| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On September 07 2013 02:47 yamato77 wrote: The point of a fucking mulligan is to change your reads. Jesus. That is the point. You never gave any concrete reasons for your reads change. It was all because of "i reread stuff". It's not enough. Why is Sno now town and Onegu scum, it makes no sense to me? | ||
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 02:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: That is the point. You never gave any concrete reasons for your reads change. It was all because of "i reread stuff". It's not enough. Why is Sno now town and Onegu scum, it makes no sense to me? Looking at how they justified their votes and how consistent this voting pattern was with the rest of their filter played a part in me slightly changing my reads. TBH the strength of my reads is always in flux and will change. It's the worst argument in all of mafia to call someone scum because they changed their mind about how they read the game. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On September 07 2013 02:54 yamato77 wrote: Looking at how they justified their votes and how consistent this voting pattern was with the rest of their filter played a part in me slightly changing my reads. TBH the strength of my reads is always in flux and will change. It's the worst argument in all of mafia to call someone scum because they changed their mind about how they read the game. I know yamato. My point is it's something that has been here, in thread all game long. For example your read on me. You have had a town read on me until D3 start. Suddenly i become scum for my D1 and D2 voting. That is something you have had access to before. Why did you not make that conclusion on N1 N2 start? It's really fishy, and the same thing happens with Onegu/Sno. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
If I accept that Hapa is doc (I don't want to) and that thrawn is still terrible at being scum (maybe he isn't?), then I have to consider that 2 out of Sn0/Syl/Onegu are mafia. But I doubt this, because I think the hubbub over Syl not having a fakeclaim is unreliable, both because of host error and because I don't trust Hapa. If Hapa is mafia, he has every reason there to lead you down this road. Plus, why would Marv tell Syl to make this messy sort of claim when it was already clear he was getting lynched? What disturbs me is: 1) Marv is a better mafia leader than that. 2) Why did Hapa want to lynch Syl over the AFK Marv who had solid cases against him? (note, his vote was only on him after he apparently scumclaimed) 3) Hapa and Marv both defended each other throughout the game against almost all rebuke, even on Marv's final day. 4) We have no way to truly confirm Hapa's role as doc because now he can't even use his own role, due to its conditional nature, AND this is a closed setup. Would a scum doctor be entirely out of the question in a themed game of this nature? Why are we presuming this to be normal in any way, shape, or form? It's POSSIBLE that we have a lynchproof townie. 5) Why the fuck would mafia Syl fakeclaim lynchproof? To save Marv? It would never have worked, and Marv would have known that. You ruined nothing, because the plan was so bad it could have never made it out of the QT, if it was even suggested, 6) Messy claims like this almost always come from town, in my experience. Scum would go over every facet of a claim before they risked making one. Also, I question my presumption that thrawn cannot play mafia. It's entirely possible that thrawn has learned how to post, especially having been on a scum team with a leader like Marv. The attitude and encouragement of your scum partners can greatly affect your ability to post things believably. This would also adequately explain the disparity in posting ability between Hapa's recent scumgames and this game. The whole reason I question this is because when I look at how the last day went down, I think to myself "who really stepped up to try at MYLO to solve the game/give their input?" Keep in mind, this is relative, but Sylencia, Onegu and Sn0 were all in the thread throughout the day discussing things. Unusually silent were Hapa and Thrawn, both of which have seen their respective activities slowly decline over the past few days, as Marv's has. Now, I'll admit, taking the step to saying that Hapa fakeclaimed is more risky than presuming that he didn't. But we can't be certain he's telling the truth, and there's enough minor connection between the Thrawn/Marv/Hapa triangle that I feel like it's at least worth discussing before we jump off a cliff trying to lynch someone who may well be unlynchable. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:00 raynpelikoneet wrote: I know yamato. My point is it's something that has been here, in thread all game long. For example your read on me. You have had a town read on me until D3 start. Suddenly i become scum for my D1 and D2 voting. That is something you have had access to before. Why did you not make that conclusion on N1 N2 start? It's really fishy, and the same thing happens with Onegu/Sno. Do you not understand that you WIPE THE SLATE CLEAN when you do something like what I did? As in, your past reads SHOULD be questioned with a heavy dose of skepticism? The fact that I entertained the possibility that I was reading the game incorrectly is actually the towniest fucking thing ever, btw. Scum yamato would never admit he was wrong. However, I have the good sense to know that I have preconceived notions about how players play, and that if I let them cloud my judgement the entire game, I could very well lose. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
Why would scum Yamato NEED to change his reads at that time? | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:08 raynpelikoneet wrote: So do you think Sylencia is mafia or not? Not really, no. | ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
Hapa's town tho so drop that. I'm willing to hear cases against thrawn for sure but you need something better than "maybe he learned to post as mafia iunno". That isn't selling me on a "this lynch is a sure thing" and its MYLO so... I'm not sure sylencia tried to "solve the game" he pretty much just showed up, claimed, then tossed a vote at marv and ran. I do agree that the claim garbage is a bit messed up. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
Why is thrawn town? You say 2 out of Onegu/Syl/Sno are scum, then you accuse thrawn and Hapa. Wtf? | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
You are not sure of anything besides me at this point? I find it hard to believe knowing your skill level. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:12 raynpelikoneet wrote: Actually yamato, you are throwing dirt on everyone besides me. You are not sure of anything besides me at this point? I find it hard to believe knowing your skill level. I'm quite clearly saying that I DON'T really think Onegu/Syl/Sn0 are mafia and that I have LOTS of reason to question Hapa and Thrawn, bro. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:11 Sn0_Man wrote: Well thats progress. Hapa's town tho so drop that. I'm willing to hear cases against thrawn for sure but you need something better than "maybe he learned to post as mafia iunno". That isn't selling me on a "this lynch is a sure thing" and its MYLO so... I'm not sure sylencia tried to "solve the game" he pretty much just showed up, claimed, then tossed a vote at marv and ran. I do agree that the claim garbage is a bit messed up. You cannot possibly blindly trust a claim in a closed setup You WILL lose. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:13 yamato77 wrote: I'm quite clearly saying that I DON'T really think Onegu/Syl/Sn0 are mafia and that I have LOTS of reason to question Hapa and Thrawn, bro. No, you are not being clear in saying anything in your big post. You say these guys are scum, or maybe it's these guys. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:13 yamato77 wrote: I'm quite clearly saying that I DON'T really think Onegu/Syl/Sn0 are mafia and that I have LOTS of reason to question Hapa and Thrawn, bro. Its Mylo. Don't "question" hapa and/or thrawn, prove one or both are scum. I know its a lot of work but the onus is kinda on you right now since ur a scum suspect and all. If you are town and want to win I think you know whats required. On September 07 2013 03:14 yamato77 wrote: You cannot possibly blindly trust a claim in a closed setup You WILL lose. The claim has a lot of shit backing it up like water level falling and debears living (until modkill) and we got to see his PM. No way thats scum lol. Besides I'm pretty sure hapa coulda got a townie lynched yesterday if he was scum and tried hard enough. Say what you will but attacking him looks scummy to me (and rayn, and him, and all the other townies in the thread). | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:11 Sn0_Man wrote: Well thats progress. Hapa's town tho so drop that. I'm willing to hear cases against thrawn for sure but you need something better than "maybe he learned to post as mafia iunno". That isn't selling me on a "this lynch is a sure thing" and its MYLO so... I'm not sure sylencia tried to "solve the game" he pretty much just showed up, claimed, then tossed a vote at marv and ran. I do agree that the claim garbage is a bit messed up. ALSO, RE: Thrawn I could go through his filter and pick out "signs" that I think thrawn could be mafia, but the most important thing is that his interest in this game and the effort he's put into solving it in the past few days has waned to a significant point. Look at his posts since he came out as thrawn. Are they really indicative of a townie, who should be caring MORE about the game as MYLO approaches, or a mafia player who cares less because he thinks the game is already won? Same goes for Hapa BTW. The end of his filter is shit compared to what a REAL town Hapa would look like at this point in the game. He's not even trying, he's just posting what amounts to random spam instead of actually trying to win the game. I mean, when have you EVER SEEN Hapa agree with Rayn? Doesn't happen. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:17 raynpelikoneet wrote: No, you are not being clear in saying anything in your big post. You say these guys are scum, or maybe it's these guys. Just because you can't see the forest for the trees doesn't mean it isn't there. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On September 07 2013 03:18 Sn0_Man wrote: Its Mylo. Don't "question" hapa and/or thrawn, prove one or both are scum. I know its a lot of work but the onus is kinda on you right now since ur a scum suspect and all. If you are town and want to win I think you know whats required. The claim has a lot of shit backing it up like water level falling and debears living (until modkill) and we got to see his PM. No way thats scum lol. Besides I'm pretty sure hapa coulda got a townie lynched yesterday if he was scum and tried hard enough. Say what you will but attacking him looks scummy to me (and rayn, and him, and all the other townies in the thread). If you're town and want to win, you should stop making stupid assumptions. | ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
Replay Cast
CranKy Ducklings
RSL Revival
WardiTV Team League
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
Patches Events
BSL
Sparkling Tuna Cup
RSL Revival
WardiTV Team League
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
