos wrote:
Also, if we HAD to lynch today, then almost certainly Sylencia would be lynched. If I was pushing scum agenda, I would definitely push for lynching Sylencia right away (like you are pushing me). It's risky to no-lynch as scum since there's even less space to hide tomorrow.
you srs? sn0 is gonna die. Or artanis is gonna die. There is nowhere to hide in a fucking 6 player game Xata.
|
the stuff you are saying is not contextually correct, making me think that you are playing this game trying to do townie looking things rather than actually doing townie things.
|
Town doesn't gather information to reinforce their existing beliefs, they gather information to find the truth. If JJD or Artanis dies, then I can be certain that that player wasn't scum.
|
Actually one of the best scenarios would be if I flipped. In that case you and Sylencia would be pretty much confirmed scum.
|
On February 28 2014 19:26 Xatalos wrote:
Town doesn't gather information to reinforce their existing beliefs, they gather information to find the truth. If JJD or Artanis dies, then I can be certain that that player wasn't scum.
So your 100% on artanis wasnt actually 100% then?
How does artanis flipping town tomorrow help town in any way to lynch Syl anymore than today?
Also you have to be joking.
|
On February 28 2014 19:35 Xatalos wrote:
Actually one of the best scenarios would be if I flipped. In that case you and Sylencia would be pretty much confirmed scum.
Why do you have to flip for Syl to be confirmed scum?
|
Confirmed for me != confirmed for everyone
|
On February 28 2014 19:42 Xatalos wrote:
Confirmed for me != confirmed for everyone
Shouldnt you want to convince people? Isnt that the point of mafia?
to push your case, not sit back and wait and wait and wait for totally fucking useless information.
|
Everyone already is pretty convinced of you + Sylencia. What we want is confirmation.
|
Like what? again, nothing will happen when we nolynch other than a townie dies.
|
Vote Count
Xatalos (2): Oatsmaster, Sylencia
No-lynch (1): Sn0_Man
Not Voting (3): JarJarDinks, Artanis[xp], Xatalos
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch. Or not lynch.
|
vote no-lynch
I'm gonna go ahead and say that both cops check should oats tonight. (though everyone should chime in on this)
If we get dual red-checks, we obv lynch him
If we get dual green-checks, we @ least know that he has no alt agenda and his reads are legit
If we get conflicting reports then we @ least have more information
Then I think the Doc should heal Sn0man.
It's not the worst thing in the world if oats is town and he gets killed because if that's the case we're probably gonna get conflicting reports anyway if he survives.
Best thing that could happen is Art or me gets killed because we're the unknowns and we'd then have the cops data on oats as well as confirmed town in sn0. Plenty of info to help solve the game.
If Sn0 is the doc then he can be killed but I don't think scum would take a 33% shot @ getting lucky.
thoughts?
|
Best thing that happens is either syl or xata die.
If we get dual red-checks, we obv lynch him I dont even. What?
There is much stuff with what jjd said
|
On February 28 2014 23:19 Oatsmaster wrote: I dont even. What? There is much stuff with what jjd said If both cops come back w/ a red check on you then we lynch you. I think that's a very possible result.
|
???????????????????????????????????
|
Proper readup tomorrow - karaoke has me drained.
However, I noticed one post that stuck out from Xat for me:
On February 28 2014 19:35 Xatalos wrote:
Actually one of the best scenarios would be if I flipped. In that case you and Sylencia would be pretty much confirmed scum.
It's a valiant attempt to gain town cred by trying to martyr, but if you think about it from his perspective it doesn't really show much towniness does it?
If he was the town cop, if he died, we'd gain +1 scum in me, but then town would have 66% chance to lose if the NK is the doc/non-protected guy. Doesn't really sound like a good tradeoff to me.
However, he's been pushing for a no lynch because it's apparently better to have us completely confused over the cop checks even more on day 2 if there are differing results. Basically he offers the self-sacrifice yet pushes no lynch.
That's scum yo.
|
On February 28 2014 23:27 JarJarDrinks wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2014 23:19 Oatsmaster wrote:If we get dual red-checks, we obv lynch him I dont even. What? There is much stuff with what jjd said If both cops come back w/ a red check on you then we lynch you. I think that's a very possible result.
no. no. no. no. no. no.
Why would my scumbuddy bus me for literally no reason? To extend the game? The game is either Xata or Syl is scum. Thats it.
No.
|
On February 28 2014 23:11 JarJarDrinks wrote:
vote no-lynch
I'm gonna go ahead and say that both cops check should oats tonight. (though everyone should chime in on this)
If we get dual red-checks, we obv lynch him
If we get dual green-checks, we @ least know that he has no alt agenda and his reads are legit
If we get conflicting reports then we @ least have more information
Then I think the Doc should heal Sn0man.
It's not the worst thing in the world if oats is town and he gets killed because if that's the case we're probably gonna get conflicting reports anyway if he survives.
Best thing that could happen is Art or me gets killed because we're the unknowns and we'd then have the cops data on oats as well as confirmed town in sn0. Plenty of info to help solve the game.
If Sn0 is the doc then he can be killed but I don't think scum would take a 33% shot @ getting lucky.
thoughts?
why are you directing blue actions?
And how does one person saying im green and one person saying im red give you more info? Like whattttttttttt.
No fuck this whole post is wrong. You get no info that helps us win the game by nolynching today. None. 0 info.
|
##Vote No-Lynch
Artanis may decide when to end the day. I'm pretty much ready already.
JJD, I very much doubt that Sylencia would bus Oats. It would be somewhat possible if it was the other way around, but frankly, I don't see how Sylencia could carry the scumteam to victory. I don't really see how Oats could either, but at least it's in the realms of possibility.
I'm almost certainly going to check Oats, and I think Sylencia should do the same. It seems like we gain the most information if we both choose the same target (and specifically Oats).
Doctor should probably heal Sn0_Man. If Sn0_Man is the Doctor, he should probably heal Artanis or JJD. There's also a small chance that I might get hit, but since my death would pretty much nail the scumteam, I doubt it. IF I was NK'd, healing me would also pretty much nail the scumteam, since then both me and the Doctor would be confirmed. But it's a lot less likely than scum hitting someone else, so it's probably not the best choice after all.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
