EPTTL Mafia LXIII: Time to Die - Page 126
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
| ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
Maybe serious. Also Grack: On November 18 2013 06:43 Grackaroni wrote: Talk to me about this post. From the first line I get the impression that you liked BC's Grack/Storrzerg scum post, yet you don't seem to agree with any of the reasoning he throws out for either me or Storrzerg being scum. Pretty sure that BC his post came between those 2. | ||
yamato77
11589 Posts
Vayne - not posting much but he's making more sense to me than I expected Grack - similar to Vayne, kinda scummy (activity-wise) at times but overall not how I expect him to play as mafia Spaghetticus - Doesn't trust VE, seems to be reading well, like his posts BC - We argued but he seems townish coming out of it, like in LXI Mig - Posts make sense, didn't look at notes but he seems interested in the game Coag - not posting much but he never does, basically trusting that he wouldn't post at all as mafia Moc - unusual cases but involved. Pandain - relatively involved, not playing overly trollish like Thug Austin - I like his return to the thread and how he pushes people for activity I have too many question marks, and even these reads aren't that solid. Anyone want to discuss? I'll be around sporadically. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:03 Pandain wrote: Symbol just playing so well atm You're lying! JJakji just did a 39min viking drop! | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On November 18 2013 06:59 supersoft wrote: yeah okay, i hope they really shoot you, so i dont have to deal with your bullshit anymore. I stopped reading, when you started making stuff up: I never said people should vote for mayor based on lynchchoices. I always said people should vote based on the townieness and skill of the candidate. I never said you said that. MAYBE YOU SHOULD READ | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
Beyond that, you found BC coming out of an argument townish. How do you feel about his play as a whole? He's not perfectly slotted into the "has a big townie rush then fades forever" thing that some vet players do when they role scum (can't keep the act going, just kind of ride a couple townie things until they get blowed up), but he's toeing that line. And I'm just not seeing much of substance from him, he follows grack and storr, pokes a little at mayoral stuff without doing anything, and gives a reads post involving the addition of BH and Hiro, who, no surprise, he's scummy on. They're not tough reads to just slot in anywhere. You cool with his specific play as a whole? | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:12 raynpelikoneet wrote: yamato have you realized austin does not really have any scumreads? who do you think is town and why? I'm really lost. I can question almost all of my townreads and I hate games like this. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:06 Koshi wrote: rofl I am not sad. Maybe serious. Also Grack: Pretty sure that BC his post came between those 2. I know it came between those posts lol. From the first line you seemed impressed by BC's post, which makes no sense if you disagree with all of his reasoning in it for me and Storrzerg being scum. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9846 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:13 Grackaroni wrote: I know it came between those posts lol. From the first line you seemed impressed by BC's post, which makes no sense if you disagree with all of his reasoning in it for me and Storrzerg being scum. I am referring to the first line in your 2nd post. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:12 yamato77 wrote: who do you think is town and why? I'm really lost. I can question almost all of my townreads and I hate games like this. People i think are town: yamato, Mocsta, Onegu, Coag, LM, Risen and kush. Like who i can really say i actually think are town. | ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:12 yamato77 wrote: who do you think is town and why? I'm really lost. I can question almost all of my townreads and I hate games like this. Lynch BH, then lynch Vayne. Good follow-up so far. | ||
|
LoneMeow
Finland1396 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:09 yamato77 wrote: Instead of picking apart night phase posts (which seem to be mostly spam), I'm going to give my list of townish reads and try to work out who is mafia from the remainder: Vayne - not posting much but he's making more sense to me than I expected Grack - similar to Vayne, kinda scummy (activity-wise) at times but overall not how I expect him to play as mafia Spaghetticus - Doesn't trust VE, seems to be reading well, like his posts BC - We argued but he seems townish coming out of it, like in LXI Mig - Posts make sense, didn't look at notes but he seems interested in the game Coag - not posting much but he never does, basically trusting that he wouldn't post at all as mafia Moc - unusual cases but involved. Pandain - relatively involved, not playing overly trollish like Thug Austin - I like his return to the thread and how he pushes people for activity I have too many question marks, and even these reads aren't that solid. Anyone want to discuss? I'll be around sporadically. What made you change your mind about Grack? | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:12 austinmcc wrote: Yes yam. You can hide stuff if you want, but I'm interested in at least a rough outline of LM in mason chat. Active? Good active? Beyond that, you found BC coming out of an argument townish. How do you feel about his play as a whole? He's not perfectly slotted into the "has a big townie rush then fades forever" thing that some vet players do when they role scum (can't keep the act going, just kind of ride a couple townie things until they get blowed up), but he's toeing that line. And I'm just not seeing much of substance from him, he follows grack and storr, pokes a little at mayoral stuff without doing anything, and gives a reads post involving the addition of BH and Hiro, who, no surprise, he's scummy on. They're not tough reads to just slot in anywhere. You cool with his specific play as a whole? LM has asked me questions but not much else. I'm just hoping that scum LM wouldn't mason me and praying he's town. Not amazing activity out of BC and his last reads post was ass but his confrontational nature toward me is similar to how he played in LXI when we butted heads. Could he replicate that as mafia? Possibly. Hence why I am leaning townish but I hjave doubts. Like basically everyone. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:16 LoneMeow wrote: What made you change your mind about Grack? Sometimes I sort of agree with things he's posted. Honestly, it's not a strong read. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:15 raynpelikoneet wrote: People i think are town: yamato, Mocsta, Onegu, Coag, LM, Risen and kush. Like who i can really say i actually think are town. Why do you think Onegu is town? Otherwise, I might actually kind of like this list for people to just not worry about until later. | ||
|
Artanis[Xp]
Netherlands12968 Posts
On November 18 2013 05:56 austinmcc wrote: + Show Spoiler [snip] + Let's keep talking about LoneMeow, and other people should also weigh in! I chose him just because of me misconstruing what thrawn wanted last night, and realizing I didn't remember much of what LoneMeow had actually posted, although there may be boatloads in mason chat (yamato, y/n?) I see the counter question, but it's really not much. What's your thought on this odd thing that just happened and involves me? Something wrong with rayn, dunno what. I'm confused on storr, would give him a null or if he's experienced, I'm not sure if I should be leaning scum. To me, there's very little there. I was really surprised to hear StorrZerg is not a new player, considering he's played in newbies recently. That makes me a bit confused about how to read him. As the StorrZerg I watched play in newbie game, I'd give him a null, but if he's supposed to be more experienced I'm not so sure if I should be instead leaning scum on him. If he's new he's null. If he's experienced, I DUNNO whether i SHOULD be leaning scum on him FOR NO REASONS WHATSOEVER. He's wishy washy on whether he should do something for no reason. I actually really dislike that bit. Even if he's asking for information, if you read it that way, what's he DOING with his question? He wants to know whether storr is new or not? So that he can either be null or be unsure whether he should be scummy on storr for unknown reasons? While he does ask for the information later, he doesn't do anything with it. Storr isn't mentioned at all in thread after he wants to know new/not, and we still don't know why new/not actually matters (or, given the SHOULD in his statement, whether new/not DOES matter). He's later compatible with VE for mayor, having never mentioned any of VE's lynch choices (or VE). Skan calls him out on this, and LM gives a very very very bland answer On November 16 2013 18:17 LoneMeow wrote: That is the white bread of answers. That is skim milk. He looks town to me and his lynch choices have been reasonable, although I liked the earlier choices more than the current ones I think. You poke at him, and he responds that BC's early reads are agreeable, and he's pushing not pro-town players. Which would mean grack, never mentioned at all by LM, and ... storrzerg? Who LM was either null on or maybe should be scummy on, but was unsure. I dunno. I actually really dislike that filter. Yamato, yamato, yamato! You have now been summoned! Do you care to give any insight into mason chat from LM? Is there...stuff there? I don't think any of the points you've made point towards a scum rather than an inexperienced player that's uncertain and looks for guidance. The fact that he masoned Yamato before starting to chat also shows that uncertainty. If he were on a scumteam, I would imagine he would receive some help from them and sound less uncertain rather than more. A potential WIFOM argument, but I don't consider his reach out for guidance scummy. I think he's just a bit lost. That he mostly asked questions to Yamato compounds that. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 18 2013 07:18 yamato77 wrote: Why do you think Onegu is town? Otherwise, I might actually kind of like this list for people to just not worry about until later. Onegu says exactly what i think. He is so right in everything he says. | ||
| ||
