okay I'm back and now at my parents place. Sorry for the screw up earlier. I had some time to read on the train until my phone told me I crossed my mobile-data limit but I now got the time to explain a little more in detail what I was getting at.

Yes I agree with rayn that the majority of the skanjab "case" wasn't anything and I wouldn't even call anything like that a case but I picked out the very last point because I thought and still think it's legit. The one thing that comes out of my towngames is that I've got a bunch of reads, the townreads are usually always right, the mafia reads are all over the place except for the ones that are based on phrasing, wording and attitude.

Last game I played as town: I told people to lynch Xatalos 3 hours into the game and that I'd shoot him if I was a dayvig so certain was I about him being mafia because he wrote in that special fashion. Obviously flipped mafia and I got modkilled.

The game before that: Marv got mayor, I got 2nd in place, we had 3 people whe thought were scummy and were in conversation with bugs in mason chat. Basicly marv said guy A is the best lynch, bugs and me said guy B is the best lynch, another guy said Guy C is the best lynch and my reasoning, again was on the guy talking/writing the way he did. End of story, all 3 flipped mafia and we fought about nothing.

Last game, the one I was mafia but had reads before knowing my alignment: The only teammade I gave mafiapoints to was Xatalos, again for his phrasing and wording early on. The rest of my teammades hadn't posted up to that point btw.

So as you can see, the vast majority of the my right reads are "weak" reads that are based on phrasing/attitude, I'm only really wrong on that when talking about VE because that dude is all over the place. I still think that one point of Skanjab1s "case" is legit and I do think the phrasing is way off and it makes him a good target right now. I've got someone who probably outright claimed mafia in one of his earlier posts of the game, but rayn will hate me for that because he missunderstood the situation and therefore has a townread on said guy, so I'll wait a little to be more certain about it

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

January 16 2014 18:45 GMT

#436

why are you telling us your life story?? tldr

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 16 2014 18:46 GMT

#437

Sno is likely mafia.

1) I had the same thoughts as skan when reading sno's response to kush's question about why he seems so happy. Most townies just ignore it or dismiss it, instead of providing a real answer (which felt kind of like bs btw).

2) These posts he makes back to back

On January 17 2014 01:10 Sn0_Man wrote:

Show nested quote +

This sounds a lot like "I intentionally made a worthless case cuz its my town meta and I gotta match that".

Which sounds a lot like scum :/

On January 17 2014 01:21 Sn0_Man wrote:
Well I was starting to think that you might have just been trying to get the thread moving and fishing for responses, which would be quite understandable, but instead it seems that you actually think I'm scum or something.

Jeeeeez.

In the initial post he very weakly accuses skan of possibly being mafia. Also, this is probably nothing but the stupid :/ face there doesn't really fit for a townie mindset in my eyes. If you think someone is doing something scummy why use the wishy washy face.

The very next post he then implies that skan is town when he says that skan actually thinks he is scum. This doesn't really make sense unless he is mafia and already knows skan is town.

#vote Sno

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

January 16 2014 18:47 GMT

#438

tl;dr:
when I lynch someone I lynch them for phrasing/wording and I'm good at picking that up
-> I still think that last point of the skanjab case is a good pick up

there's more to it but that's a buildup for later stuff you don't need to concern yourself with

Mig

United States4714 Posts

January 16 2014 18:48 GMT

#439

Grack isn't a bad 2nd candidate. He trolls as town and mafia (I feel like he does it more as mafia tho), so only trolling combined with the fact that while under pressure he just disappeared as soon as thrawn/oats started arguing and taking the heat off of him.