EPTUmasi, gotard and nightcat99 as mafia and sc_am as a neutral (don't know about role he may just be survivor or sk)
Newbie Mini Mafia XLV - Page 39
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Umasi, gotard and nightcat99 as mafia and sc_am as a neutral (don't know about role he may just be survivor or sk) | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:19 Alakaslam wrote: HolyFlare, do you think Indio is scum? Not so much to be honest, that's why I'm asking about the umasi gotard nightcat link, specifically umasi and gotard on infii is what sparks my interest | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:21 Holyflare wrote: I'm going to tell you a possible scenario and I want to see what you think about it. Umasi, gotard and nightcat99 as mafia and sc_am as a neutral (don't know about role he may just be survivor or sk) Huh! My scenario is Gotard, scam and ???. Yours should be posted as late a you can And is feasible to me but surprised me. Probably because of my strong, unhealthy Umasi bias | ||
|
RDaneelOlivaw
Vatican City State733 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:08 Umasi wrote: It was directed at holyflare, but you can talk too :3 I don't really have a ton more to say other than to direct you towards my posts answering Slam a page ago and my preliminary investigation of gotard. As I state there, I think he is someone who hasn't gotten enough discussion for the way he pressured infinii so early and then kind of fell off as a prescence once it failed to stick. I agree with umasi though gotard did have some good points, even if he went about it badly. I'd really like to know why stim and slam are so convinced infinii is town. If there is a good reason for it I think that further cements gotard as a suspect. Really I think thats one of the key pieces we need to begin unraveling...given the neutral posting of infinii and the strange aggression of gotard one of them is almost certain to be scummy...I'm inclined to gotard, but either way theret is just a scummy taint to their exchange imo. Sorry, this is kind of rambling. Summary, since it kind of rambled: Gotard or infinii is scummy I think its gotard, as I elaborated on above and in previous post We need to hear more about why slam and stim trust infinii We then need to discuss and act on one of them. In my opinion it's one of our most solid reads that 1 of those 2 is scummy, we just need to determine which | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:23 Alakaslam wrote: Huh! My scenario is Gotard, scam and ???. Yours should be posted as late a you can And is feasible to me but surprised me. Probably because of my strong, unhealthy Umasi bias This is just a theory it isn't actually in my post yet, I just wanted to see your reply. I also have other theories. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:22 Holyflare wrote: Not so much to be honest, that's why I'm asking about the umasi gotard nightcat link, specifically umasi and gotard on infii is what sparks my interest Yes, indeed I don't like the attacks on our German Indio Jones. But I didn't see that as particularly scummy. Btw, expect one of us does tonight. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:24 RDaneelOlivaw wrote: I don't really have a ton more to say other than to direct you towards my posts answering Slam a page ago and my preliminary investigation of gotard. As I state there, I think he is someone who hasn't gotten enough discussion for the way he pressured infinii so early and then kind of fell off as a prescence once it failed to stick. I agree with umasi though gotard did have some good points, even if he went about it badly. I'd really like to know why stim and slam are so convinced infinii is town. If there is a good reason for it I think that further cements gotard as a suspect. Really I think thats one of the key pieces we need to begin unraveling...given the neutral posting of infinii and the strange aggression of gotard one of them is almost certain to be scummy...I'm inclined to gotard, but either way theret is just a scummy taint to their exchange imo. Sorry, this is kind of rambling. Summary, since it kind of rambled: Gotard or infinii is scummy I think its gotard, as I elaborated on above and in previous post We need to hear more about why slam and stim trust infinii We then need to discuss and act on one of them. In my opinion it's one of our most solid reads that 1 of those 2 is scummy, we just need to determine which Hell yes RDO. Coming right up you have bamcis within a post. I trust Indio because his analysis has seemed cool an collected, and he has contributed to town. He is in Germany, his posting won't come until later. Quotes of Indio coming | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
| ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:00 Umasi wrote: tbth, I don't know what to think of gotard, since he's always kinda scummy to me, but never REALLY scummy. He goes through times of not scum and very scummy, but at the moment I'm leading only kinda scummy. I actually liked how he picked up on infiis posts, and I heavily agree with him on a lot of points. The way he preformed his pressure is the only issue, but I think he's done more for town than infii. ~I still don't know why slam and stim think infii is town, if you want to enlighten me, go for it, unless I missed a post, in which case, point it out to me~ my thoughts on alakaslam~ upon rereading him, he "felt town". It's hard to understand what he's saying a lot of the time, but I've kind of gotten the hang of it, I think. He has six pages of gameplay in his filter, and there's no reason for scum to be as active as he has been, and he's thrown himself around with reckless abandon. I'm willing to overlook him till later in the game, I don't think he's who we should target lynch wise. reading this is what just added to the theory I asked you about, if you read it in the sense that those 2 are in fact mafia then the link just seems all too obvious | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:27 Holyflare wrote: reading this is what just added to the theory I asked you about, if you read it in the sense that those 2 are in fact mafia then the link just seems all too obvious Did he post this at night? | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
1 page ago | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
Then You've hit it | ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
| ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
| ||
|
Nightcat99
United States239 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:21 Holyflare wrote: I'm going to tell you a possible scenario and I want to see what you think about it. Umasi, gotard and nightcat99 as mafia and sc_am as a neutral (don't know about role he may just be survivor or sk) I am a little confused about this scenario. cause i am not seeing either oUmasi or gotard as scum and obviously not myself..... and the netural read on sc_am, i dont understand how any one can get a read on Sc-am with the limited amount htat he has posted. | ||
|
Nightcat99
United States239 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:33 Umasi wrote: slam what are you even communicating? Right when I think I can understand what you're trying to communicate normally, you post that video t.t Dont get me started. | ||
|
StiMaDDict
Korea (South)313 Posts
| ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:34 Nightcat99 wrote: I am a little confused about this scenario. cause i am not seeing either oUmasi or gotard as scum and obviously not myself..... and the netural read on sc_am, i dont understand how any one can get a read on Sc-am with the limited amount htat he has posted. Nightcat you are only a possibility at this moment not definitive, I do think that Umasi and Gotard do have a link though. My neutral (3rd party) read on sc_am is because I think sc_am is scummy but I don't think that he is mafia because he all out gave up on everything yesterday and voted a no_lynch (Presumably what he thought was a beyond neutral move) so that maybe we would not look at him suspiciously. He has been absent from discussions because his neutral role does not involve doing anything till night times OR he is a survivor and so wants to sit on a fence and be ignored | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On August 02 2013 12:33 Umasi wrote: slam what are you even communicating? Right when I think I can understand what you're trying to communicate normally, you post that video t.t I'm saying his FoS, combined with what he says, implicates ya Sawry Haha now I think I don't die tonight but HolyFlare, please do not forget to post your reads I ask you like the child (@2:55) | ||
|
Umasi
United States1399 Posts
| ||
| ||
