|
On September 04 2013 00:24 kitaman27 wrote:
s&b, in the event that Hassy were to flip town, would you want to lynch Vayne for his reaction to the claim?
not necessarily. his reaction was pretty bad but it seemed more like he was super butthurt about alakaslam than like he had secret extra information. like, he was arguing really hard based on a completely wrong interpretation of what you were saying had happened. idk, it's not like it's not scummy, but i would have to hear some more analysis about why his reaction makes him scum before i vote him.
|
On September 04 2013 01:15 Hassybaby wrote:
Oats, for a guy claiming to not have much time for the game, you relied to that hella quickly
well its 12.30 am now, so yeah now i have town.
Like Im free in short bursts. The next time Ill be on will be in like 22-23 hours.
|
Some updates from BM. One shot cop check on Shiao came back green. Didn't mention anything about sanity and that person's role is weird so take it at face value. Master Yi(3p) also revealed his role name, not validated, but he asked one of the outed members to share it so I figured I'd leave it up to you guys to decide if you want it. Catching up now.
|
kitaman already making pre-flip assocations, something weird is going on over there with him. Im the only one that sees it though apparently
|
On September 04 2013 00:48 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 04 2013 00:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:On September 04 2013 00:27 kitaman27 wrote:
From a game design standpoint, it does make sense to provide the mafia with a tool to disrupt the passing of items that are claimed openly in the thread. Does it make sense there is not a tool regarding that for mafia? A thief type role would also address that concern. Tough to say without the role list. It also wouldn't be out of the question of being a town role. Who are your top two lynch preferences? It's not quite clear.
geript + randombum/alakaslam/hassy. I would like to hear more from them. Also debears looks bad to me. My vote is on geript and will stay there.
|
On September 04 2013 00:59 Koshi wrote:
LYNCH ALAKASLAM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FAUGH!!!!!!!!!!¡¡!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!!!¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!!!¡¡!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
um so ve wasn't master yi?
anyway i read a bunch of hassy's old games. he's like never been scum so i'm having trouble finding a pattern.
i really don't like his filter. there's zero discussion of who might be scum except for an ill-reasoned shoutout at wos (srsly, as far as I can tell his only read is based off of confusing who said what between wos and va?)
and the "oh my action didn't go through" excuse is pretty much the only thing scum could say if they feel caught... but it could also be true...
okay so conclusion: scummy filter + night action suspicion = i'm going to keep my vote on hassy.
i think our other lynch should be alakaslam. i would also support a shiaopi lynch or a geript lynch, since geript is still refusing to play the game.
|
right now i think hassybaby and alakaslam are getting lynched, with geript in a close third. i am okay with all of those choices at this moment.
|
On September 04 2013 01:50 strongandbig wrote:
um so ve wasn't master yi?
anyway i read a bunch of hassy's old games. he's like never been scum so i'm having trouble finding a pattern.
i really don't like his filter. there's zero discussion of who might be scum except for an ill-reasoned shoutout at wos (srsly, as far as I can tell his only read is based off of confusing who said what between wos and va?)
and the "oh my action didn't go through" excuse is pretty much the only thing scum could say if they feel caught... but it could also be true...
okay so conclusion: scummy filter + night action suspicion = i'm going to keep my vote on hassy.
i think our other lynch should be alakaslam. i would also support a shiaopi lynch or a geript lynch, since geript is still refusing to play the game.
Cephiro has a green check/mason/something on Shiaopi, or at least that's how I took his post at the start of d2.
Here's the thing, hassy mentioned his action and the apparent failure thereof WAY before kita claimed his ability and used it.
Did scum hassy have a reason to think he was tracked/watched/whatever? Not as far as I'm aware.
|
oh right
dont lynch shiaopi
he still hasn't done anything but i forgot about the check, we should leave him for now
but clarity, you're wrong about hassy. he didn't claim "maybe my action didn't go through" until after kita did his thing. What he claimed at first was that he tried to protect VE but either his protection failed or VE was double stacked.
|
On September 04 2013 01:57 strongandbig wrote:
oh right
dont lynch shiaopi
he still hasn't done anything but i forgot about the check, we should leave him for now
but clarity, you're wrong about hassy. he didn't claim "maybe my action didn't go through" until after kita did his thing. What he claimed at first was that he tried to protect VE but either his protection failed or VE was double stacked.
Oh okay that's what you meant. Yeah I deconstructed that, but his reaction seemed really genuine. Maybe I'm just a sucker?
Bleh. I also don't like how he had this surge of "fuck it I'm just gonna post till I figure out the game!" and then nothing.
I'd rather lynch geript or one of the lurkers over hassy =/
|
On September 04 2013 01:53 Clarity_nl wrote:Show nested quote +On September 04 2013 01:50 strongandbig wrote:
um so ve wasn't master yi?
anyway i read a bunch of hassy's old games. he's like never been scum so i'm having trouble finding a pattern.
i really don't like his filter. there's zero discussion of who might be scum except for an ill-reasoned shoutout at wos (srsly, as far as I can tell his only read is based off of confusing who said what between wos and va?)
and the "oh my action didn't go through" excuse is pretty much the only thing scum could say if they feel caught... but it could also be true...
okay so conclusion: scummy filter + night action suspicion = i'm going to keep my vote on hassy.
i think our other lynch should be alakaslam. i would also support a shiaopi lynch or a geript lynch, since geript is still refusing to play the game. Cephiro has a green check/mason/something on Shiaopi, or at least that's how I took his post at the start of d2. Here's the thing, hassy mentioned his action and the apparent failure thereof WAY before kita claimed his ability and used it. Did scum hassy have a reason to think he was tracked/watched/whatever? Not as far as I'm aware.
No he had one on Zentor right?
Someone else had a green on ShiaoPi?
|
I really dont understand the thought process of Scum hassy doing this though.
Hey lets claim a medic fail protect on VE because why the fuck not..
Yeah....
|
On September 04 2013 02:01 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 04 2013 01:53 Clarity_nl wrote:On September 04 2013 01:50 strongandbig wrote:
um so ve wasn't master yi?
anyway i read a bunch of hassy's old games. he's like never been scum so i'm having trouble finding a pattern.
i really don't like his filter. there's zero discussion of who might be scum except for an ill-reasoned shoutout at wos (srsly, as far as I can tell his only read is based off of confusing who said what between wos and va?)
and the "oh my action didn't go through" excuse is pretty much the only thing scum could say if they feel caught... but it could also be true...
okay so conclusion: scummy filter + night action suspicion = i'm going to keep my vote on hassy.
i think our other lynch should be alakaslam. i would also support a shiaopi lynch or a geript lynch, since geript is still refusing to play the game. Cephiro has a green check/mason/something on Shiaopi, or at least that's how I took his post at the start of d2. Here's the thing, hassy mentioned his action and the apparent failure thereof WAY before kita claimed his ability and used it. Did scum hassy have a reason to think he was tracked/watched/whatever? Not as far as I'm aware. No he had one on Zentor right? Someone else had a green on ShiaoPi?
Oh that's right. Cephiro said that about zentor. Don't recall what happened to my read on shiaopi now, wtf. >.<
Will check.
On September 04 2013 02:06 Oatsmaster wrote:
I really dont understand the thought process of Scum hassy doing this though.
Hey lets claim a medic fail protect on VE because why the fuck not..
Yeah....
Yeah, this.
|
In case I'm not around for deadline (very likely)
##Vote: Geript
Don';t know who my second should go on though.
Not Shiao, not Alakaslam (He actually made one post that was COMPLETELY coherent and it shocked the hell out fo me, so I might actually be able to read him from now on)
Hassy has some sort of bullshit suspicion on me because I haven't continued to call Hiro scum (despite me not being sure of his alignment to begin with) but I have no idea whether he is scum or not.
I think in the end I might just need to sheep thread on my second vote.
Clarity I trust you, what do you think?
|
Oh right the weird semi-claim by Shiaopi about the messenger thing, whatever that is.
Seems pretty town.
|
Oh I didn't understand the doublevote. I don't have to be sure of anyone else yet, which is good.
Just get rid of Geript and be done with it. I know the guy's townplay and this 100% is not it.
|
Day 1 Lynch
MrZentor (0): Clarity_nl, AxleGreaser
HiroPro (3): cakepie, debears, Felkyr, AxleGreaser, ShiaoPi, ObviousOne
cakepie (0): HiroPro
ShiaoPi (0): Alakaslam
Alakaslam (4): Koshi, Clarity_nl, Mr. Cheesecake, VayneAuthority
geript (4): raynpelikoneet, Alakaslam, cakepie, WaveofShadow
kitaman27 (0): strongandbig
Oatsmaster (2): MrZentor, Cephiro
Felkyr (1): Onegu
Hassybaby (5): kitaman27, strongandbig, Coagulation, AxleGreaser, ShiaoPi
ObviousOne (1): HiroPro
The lynch will happen in at Wednesday, Sep 04 12:00am GMT (GMT+00:00). It is a double lynch and the top two vote getters will be lynched. You can only vote for one person, though. Let me know if I missed something or made a mistake. Remember that only votes in the voting thread count and voting is required.
|
On September 04 2013 02:08 Clarity_nl wrote:
Oh right the weird semi-claim by Shiaopi about the messenger thing, whatever that is.
Seems pretty town.
No somebody claimed there is a rolename+town check on ShiaoPi.
|
On September 04 2013 02:07 WaveofShadow wrote:
In case I'm not around for deadline (very likely)
##Vote: Geript
Don';t know who my second should go on though.
Not Shiao, not Alakaslam (He actually made one post that was COMPLETELY coherent and it shocked the hell out fo me, so I might actually be able to read him from now on)
Hassy has some sort of bullshit suspicion on me because I haven't continued to call Hiro scum (despite me not being sure of his alignment to begin with) but I have no idea whether he is scum or not.
I think in the end I might just need to sheep thread on my second vote.
Clarity I trust you, what do you think?
I think alakaslam is scum... The big questionmark that stops people from piling on is "why claim he has the item d1", but that's just one piece "not scum" against a mountain of "scum". Which post of his are you referring to?
I just cannot rationalize the use of this item and the lack of scumhunting today after being "caught"
Check out newbie XLVI, he was scum and he came across as rational when he wanted to.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
