|
On February 28 2014 09:31 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
This is a very interesting claim though. Very interesting.
JJD why didn't you believe Xatalos' claim? I lied cause I wanted there to be a counter. I figured scum might not counter if everyone was all in on Xat being town.
Xat is 100% the cop because if he was scum he'd have no way to know Sn0 wouldn't be the actual cop which would immediately out Xat as the fake (cause he gave him a green check).
That logic make sense to everyone?
|
Dear Oats,
Why the fuck would we not no-lynch?
just voting is scumclaiming, or near enough
@JJD I don't think cop would return blue, it would return green lol
|
oh wait
I MAKE NO SENSE IGNORE MY LAST SENTENCE
My question to oats stands
|
A 1 in 4 chance that im cop is pretty risky to fakeclaim good call
|
Sn0 would've been a pretty safe person to fake check because his filter doesn't look cop-like at all.
|
If anyone else votes for Xatalos after this they are bad. Don't be bad. It's IML and who knows what can happen.
I like JJD's thought process but don't think it makes Xata confirmed town in any way. Scum need to take chances, it's a fakeclaim game after all. Definitely a point in favour of Xata though.
Today is also obviously a no lynch. Night actions are in town's favour on N1.
|
Sylencia how would you define a "cop-like" filter looks like?
|
When you don't afk from the night cycle because it's too quiet, when you provide search targets to get feedback indirectly on whether it's a good check etc etc.
Sn0's filter was 99% day 1 play plans, and only his PS ever hinted at who to check - but being an afterthought it seems unlikely he cared about the night at all.
|
I'm not 100% sure no-lynch is the right play here. If we lynch syl (and assumming he is in fact red), then doc heals Xat and if he gets a green check then we can always use our no lynch the next day. Which means unless they hit the doc tonight, we autowin.
|
On February 28 2014 11:55 Sylencia wrote:
When you don't afk from the night cycle because it's too quiet, when you provide search targets to get feedback indirectly on whether it's a good check etc etc. Did you post during the night cycle or provide search targets to get feedback?
|
I mean. You just explained what a cop filter looks like and it looks nothing like yours. It looks like Xats lol.
|
On February 28 2014 10:23 Sn0_Man wrote:
Dear Oats,
Why the fuck would we not no-lynch?
just voting is scumclaiming, or near enough
@JJD I don't think cop would return blue, it would return green lol
because both xata and syl will be alive tmr anyway. So we should just kill scum today.
|
On February 28 2014 10:14 JarJarDrinks wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2014 09:31 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
This is a very interesting claim though. Very interesting.
JJD why didn't you believe Xatalos' claim? I lied cause I wanted there to be a counter. I figured scum might not counter if everyone was all in on Xat being town. Xat is 100% the cop because if he was scum he'd have no way to know Sn0 wouldn't be the actual cop which would immediately out Xat as the fake (cause he gave him a green check). That logic make sense to everyone?
No? cops never return roles, only alignments, either green or red.
|
No scum fakeclaims so bad man. Xata's fakeclaim is way too clean and it looks so much like he expected to claim today. Which he shouldn't have unless under huge pressure because he doesn't have a red check. Town cop doesn't want to claim because he outs himself. Syl's claim is townier cause its worse.
|
On February 28 2014 12:27 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On February 28 2014 10:14 JarJarDrinks wrote:On February 28 2014 09:31 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
This is a very interesting claim though. Very interesting.
JJD why didn't you believe Xatalos' claim? I lied cause I wanted there to be a counter. I figured scum might not counter if everyone was all in on Xat being town. Xat is 100% the cop because if he was scum he'd have no way to know Sn0 wouldn't be the actual cop which would immediately out Xat as the fake (cause he gave him a green check). That logic make sense to everyone? No? cops never return roles, only alignments, either green or red.
That's not what I meant. If he claims cop and get's countered by Sn0, he cant very well say that Sn0 is lying after he just told us Sn0 was green.
|
ohhh right.
25% is pretty low. And he could conceivably go like "hahaha I lied, I actually checked other person. I wish I checked you qq"
I don't think it makes xata town at all.
Do you think that it was a good idea of townXata to claim cop with a green check today?
|
|
|
sick so its oats/syl scumteam although we still definitely have to no lynch today.
At this stage, I'm willing to ##Vote: No Lynch
|
Why nolynch guys wtf. What advantage does it give us? No advantage.
|
it gives us 1 real cop check and 1 fake cop check lol
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
