Oats, you remind me a lot of myself in my previous game as Mafia where I relentlessly tried to stop town from mass claiming blue roles. Nobody believed me, but I continued to try, since a mass claim would pretty much end the game (the setup was quite OP too). You're doing exactly the same thing here.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

February 28 2014 15:42 GMT

#484

Doctor should probably randomize his heal target by giving each player a chance of getting hit (something like 50% for Sn0_Man for example) and then going to http://www.random.org

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

February 28 2014 15:45 GMT

#485

There's definitely some value to the doc healing whoever he thinks the "real cop" is since my death is pretty irrelevant honestly (since we need 4 votes today and 3 tomorrow, its much the same as my vote still counting).

Whereas if either "cop" dies sure we have a red check on the other but we miss the information of their cop checks.

Although there's also the possibility of some no-kill wifom bombs depending on who the doc saves LOL.

Honestly though, the fact that oats and Syl just voted like that tells you what you need to know. Sure, technically they could be town because if they were then xat would be scum and scum wouldn't self-hammer, but there's just no way lol. No-lynch is categorically GOOD for town. The fact that 2 people don't like a no lynch clearly indicates that THEY ARE SCUM.

Scum MUST BE:
One of Syl/Xat
One of Artanis/JJD/Oats

If we no-lynch, then we get MORE INFORMATION based on Syl/Xat's true and fake cop checks. THIS CAN'T BE BAD. Sure, there are situations where we don't learn much (my death). But the loss is nonexistant because the voting is ALWAYS every towny required to lynch scum. Losing my vote means literally nothing. Plus the possibility of hero doc saves etc...

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

February 28 2014 15:47 GMT

#486

Also, the fact that Oats isn't afraid of insta-maf-hammers tells you a lot.

ITS IML PEOPLE.

Especially keep in mind tomorrow if ANY towny EVER votes for town they can lose on the spot. So NEVER VOTE until all of town agrees on the lynch. Scum will be willing to bus hammer if they feel like it gives them cred.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:47 GMT

#487

On March 01 2014 00:39 Xatalos wrote:
Oats, you remind me a lot of myself in my previous game as Mafia where I relentlessly tried to stop town from mass claiming blue roles. Nobody believed me, but I continued to try, since a mass claim would pretty much end the game (the setup was quite OP too). You're doing exactly the same thing here.

except there is no plan.
Ok lets say scum shoot artanis. Then what? We still lynch between you and Syl. How does this nolynch help?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:48 GMT

#488

On March 01 2014 00:47 Sn0_Man wrote:
Also, the fact that Oats isn't afraid of insta-maf-hammers tells you a lot.

ITS IML PEOPLE.

Especially keep in mind tomorrow if ANY towny EVER votes for town they can lose on the spot. So NEVER VOTE until all of town agrees on the lynch. Scum will be willing to bus hammer if they feel like it gives them cred.

orrrrrr i know that xata is scum.
Wooooohooooo yeahhhhhhhhh. Look at the last IML game man.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

February 28 2014 15:50 GMT

#489

On March 01 2014 00:47 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

except there is no plan.
Ok lets say scum shoot artanis. Then what? We still lynch between you and Syl. How does this nolynch help?

Lets say scum shoot artanis.

Now we know that scum can't be artanis. This is valuable info.

THE LONGER THE GAME GOES THE MORE FAVOURED TOWN IS. Then scum MUST be You or JJD one of the 2. I just covered how this can't possibly be bad for town.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:52 GMT

#490

Oh shit it still doesnt matter because we have to lynch between Xata and Syl.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:53 GMT

#491

look.
we lynch scum today.
Then the doc procts the cop. We still get a check, and a townie still dies.

ITS THE SAME THING.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

February 28 2014 15:57 GMT

#492

On March 01 2014 00:52 Oatsmaster wrote:
Oh shit it still doesnt matter because we have to lynch between Xata and Syl.

False.

And with that I'm done arguing with Oats.

Better luck next time dude.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:58 GMT

#493

ANDDDD If the doc doesnt die, then we no lynch tmr and if the doc gets off a save, town wins. So much more benefit than nolynching today.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 15:58 GMT

#494

On March 01 2014 00:57 Sn0_Man wrote:

Show nested quote +

False.

And with that I'm done arguing with Oats.

Better luck next time dude.

WHAT? ?? ??
Who do we lynch tmr?

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

February 28 2014 16:01 GMT

#495

If one of u/artanis/jjd dies, then it becomes head 2 head between the other 2 for scum, same as between syl/xat.

Its just as reasonable to lynch one of them.

Regardless, we dont know who we lynch tmr until we get our fucking cop checks.

JarJarDrinks

United States1302 Posts

February 28 2014 16:01 GMT

#496

Oats ur not gonna convince enough people to not no-lynch. And ur sure as heck not gonna convince enough people to vote Xat. Just hammer no-lynch so we can move on please.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2014 16:05 GMT

#497

On March 01 2014 01:01 Sn0_Man wrote:
If one of u/artanis/jjd dies, then it becomes head 2 head between the other 2 for scum, same as between syl/xat.

Its just as reasonable to lynch one of them.

Regardless, we dont know who we lynch tmr until we get our fucking cop checks.

except one cop check is real and one is fake and you have no idea which one is which.