|
Message GMarshal if you request a ban please ^_^
Also when the game you're sitting out is over!
~GMarshal |
United Kingdom30775 Posts
requesting a 1 game ban for milo109 for not posting at all in a high activity requirement game (he was around because he posted hello once in mafia qt) and also failed to vote
|
United Kingdom10443 Posts
meh just warn him imo
he's kind of new i think
|
Blazinghand
United States25553 Posts
did he sign up, make a single post, then never post for the entire rest of the game?
|
The only thing he posted in thread was "/in" and a "hello" in the mafia QT.
|
Blazinghand
United States25553 Posts
So, he was aware the game started, then decided not to play, or was unable to play. Be a good host and send him a PM and see what's going on. It sounds like he knew the game started, so maybe something came up in his life. His wife died, or he got fired, or whatever. If he just decided after signing up that he couldn't play, or that he wasn't interested, or there was a vacation he knew was coming and never told you about, yeah, there should be punishment. IMO we should find out if there were extenuating circumstances. PM him and see if he replies in the next few days, yes?
|
On July 22 2015 09:13 Blazinghand wrote:
So, he was aware the game started, then decided not to play, or was unable to play. Be a good host and send him a PM and see what's going on. It sounds like he knew the game started, so maybe something came up in his life. His wife died, or he got fired, or whatever. If he just decided after signing up that he couldn't play, or that he wasn't interested, or there was a vacation he knew was coming and never told you about, yeah, there should be punishment. IMO we should find out if there were extenuating circumstances. PM him and see if he replies in the next few days, yes?
I have done/been both of these types before, big difference between them
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
It does matter what people's circumstances are in general, however, he posted "Hello" in the mafia qt 2 days after the game had officially started. So, not only did he actually know the game was ongoing and decided to post nothing in the actual game thread but he failed to inform me if he actually did have circumstances that meant he could not post. I have also explicitly stated several times that the game required high activity. If he could not inform me otherwise that is flagrant disregard for my rules and the people he signed up with (especially the "hello"). He can feel free to PM me with an excuse and depending on it I may lower it to a warning but the fact that he posted in the QT means he was actually around anyway.
|
Blazinghand
United States25553 Posts
Right, I'm not saying he wasn't around, I'm saying, send the guy a PM and see what happened. If he just was busy or decided not to play, then this is 100% appropriate.
|
Blazinghand
United States25553 Posts
No ban list actions for Gaiden Mafia
|
On April 21 2015 08:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:I am a bit hooked up with work during summer (currently 70+ hours/week). But DP, i promise you the blog post. I have already started written it. At least July 27th, noBHpromise. 
Is it a BH promise or not?
Happy birthday Rayn and Kita
|
On July 18 2015 07:01 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +Special Ban List InitiativeThe forum has been slowing down and as multiple long time players are and have been on the ban list for quite a long time, we have decided that this would be a good time to offer a one time deal to clear some bad records and reduce the size of the ban list while getting the TL Mafia Library up to speed. How does it work?In exchange for decreasing your ban count by one, you can contribute to the TL Mafia Library. First, post in here saying you are doing your service for your ban. Next, head over to the TL Mafia Library thread. For one ban, you will need write summaries for Three TL Mafia games which aren't currently in the library. The Mafia XV summary is the guideline for what we expect when you write a summary. Example: + Show Spoiler [Summary] +TL Mafia XV took place in October 2009 and was hosted by Ver and Qatol. It was an invite game with 21 players, 4 mafia, pms and no clues. The most significant set-up feature was the presence of detectives with 6 possible sanity variations. Day one included a mayor and pardoner election. The first day was comprised mostly of discussion of the set-up and how best to utilize the blue roles. Additionally, BC let loose his inner poet and Chezinu came to the shocking discovery that L + Ace = Lace. Several people put forth lackluster mayoral campaigns and pyrrhuloxia won by a tiebreak over Ace. As promised, pyrr chose to lynch motbob who was inactive for personal reasons. Ace responded by pardoning motbob and saving him from the lynch. The following day, Ace claims detective and outlines a plan to check the bodyguard's alignments. After town becomes suspicious of Ace's actions, he proceeds to call a bunch of people dumb and posts a monster wall of text. In response, town lynches Ace with a whopping four votes. In comparison, seven people decided to abstain from voting. At night, Dreamflower saves the day by taking a scummy judge with her to the grave using a well placed mad hatter bomb. At the start of Day 3, L claims to have been hit by mafia and medic protected. Additionally, he claims vet and to be in contact with his medic ally via PMs. In a close vote, Chezinu is lynched for being Chezinu and flips scum. A true tragedy for the Brown. Reduced to a single kp, mafia is now in a horrible position, which is made even worse after their only hit is blocked. + Show Spoiler [Night Hit PM] +From: L [ Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Self Bombing:
Date: 10/31/09 10:08
I kill sugi, who is most likely medic protected and has a bomb on me.
Possibly the ballsiest move ever. Expected chance of victory:
0. On day 4, Midori claims dt, and bc is lynched as a sanity check. He flips bodyguard and a double lynch is passed for the following day. Scum come out with a minor victory by sniping medics on consecutive nights and avoiding the day 5 double lynch. However, things came crashing down on L on day 6 as his thread presence is not enough to save the scum godfather. The mafia team proceeds to concede with the mayor pyrr being revealed as the final scum. Overall, L and Pyrr played a solid game, but was unable to overcome the early hole, which led to the town victory. The easiest way to burn through bans that nobody really takes advantage of is just to write game summaries. They're technically part of the database thread instead of the library now, but I would assume the offer still stands. Plus, they're fun to read. 
On July 18 2015 05:31 geript wrote:
I'd rather see hosting be -1/2 ban preemptively with a limit of -1 able to be saved up at any time by a person. That way, smaller offenses aren't as bad for people who contribute actively, but larger issues (e.g. things that require 2+ games) still have some effect. Maybe -1/4 for cohosting since that's generally only vote counts nowadays.
I would very much be in favour of something like this.
Happy birthday to Kita and Rayn, hope you two are enjoying yourselves <3
|
On July 27 2015 03:40 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2015 07:01 kitaman27 wrote:Special Ban List InitiativeThe forum has been slowing down and as multiple long time players are and have been on the ban list for quite a long time, we have decided that this would be a good time to offer a one time deal to clear some bad records and reduce the size of the ban list while getting the TL Mafia Library up to speed. How does it work?In exchange for decreasing your ban count by one, you can contribute to the TL Mafia Library. First, post in here saying you are doing your service for your ban. Next, head over to the TL Mafia Library thread. For one ban, you will need write summaries for Three TL Mafia games which aren't currently in the library. The Mafia XV summary is the guideline for what we expect when you write a summary. Example: + Show Spoiler [Summary] +TL Mafia XV took place in October 2009 and was hosted by Ver and Qatol. It was an invite game with 21 players, 4 mafia, pms and no clues. The most significant set-up feature was the presence of detectives with 6 possible sanity variations. Day one included a mayor and pardoner election. The first day was comprised mostly of discussion of the set-up and how best to utilize the blue roles. Additionally, BC let loose his inner poet and Chezinu came to the shocking discovery that L + Ace = Lace. Several people put forth lackluster mayoral campaigns and pyrrhuloxia won by a tiebreak over Ace. As promised, pyrr chose to lynch motbob who was inactive for personal reasons. Ace responded by pardoning motbob and saving him from the lynch. The following day, Ace claims detective and outlines a plan to check the bodyguard's alignments. After town becomes suspicious of Ace's actions, he proceeds to call a bunch of people dumb and posts a monster wall of text. In response, town lynches Ace with a whopping four votes. In comparison, seven people decided to abstain from voting. At night, Dreamflower saves the day by taking a scummy judge with her to the grave using a well placed mad hatter bomb. At the start of Day 3, L claims to have been hit by mafia and medic protected. Additionally, he claims vet and to be in contact with his medic ally via PMs. In a close vote, Chezinu is lynched for being Chezinu and flips scum. A true tragedy for the Brown. Reduced to a single kp, mafia is now in a horrible position, which is made even worse after their only hit is blocked. + Show Spoiler [Night Hit PM] +From: L [ Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Self Bombing:
Date: 10/31/09 10:08
I kill sugi, who is most likely medic protected and has a bomb on me.
Possibly the ballsiest move ever. Expected chance of victory:
0. On day 4, Midori claims dt, and bc is lynched as a sanity check. He flips bodyguard and a double lynch is passed for the following day. Scum come out with a minor victory by sniping medics on consecutive nights and avoiding the day 5 double lynch. However, things came crashing down on L on day 6 as his thread presence is not enough to save the scum godfather. The mafia team proceeds to concede with the mayor pyrr being revealed as the final scum. Overall, L and Pyrr played a solid game, but was unable to overcome the early hole, which led to the town victory. The easiest way to burn through bans that nobody really takes advantage of is just to write game summaries. They're technically part of the database thread instead of the library now, but I would assume the offer still stands. Plus, they're fun to read. Show nested quote +On July 18 2015 05:31 geript wrote:
I'd rather see hosting be -1/2 ban preemptively with a limit of -1 able to be saved up at any time by a person. That way, smaller offenses aren't as bad for people who contribute actively, but larger issues (e.g. things that require 2+ games) still have some effect. Maybe -1/4 for cohosting since that's generally only vote counts nowadays. I would very much be in favour of something like this.
I wouldn't. Why would we want cohosts who only do it because they have to and do not really care about the game? Why would we want to shorten the punishments we hand out anyways?
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On July 27 2015 03:38 Onegu wrote:
Happy birthday Rayn and Kita
On July 27 2015 03:40 Half the Sky wrote:
Happy birthday to Kita and Rayn, hope you two are enjoying yourselves <3
Thanks! :D
|
On July 27 2015 04:34 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On July 27 2015 03:40 Half the Sky wrote:On July 18 2015 07:01 kitaman27 wrote:Special Ban List InitiativeThe forum has been slowing down and as multiple long time players are and have been on the ban list for quite a long time, we have decided that this would be a good time to offer a one time deal to clear some bad records and reduce the size of the ban list while getting the TL Mafia Library up to speed. How does it work?In exchange for decreasing your ban count by one, you can contribute to the TL Mafia Library. First, post in here saying you are doing your service for your ban. Next, head over to the TL Mafia Library thread. For one ban, you will need write summaries for Three TL Mafia games which aren't currently in the library. The Mafia XV summary is the guideline for what we expect when you write a summary. Example: + Show Spoiler [Summary] +TL Mafia XV took place in October 2009 and was hosted by Ver and Qatol. It was an invite game with 21 players, 4 mafia, pms and no clues. The most significant set-up feature was the presence of detectives with 6 possible sanity variations. Day one included a mayor and pardoner election. The first day was comprised mostly of discussion of the set-up and how best to utilize the blue roles. Additionally, BC let loose his inner poet and Chezinu came to the shocking discovery that L + Ace = Lace. Several people put forth lackluster mayoral campaigns and pyrrhuloxia won by a tiebreak over Ace. As promised, pyrr chose to lynch motbob who was inactive for personal reasons. Ace responded by pardoning motbob and saving him from the lynch. The following day, Ace claims detective and outlines a plan to check the bodyguard's alignments. After town becomes suspicious of Ace's actions, he proceeds to call a bunch of people dumb and posts a monster wall of text. In response, town lynches Ace with a whopping four votes. In comparison, seven people decided to abstain from voting. At night, Dreamflower saves the day by taking a scummy judge with her to the grave using a well placed mad hatter bomb. At the start of Day 3, L claims to have been hit by mafia and medic protected. Additionally, he claims vet and to be in contact with his medic ally via PMs. In a close vote, Chezinu is lynched for being Chezinu and flips scum. A true tragedy for the Brown. Reduced to a single kp, mafia is now in a horrible position, which is made even worse after their only hit is blocked. + Show Spoiler [Night Hit PM] +From: L [ Profile | Buddy ]
Subject: Self Bombing:
Date: 10/31/09 10:08
I kill sugi, who is most likely medic protected and has a bomb on me.
Possibly the ballsiest move ever. Expected chance of victory:
0. On day 4, Midori claims dt, and bc is lynched as a sanity check. He flips bodyguard and a double lynch is passed for the following day. Scum come out with a minor victory by sniping medics on consecutive nights and avoiding the day 5 double lynch. However, things came crashing down on L on day 6 as his thread presence is not enough to save the scum godfather. The mafia team proceeds to concede with the mayor pyrr being revealed as the final scum. Overall, L and Pyrr played a solid game, but was unable to overcome the early hole, which led to the town victory. The easiest way to burn through bans that nobody really takes advantage of is just to write game summaries. They're technically part of the database thread instead of the library now, but I would assume the offer still stands. Plus, they're fun to read. On July 18 2015 05:31 geript wrote:
I'd rather see hosting be -1/2 ban preemptively with a limit of -1 able to be saved up at any time by a person. That way, smaller offenses aren't as bad for people who contribute actively, but larger issues (e.g. things that require 2+ games) still have some effect. Maybe -1/4 for cohosting since that's generally only vote counts nowadays. I would very much be in favour of something like this. I wouldn't. Why would we want cohosts who only do it because they have to and do not really care about the game? Why would we want to shorten the punishments we hand out anyways?
agree with this
|
On July 27 2015 03:38 Onegu wrote:Show nested quote +On April 21 2015 08:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:I am a bit hooked up with work during summer (currently 70+ hours/week). But DP, i promise you the blog post. I have already started written it. At least July 27th, noBHpromise. Is it a BH promise or not? Happy birthday Rayn and Kita
I am busy.
I'll do it when BH does his analysis.
|
On July 31 2015 05:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On July 27 2015 03:38 Onegu wrote:On April 21 2015 08:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:I am a bit hooked up with work during summer (currently 70+ hours/week). But DP, i promise you the blog post. I have already started written it. At least July 27th, noBHpromise. Is it a BH promise or not? Happy birthday Rayn and Kita I am busy. I'll do it when BH does his analysis.
...
|
Confirming Sicklucker for sitout of Desert Center
|
A few things:
1. WonnaPlay had finished his sitout for Newbie Student Mafia XIII
2. Warning for Flexes for failing to vote and not posting in the Night Phase for activity requirement.
3. 1-2 Game Ban for MoosyDoosy for his poor behavior regarding himself and ruXxar and kept on asking me if people who got modkilled get the OBS QT and felt compromised about telling him if they do or not and decided not to answer him there.
|
I'd actually say a warning is fine for moosey the game was extremely tense and others were bring extremely hostile towards him. Being a newb game I feel its better for him to just get a warning and move on than have to sit out while he could be learning how to better play.
|
Having talked through with LS about the modkill, I think that between Moosy wanting to get himself modkilled (so people would believe his read and wouldn't have to lynch either him or n00bking) and threatening other players (or threatening to threaten other players) that a 1 game ban for MoosyDoosy is fair.
Like I'm not the most even keeled persona online, but it went even further than I expected it to.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
