|
On February 28 2014 10:14 JarJarDrinks wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2014 09:31 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
This is a very interesting claim though. Very interesting.
JJD why didn't you believe Xatalos' claim? I lied cause I wanted there to be a counter. I figured scum might not counter if everyone was all in on Xat being town. Xat is 100% the cop because if he was scum he'd have no way to know Sn0 wouldn't be the actual cop which would immediately out Xat as the fake (cause he gave him a green check). That logic make sense to everyone?
In fact, if I was scum with Sn0_Man, then it would make a lot of sense. But yeah, if I was scum and Sn0_Man town, then it wouldn't really make any sense at all (taking an unnecessary 25% chance of losing immediately for no real reason).
|
What's the scumslip, if I may ask?
|
On February 28 2014 17:34 Oatsmaster wrote:
where's your vote Xata?
What's the rush? Unless your time is running out...
|
I think it's more like the real Cop expects to claim and scum hopes to get away without needing to fakeclaim.
|
On February 28 2014 17:42 Xatalos wrote:What's the rush? Unless your time is running out...
Its about intent. No vote, no intent to lynch.
If syl is my scumbuddy, then we faked all of the stuff that happened between us. So obviously he has wouldnt comment on me because its faked. Now, you just talked about it like you thought I was not on the same team as Syl.
|
On February 28 2014 17:45 Xatalos wrote:
I think it's more like the real Cop expects to claim and scum hopes to get away without needing to fakeclaim.
you srs bro? Did you not read the last game?
|
Why did you claim? I didnt see any good reason at all.
|
My original intention was to wait until scum had made their moves (making them think that I had checked BH or something). Then I noticed everyone just kept assaulting poor Sn0_Man so I thought it would be more constructive to focus attention elsewhere.
|
but you didnt have any followup. You just claimed and sat there on that claim. You didnt focus attention elsewhere at all. Why not?
|
What I meant is that it was a waste of effort to pile suspicions against Sn0_Man and mostly ignore other players when he was innocent.
|
And I did focus attention on you and Sylencia, clearly.
|
On February 28 2014 17:57 Xatalos wrote:
What I meant is that it was a waste of effort to pile suspicions against Sn0_Man and mostly ignore other players when he was innocent.
But you didnt do anything. You claimed and then made 0 effort to find scum. No effort at all. What were you thinking at that time to not push your other suspects now that your TOP SUSPECT is town?
|
Btw I still don't see the supposed scumslip. I just said that the connection between Oats/Sylencia was much stronger than any connection between Xata/JJD.
Sigh, it seems so futile to argue with scum.
|
Zero effort? LOL. I've basically handed the scumteam to town on a silver platter. That's just ridiculous.
|
You said that to Sylencia though.
|
On February 28 2014 18:02 Xatalos wrote:
Zero effort? LOL. I've basically handed the scumteam to town on a silver platter. That's just ridiculous.
You did nothing though. Literally nothing except go, "hey guys im cop".
Its zero effort. You want to show me where you 'found' scum before you claimed?
|
I don't think this really achieves anything.
|
But I'll have to say that surviving and pretty much clearing 3 townies by D1 isn't a bad achievement. Then it's just a process of elimination that the rest are scum.
|
ok yeah Xata intended to claim today. Why did you decide before the night actions?
|
Besides, Sylencia had a classic newbie Mafia opening where he just talked about some "safe" policy stuff. And you, Oats, had a really weird strong townread on BH for the worst reason I've ever seen. So it's not even just process of elimination, but it helps.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
