EPTGolden Sun: The Lost Age Mafia Djinn Edition - Page 82
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
| ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:20 Hapahauli wrote: You were asking ritoky to respond to my case, and marv's comment about someone's MZ read was about ritoky.But I'm not advocating lynching ritoky over layabout. I'm advocating lynching Tambo over layabout >> On May 22 2014 07:18 ritoky wrote: Can you start small then? Go with the people you've played with, pick like...2. Any 2 of your choice. Plox to read them and try to get a feel for them and actually conclude stuff. re Austin: I mean, I wish my reads were better too, but so far this game has been very confusing for me. Yesterday turned out to be a very busy day for me, so my attention wasn't at it's fullest in this thread, which is partially my own fault. However, nearly 25% of this thread seems to me to be a group of veterans who know eachother trolling and making inside jokes which I don't particularly get. Thus it is very hard to read a lot of people in this game. I have only read about 10 pages from my last post so hopefully by the time I get caught up I will have better material. If you want my thoughts on particular people, then I will do my best to oblige. On May 22 2014 07:17 geript wrote: You got a long way to go, sir.Slam... Think about Scumeling and answer me my questions three mmmK. 1. On a scale of 4 to 36, how much scooby doo are you? 2. If you were forced into having a threesome, which two celebrities would you choose? 3. Beets or Brussel sprouts? | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
This reveals things about geript, I feel. | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
Everyone should go roast some beets and put some ginger/scallions/oil on em. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:23 marvellosity wrote: I also love "forced" into having a threesome. This reveals things about geript, I feel. Nay he knows who I am. I am asexual, but hetero. Primarily asexual. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:23 austinmcc wrote: Also have I professed my love of beets here? Or did you just randomly pick one of my favorite vegetables/foods. Everyone should go roast some beets and put some ginger/scallions/oil on em. Please tell me you are in the west? My neighbor is the president of OceanMist's desert division, I can get so much fresh produce and he knows the art of Grillen well (see Zatic and blog, and his neighbor is a East German woman who is also amazing but later) basically this is great wisdom | ||
|
27ninjabunnies
United States2486 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + On May 22 2014 00:16 bkqyrldp wrote: When early on in the first day I always like to look how players enter the thread. I find it that mafia has a hard time writing the first couple posts and they often look artificial and forced. I stand by my marv read so far. I think it's more likely he enterss the thread like that as scum than town, and his unwarrated anger after he got called out doesn't read natural either. The rest of his filter is really uninspiring for someone who has been on the thread for basically the whole game, even if you are just skimming. He is bickering on irrelevant points and not asking the right questions, which further enforces my feeling he might be mafia. The level of confidence he later uses to say that we are scum for questioning him on his entering post is also way off. That said I'm willing to give him a pass for today, because even if he isn't town aligned he is capable of uncovering other mafia and if he is town aligned it's a shame to mislynch him in the first day. Also there is a chance that he atracts a bullet too as any alignment so lynching him today is not the highest ev. I still feel a bit uneasy about MZ, but wouldn't lynch today either. I think his posting improved a bit after the the first couple. And speaking of entering the thread as scum, after I reread the thread jampi caught my attention: This string of quotes don't look natural at all. As I've said when you enter the thread as scum you have to force yourrself into a mindset and it often looks a bit off. In this case the level of aggression and "scumhunting" which are normally characteristics of a townie are way over the top and forced, thus I feel there is a strong chance jampi is scum. So when leaving the thread earlier, I asked BKQ to expand a bit on his read of marv, Steve, and MZ, and his response seemed pretty townie to me. His expansion on his Marv read is something to look at. I'll need to read Marv's filter to see if his read makes sense, but it seems as if it does. He didn't give a read on Steve, and his MZ read was still unsupported imo. The thing about Jampi seems to make a bit of sense as well. The thing that I don't like about BKQ is that all of his reads in this post were based off of how the person entered the thread, and didn't really focus on anything they said after -such as Jampi questioning on me (something people have used in their reads- or MZs interactions with others in the thread. I like yell0ws read here. I like how he is willing to address the ones he has played with before. This gives those who haven't played with any of those more insight. However, these reads are based on last game too. I want yell0w to expand on why Jampi is scum, and why he trs poofter and hapa. As geript, poofter, and I have stated- tamburini is a girl. + Show Spoiler + DAMMIT HOLYFLARE. Don't lie to everyone! On the sqrt thing- sqrt posted very short and straight to the point reads. Usually they had some backing to them. He also cluttered the newbie forum by posting back to back, so him not posting often and atleast trying to direct conversation is leaning more scum towards me. I know he claims it is because of how big this game is, but still. I feel as if he could contribute more. Finally, Odin makes an appearance into the thread. And I want to lynch him. Not because of the RNG thing, but his initial post seems crazy to me. And that OMGUS on BH. I mean, that's fine and whatever, he says his reasons as to why, but Idk, just something doesn't sit right with me abut him. Hapa is town for me. I'll look more through hapa's filter to be sure later- but hapa's reads on tamburini this game are spot on to what I was thinking- and the point he brings up about tamburini wanting to kill yell0w, and wanting to kill me for the same thing- when yell0w flipped town is a compelling argument. I forgot there was an austin in this game. I'll leave you with this until I can read some more. I'm on page like... 68 or something. also, the BH thing. I see your point. It can confuse scum. But it just seemed really odd to me that he did it at THAT point. | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:26 Alakaslam wrote: Atlanta Please tell me you are in the west? My neighbor is the president of OceanMist's desert division, I can get so much fresh produce and he knows the art of Grillen well (see Zatic and blog, and his neighbor is a East German woman who is also amazing but later) basically this is great wisdom  I would super highly recommend slicing em into chunks, roasting in the oven, and adding just some ginger/scallions in oil to it. If you want to Grill em, usually you gotta wrap em in foil and do em whole. | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:17 austinmcc wrote: Also I don't want sheep yet. Does willingness to sheep indicate you AGREE? Regardless of the answer there, whatchoo feel about wishy washiness and small --> large games. Being in a larger game makes you automatically more wishy washy about the greater picture. Simply because PoE is not an option anymore and you feel more lost. The fact he is talking about people that he knows he can read makes him look good. Because he is contributing in the way he would contribute as town. 1) 27ninjabunnies talks a whole lot about herself. I am kinda gonna sheep tamburini's reads on bunnies. I read a post and I am neutral, then I read the next one and I find it defensive and with 1 million I's in it, which puts me off. Then I read the next one and I am back to neutral. Idk, it just leaves me a bit skeptical because last game I played with her she was oozing town out of her pores it was so obvious, and the fact that I don't have that feeling right now gives me pause and concern. That said, she is contributing and typing seriously which is significantly more than most people (including myself) have done thus far. This quote is either a lie, or it is town. Mafia is not able to feel like this. I wasn't in this newbie game nor did I read it but if they both were town and if it is true that rikoty was able to instant read her town than this read is pretty ok in my book. It isn't that wishy washy. There are maybe more sentences than needed but each sentence adds some more meaning. 2) I find the people who were highly opposed to the RNG lynch on day 1 questionable. Especially those who said things along the lines of "I think I am better than RNG". I think if you say that on day 2 you can sell me quite a bit on it, as I would not be in favor of an RNG lynch on any day after day 1. Usually there is enough information to make singinifcantly informed guesses by that point in the game. But when you say something along the lines of being "better than RNG" on day 1, it makes me think that you have more information than I do. Which very likely means that you are scum. The content here is not good. But again it somewhat feels like he actually believes this and is telling us how he sees things. I can see it being true. This time mafia can actually think like this though, it is not solely town thoughtprocess. I have to do a couple things unexpectedly now and should be back in an hour or so to contribute more, but for now my I will at least leave my top town and scum read. Top town: Meapak Top scum: waveofshadow This also felt like something new at the time he posted it. I read it and was surprised. I don't know if scum would risk it. On May 21 2014 15:15 ritoky wrote: This wasn't directed at me, but I just got back and noticed a decent segue for me to give input on this as well. re Yell0w: To me, his play is very much similar to the last game he played. He bumbles and fumbles with the details sometimes but overall I read his intentions are fairly pure for now. I don't necessarily think that because he contradicted himself that makes him mafia, it could just be bad VT play or forgetting what he said. He even admitted he contradicted himself, which is uncharacteristic of scum imo. Usually scum would be more concerned with keeping their story straight and their ducks in a row so early on. re HF/Steve: I think a lot of that is predicated on reads from previous game experience with eachother, which I don't have with them so I can't say. re Austin: null re Ceph on bunnies: I think it is the most substantive accusation out there right now; that said I don't like all of the substance. I think bunnies has a ton of redeeming qualities and has done quite a bit to drive conversation so far, however as I said previously and as Ceph pointed out she seems very defensive in some posts and concerned with self image which is offputting for me. So for now I have her in a neutral area. re Bunnies on thrawn: I think she is trying to shove a square peg in a circular hole. I think she is pushing a stubborn and conservative player who doesn't like making accusations until there is enough substance to make them into making an accusation before he is comfortable. As of now I like thrawn more than bunnies because he chose deliberately to not force out a read or flimsy accusation and stuck to his guns. However, that comes with an asterisk; that asterisk being that when he does talk, if it comes off as sheepish, parroting, or flimsy; then he is probably scum trying to blend in with the current of votes. And just because someone (can't remember) seemed to think my read on waveofshadow was odd. I would say to you: read his filter. I find that he seems to be asking for a lot of information without giving anything back and either ignoring productive talking or actively avoiding it in a lot of cases. Much of what he says is jokes and non-committal responses. He could just be playing trolly VT during day 1, but I read it as more scummy. Could be town sharing his ideas? I already forgot what you wrote about him. But your post was pretty ok. It was something with meta. So yeah. Maybe I won't sheep you now I used my own analytical superskills on rikoty. Your fault really. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:26 geript wrote: Your return does not make my peepee hard Slam. I'm very unconvinced. Why? She squint too much? Now if you wanted that, I say to you: Paige Butcher and Uh Crap too many I say perhaps RNG Natalie Portman? No too famous that benefits movie. RNG Dakota Fanning? Really young? Oh Well I guess not anymore, I guess tha works? Enough of that I tell ye, I would pick those folks because they get along with each other so be less awkward | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:26 geript wrote: Your return does not make my peepee hard Slam. I'm very unconvinced. I just read slam's filter and this post was the only one I found that had substantial content: On May 21 2014 15:05 Alakaslam wrote: Haven't even seen yellow, HF null, Steve town, Austin town, you see me talking about CEPHIRO I am trying to find out, haven't even seen anything NJB said except in CEPHIRO quote Slam's got some seriously weak ass shit going on right now, I think people should really reread his filter and not dismiss him as easily. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
Somebody besides Austin give me something to do mebbe? I dunno I feel like a dumb American watching a game of cricket right now. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
| ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:32 WaveofShadow wrote: This would be such an amazing game to be scum. Somebody besides Austin give me something to do mebbe? I dunno I feel like a dumb American watching a game of cricket right now. Hey Wave I have something for you, pick up your game You've made me so sad so far | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25559 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:20 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: I can't be forced to vote for him, that'd break the rules of an outside bet influencing the game, but I agree to a draw if he's shot by the town. I will certainly vote him if I think he's scum which at the moment I think there are other people who I've previously discussed who are better choices. No deal then | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6786 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:32 WaveofShadow wrote: This would be such an amazing game to be scum. Somebody besides Austin give me something to do mebbe? I dunno I feel like a dumb American watching a game of cricket right now. I literally made a post with a whole bunch of semi-interesting questions for you to answer. Or layabout, ritoky, mtamb. Whatever. Stop being poo. | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25559 Posts
Um, i'm fine with a draw if he's shot by scum btw but i'm not sure you understand how bets work. Like, how could you possibly win? 1. if he's lynched, I win 2. if he's shot by a vigi, draw 3. if he's shot by scum, also draw for some reason 4. ??? unless you really want to bet on him living to end game | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On May 22 2014 07:34 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: Hey Wave I have something for you, pick up your game You've made me so sad so far Yay I was mentioned in a 5k post! I dunno I'm legit having a shit time right now. What have you got besides memorializing me forever in your milestone post? Who are the serious candidates right now that I should look into? I feel like layabout is one of them but to me that essentially amounts to lurker lynch I thinks. Who else? | ||
| ||
