On August 02 2013 11:05 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: As you can see I've been trying to pick up my posting in the past couple of pages. Started slow obviously.
I'm concerned a little about Stim still. I haven't seen an in-depth post from him, he's mostly just one liners, and nobody has called him out on it at all. I understand why you've looked at some of my posts, since most of them were pretty reactionary, but why has he gotten so little attention?
Stim has my attention actually, and I think he is townie. But main point is, I'm glad you're here. Absolve yourself in detail? Quote yourself will help.^^^^^^
I found his filter to be scummy because of the how he kept talking about all the guides he had been studying. I honestly overestimated him as a player. As you all were quick to point out, he was either bad town or mafia, and his he claimed to be so well read on the game I assumed he was a mafia member who had not quite learned how to play his hand with subtlety. To be fair, I think I was probably a little hard on him, he did get thrown into a rough situation. My estimation of Deus was based off of the first couple of pages I read, where he was being aggressive against reps with what I saw as little reason, which is why I initally questioned his motives. Unwarranted aggression so early seems a bit scummy to me. As I dug in deeper to reps posts though I began to suspect him myself, for the above mentioned reasons, which is why I withdrew my statement against Deus and shifted my attention towards reps.
On August 01 2013 04:31 Zyrre wrote: Was just about the post the same thoughts holy. Noting every single thought in the thread is a terrible idea if you are town. As you say holy, its a simple way for scum to fit in since you dont really have to commit to any single post. But also its not very productive. If you have a thought you should first pursue it yourself and compare against filters/other posts/votes etc and develop it in to an idea or theory, thats the work you are supposed to do as town. Spamming single thoughts and nitpicking on a single post is largely useless.
Sometimes you have to do this. I almost always phone post, pm R1CH if you must. He knows my sprint IP and my TWC, so pretty obvious to him my tendencies.
It is a ton of work to put together a multi-quote post from a phone, though possible.
Oh yeah just saw wifi logo
Well my phone will show dc.rr anyway. But yeah, I think he could even tell you it's usually xxx xxx 0 100- my phone. My PC is 1.
Whatever maybe kinda stupid to give out my ip so that is why xxx.
On August 02 2013 11:16 Holyflare wrote: I want you to read up on Nightcat, it would help make my job easier and I see you haven't really commented on him much.
Ok. Defaulted to zyrre but will switch to nightcat.
On August 02 2013 11:21 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: I found his filter to be scummy because of the how he kept talking about all the guides he had been studying. I honestly overestimated him as a player. As you all were quick to point out, he was either bad town or mafia, and his he claimed to be so well read on the game I assumed he was a mafia member who had not quite learned how to play his hand with subtlety. To be fair, I think I was probably a little hard on him, he did get thrown into a rough situation. My estimation of Deus was based off of the first couple of pages I read, where he was being aggressive against reps with what I saw as little reason, which is why I initally questioned his motives. Unwarranted aggression so early seems a bit scummy to me. As I dug in deeper to reps posts though I began to suspect him myself, for the above mentioned reasons, which is why I withdrew my statement against Deus and shifted my attention towards reps.
On July 31 2013 23:34 Nightcat99 wrote: I will give some opinion.
Alakaslam: I have played with him one whole game, and 95% of the time i still have no idea what he is saying. Dont ask me read about him, Lynch him before LYLO.
Umasi is a little strange to, especiallyy at the middle of the night with slam, but he recovers in the morning, i am not getting alot of scum tell from him.
Gotard is being scumy, Infil made 1 post on day 1 and call a bunch of ppl netural, thats pretty much how you shall feel on day 1 and the throws a vote on him, kind of strange.
I am off rep for now, there was quiet a bit of scum tell imo, but the chance of him actually just being new is quiet high as well, but i would like to ask Rep to point some fingers and tell us what you feel about people instead of responding nonsense.
I would much lynch a lurker then any one thats posting at the moment, but there are still time, every one shall give some opinion on what is going on.
On August 01 2013 10:14 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: Seems really suspicious to me that DeusX keeps trying to nail squishy. Umasi and Alak, why did you withdraw your votes for him? Did I miss something earlier in the thread?
As I mentioned, found Deus suspicious---obviously two of you had as well, and I wondered why you had withdrawn since I couldn't see a reason immediately.
Also, again with the suspicison of him trying to nail reps
On August 01 2013 10:27 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: I take back what I said earlier about Deus...just found that awesome filter tool. Reps does look shady as hell...he has an excuse for everything, and that whole newbie act at the beginning was pretty fishy...I agree with Deus anyway at this point. At some point we're going to have to deal with him anyway, right now he is just muddying the waters.
Here is where I filtered and saw what reps had posted..basically about how much he had read and then all the sketchy signs he was giving off initially. See here:
On July 31 2013 07:59 reps)squishy wrote: So I have read a few TL Mafia games to try to get a grasp of the game. People love lynching people who don't post. What do you guys think of non-posters? Should we lynch them and hang them in the entrance of the town to let them all see that scums are not allowed here?
On July 31 2013 12:21 reps)squishy wrote: Well taking that DeusXmachina has already posted to lynch me Here I am going to remain neutral and NOT lynch him he may be town and, the more town the better right? It is day one and despite him going against me there is no evidence that he scum or an aggressive townsman or something else.
Pfft. 'Scuse me, yeah there is. Coming
I am Hapless Peon (Vanilla Townie) what you claimed to be
All trying to play up his newbiness despite his claims that he's read through all these threads. Just didn't add up to me, which is why I switched to him
On August 02 2013 04:18 Nightcat99 wrote: If we get a no Lynch because you move your vote on the last minute, you and rep is both going to be voted as scum team.
On August 01 2013 10:14 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: Seems really suspicious to me that DeusX keeps trying to nail squishy. Umasi and Alak, why did you withdraw your votes for him? Did I miss something earlier in the thread?
As I mentioned, found Deus suspicious---obviously two of you had as well, and I wondered why you had withdrawn since I couldn't see a reason immediately.
Also, again with the suspicison of him trying to nail reps
On August 01 2013 10:27 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: I take back what I said earlier about Deus...just found that awesome filter tool. Reps does look shady as hell...he has an excuse for everything, and that whole newbie act at the beginning was pretty fishy...I agree with Deus anyway at this point. At some point we're going to have to deal with him anyway, right now he is just muddying the waters.
Here is where I filtered and saw what reps had posted..basically about how much he had read and then all the sketchy signs he was giving off initially. See here:
On July 31 2013 07:59 reps)squishy wrote: So I have read a few TL Mafia games to try to get a grasp of the game. People love lynching people who don't post. What do you guys think of non-posters? Should we lynch them and hang them in the entrance of the town to let them all see that scums are not allowed here?
On July 31 2013 12:21 reps)squishy wrote: Well taking that DeusXmachina has already posted to lynch me Here I am going to remain neutral and NOT lynch him he may be town and, the more town the better right? It is day one and despite him going against me there is no evidence that he scum or an aggressive townsman or something else.
Pfft. 'Scuse me, yeah there is. Coming
I am Hapless Peon (Vanilla Townie) what you claimed to be
All trying to play up his newbiness despite his claims that he's read through all these threads. Just didn't add up to me, which is why I switched to him
On August 02 2013 04:22 Nightcat99 wrote: If Umasi posted something like this 5 to 6 hour ahead i would have been happy to consider a switch , because rep although scummy is no way on top of my radar, and i have stated before that a scum will have a scum team with coach and there is no way they would play like this.
But this is too late, there is no switching at this point.
On August 02 2013 05:19 Nightcat99 wrote: Ok now that we have reach night 1, i would like to stay that i want every one to make a post before then ends about who we shall pressure if in the event they die.
List out names that you feel scummy and people that you trust atm, an hour or so before the dead line so scum cant change their target.
On August 02 2013 05:19 Nightcat99 wrote: Ok now that we have reach night 1, i would like to stay that i want every one to make a post before then ends about who we shall pressure if in the event they die.
List out names that you feel scummy and people that you trust atm, an hour or so before the dead line so scum cant change their target.
And Uamsi , you need to explain yourself.
HWOAOAH!!
A town ish post becomes scummy!
DO
NOT
DISCUSS
TOWNREADS
AT
NIGHT
My giant post has a list of everyone, if I leave out people then aren't the town reads obvious from that anyway? Do you want me to cut out chunks of it or just leave it as it is for more information?
On August 02 2013 05:19 Nightcat99 wrote: Ok now that we have reach night 1, i would like to stay that i want every one to make a post before then ends about who we shall pressure if in the event they die.
List out names that you feel scummy and people that you trust atm, an hour or so before the dead line so scum cant change their target.
And Uamsi , you need to explain yourself.
HWOAOAH!!
A town ish post becomes scummy!
DO
NOT
DISCUSS
TOWNREADS
AT
NIGHT
My giant post has a list of everyone, if I leave out people then aren't the town reads obvious from that anyway? Do you want me to cut out chunks of it or just leave it as it is for more information?
You should only do this at day, or toward the end of the final hour of night.
Can you be online at/near deadline tomorrow?
Hate to wait. -_- but if you give strong townreads at night it's a death sentence.
I am going out tomorrow night so won't be able to post it that late, the latest I could do is 5pm GMT which I feel would be enough time for some mafia to read it. It's actually pretty interesting right now if you look at the voting page alone you can see some potential links already.
EPT
