In case I happen to die an early death, here are my early reads to consider.

Artanis
99.99% town. If he's Mafia, I will salute his extreme efforts to radically change his style and basically scream town with his every action (compared to Titanic where he just lurked and bussed me... it's almost impossible to compare these two games).

JJD
Pretty sure he's town. He's seemed very convinced of his own ideas and has pushed them in a way that's felt genuine. He also made some decent points about Sn0_Man.

Sylencia
A big null. He hasn't really contributed anything or taken any stances. Originally I thought more town... For example this post felt like he was actually thinking about the game:

On February 27 2014 16:33 Sylencia wrote:
Actually, tbh I don't think discussing scumreads influences much at all - scum probably aren't even targeting the most townie member tonight if they can get an inkling of who is a blue role.

So really, advocating discussing scum reads or not doesn't matter, but saying not to discuss (which in theory makes it harder for scum to choose an NK target) makes you look townier?

I think I confused myself writing this.

But on further inspection, not so much. Maybe slightly Mafia for just being so lackluster overall.

BH
I haven't really figured him out yet. His extremely tryhard start and then just disappearing into uselessness caused me to see red (I really dislike when someone gets less useful as the game goes on - it's typical for Mafia). But he could be just trolling for N0 or something. Null for now.

Oatsmaster
He's been pretty active and had a presence in the discussion, which I like. But some of his filter just doesn't make sense. For example, his (non-)reason to strongly townread BH and his attempt to "bait town" (why would only town attack a lynchbait?). Pretty null for now.

Sn0_Man (!)
I don't really like him so far. He's being so casually lurky and just suggesting stuff rather than pushing things forward:

On February 27 2014 07:44 Sn0_Man wrote:
oke jjd is actively promoting ways for town to lose tho wtf

On February 27 2014 07:47 Sn0_Man wrote:
how many levels deep of "they know that we know that they know that we know..." did you go?

On February 28 2014 01:02 Sn0_Man wrote:
Oke u guys didn't even solve the game wtf

On February 28 2014 01:41 Sn0_Man wrote:
Posting reads in the thread actually gives you insight into what scum is thinking cuz they are guaranteed to take ur reads into account when making NK's.

It can't be bad. If only I had reads.

He's basically a slight / medium scumread right now. He's never directly pushing his opinions and only suggests stuff indirectly or reacts to other posts. I don't like, at all. He needs to seriously step up if he wants to look like a townie. And he also needs some more pressure.

JJD also makes decent observations here:

On February 28 2014 02:10 JarJarDrinks wrote:

Show nested quote +

I saw no indication that you were talking about wifom for a no counter scenario. You said "scum literally can't shoot the [cop]" The only reason that would be true is because of a counter.

not to mention the fact that you know there will be a counter since you made this post before roles were sent:

Show nested quote +

On February 28 2014 02:12 JarJarDrinks wrote:
I also think this post is Sn0 getting pissed off that I was getting towncred my "noob mistake"

Show nested quote +

Blazinghand

United States25555 Posts

February 27 2014 22:00 GMT

#310

i've contributed far more than anyone in this entire game. the fact that anyone thinks i'm even remotely scummy is preposterous. you'll see after the day post.