EPTDidn't read my check result?
Boardwalk Empire Mafia: Pick Your Power - Page 177
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Vivax
22290 Posts
Didn't read my check result? | ||
|
strongandbig
United States4858 Posts
Raynpelikoneet -- DEAD UNKNOWN 5, 1 sharrant -- Vanilla (denied Detective) 11, X gonzaw -- Jack 8, X Austinmcc -- Copycat 8, X (green check from Keirathi NK) Sinani206 -- claimed Vote Rigger, green check from Keirathi invention - can only be scum if keir is making up checks or if there are two GFs, which is unlikely, could be traitor until he uses one of his powers Geript -- Vanilla (denied NRA Member) - can't be traitor, wouldn't know NRA had been taken above him, could be scum strongandbig -- claimed detective - can't be traitor as DT is confirmed taken restraining order -- claimed framer, no checks (as a claimed framer, must be considered immune to checks) Keirathi -- claimed NKVD, green-checked austin & sinani, red-checked BM so probably town Mocsta -- claimed Capitalist, green check from vivax - not traitor because of claimed shot on decon - only scum if vivax is traitor making up checks Shelvocke -- checked as vanilla by mocsta, denied DT -- could be vanilla scum ; wouldn't know DT was taken, so denied claim would have had to be a big gamble if he's traitor but also possible Vivax -- claimed parity cop, green-checked austin and mocsta Oatmaster -- confirmed recruiter mason - could be scum, can't be traitor Yamato77 -- claimed vanilla (denied Justice Vigilante) - VT check from snb - can't be scum unless i am, could be traitor scum candidates in order of my estimated likelihood, assuming there's not two godfather bonuses RO Vivax Geript? Oatsmaster? This doesn't really make sense tho traitor candidates Sinani Yamato RO? Recommended actions It's highly unlikely that sinani is the remaining scum, since keirathi would have to be making up checks. However, Sinani's play doesn't make me feel super townie about him. If sinani uses his role, we know he isn't traitor. However, IMO a double lynch today is not good for town, since it just decreases the amount of time we have for our investigative roles to work on everyone. Therefore, we should vote for Sinani, and he should use his vote rigging power to lynch RO. This way if he's lying about his role he dies, and if he's not lying then town can absolutely confirm his role. If he rigs the vote to anyone other than RO, he should be shot or insta-lynched the next phase, and he will no longer have his vote-rig to wriggle out of the lynch. RO should be our real lynch for today. As a claimed framer, we can't trust checks on him, and the safest way to a town victory appears to be through mechanics. IMO he's a better lynch than any of the investigative roles at this time and better than anyone with a check on them, which leaves just him, Geript, and Oatsmaster. Out of those three I think RO is by far the most likely to be scum. | ||
|
strongandbig
United States4858 Posts
| ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
But the better question is, who is he using his frames on? Just not using them? Why not at least throw one on his teammate BillMurray? I mean, no one said we were checking BM; I kinda just made that decision at the last minute because BM wasn't cooperating and said he was "fishing for reactions". RO being scum is not impossible, but RO being scum AND framer seems quite unlikely. | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
| ||
|
Restraining Order
Qatar276 Posts
On April 14 2013 04:42 strongandbig wrote: + Show Spoiler [dead people] + Raynpelikoneet -- DEAD UNKNOWN 5, 1 sharrant -- Vanilla (denied Detective) 11, X gonzaw -- Jack 8, X Austinmcc -- Copycat 8, X (green check from Keirathi NK) Sinani206 -- claimed Vote Rigger, green check from Keirathi invention - can only be scum if keir is making up checks or if there are two GFs, which is unlikely, could be traitor until he uses one of his powers Geript -- Vanilla (denied NRA Member) - can't be traitor, wouldn't know NRA had been taken above him, could be scum strongandbig -- claimed detective - can't be traitor as DT is confirmed taken restraining order -- claimed framer, no checks (as a claimed framer, must be considered immune to checks) Keirathi -- claimed NKVD, green-checked austin & sinani, red-checked BM so probably town Mocsta -- claimed Capitalist, green check from vivax - not traitor because of claimed shot on decon - only scum if vivax is traitor making up checks Shelvocke -- checked as vanilla by mocsta, denied DT -- could be vanilla scum ; wouldn't know DT was taken, so denied claim would have had to be a big gamble if he's traitor but also possible Vivax -- claimed parity cop, green-checked austin and mocsta Oatmaster -- confirmed recruiter mason - could be scum, can't be traitor Yamato77 -- claimed vanilla (denied Justice Vigilante) - VT check from snb - can't be scum unless i am, could be traitor scum candidates in order of my estimated likelihood, assuming there's not two godfather bonuses RO Vivax Geript? Oatsmaster? This doesn't really make sense tho traitor candidates Sinani Yamato RO? Recommended actions It's highly unlikely that sinani is the remaining scum, since keirathi would have to be making up checks. However, Sinani's play doesn't make me feel super townie about him. If sinani uses his role, we know he isn't traitor. However, IMO a double lynch today is not good for town, since it just decreases the amount of time we have for our investigative roles to work on everyone. Therefore, we should vote for Sinani, and he should use his vote rigging power to lynch RO. This way if he's lying about his role he dies, and if he's not lying then town can absolutely confirm his role. If he rigs the vote to anyone other than RO, he should be shot or insta-lynched the next phase, and he will no longer have his vote-rig to wriggle out of the lynch. RO should be our real lynch for today. As a claimed framer, we can't trust checks on him, and the safest way to a town victory appears to be through mechanics. IMO he's a better lynch than any of the investigative roles at this time and better than anyone with a check on them, which leaves just him, Geript, and Oatsmaster. Out of those three I think RO is by far the most likely to be scum. weak stuff. You're not even glancing at my play (prolly cause you know you can't find anything on me), you're just sitting there saying "RO is a framer therefor he must be scum!" And that's the extent of your 'arguments'. Not to mention your post is choke-full of untruths. Keirathi COULDN'T have made up the check on sinani, since sno gave him the invention and knows pretty well how it works. Keirathi red-checking BM is not actually alignment indicative. At that point, BM was already guaranteed scum thanks to his role. If anything, the check is slightly scummy-ish because, as was said multiple times beforehand, BM's role showed it's alignment automatically. So checking him was actually bad play, but whatevs. Double-lynch today does absolutely NOTHING to decrease the amount of time we have. 9-1 6-1 4-1 2-1 vs 9-1 7-1 5-1 3-1 Exact same amount of time. Sinani activating doublelynch will confirm his role just as well. As Framer, checks on me would actually be the ONLY thing you could trust. For I am the only person I cannot make appear differently. So, your setup-talk is full of bull. And you don't have any arguments outside of your setup talk. Why are you not acting like you're suspicious of Shelvocke? He claimed VT going for showtime (which is another instance of you speaking the untruth btw), and the only check on him was the vanilla rolecheck. He claimed that waaaay after caller was confirmed showtime, so it's not even hard. Which means he can still be goon (Caller confirmed town yo) or even traitor (appears as VT) It's like you're not even thinking about your own arguments. I'm feelin pretty good about my vote. | ||
|
sinani206
United States1959 Posts
I will kill whoever town agrees on with the rig to prove I have it. | ||
|
sinani206
United States1959 Posts
| ||
|
sinani206
United States1959 Posts
On April 14 2013 05:50 sinani206 wrote: ##Vote: Sinani206 I will kill whoever town agrees on with the rig to prove I have it. Wait snb is dumb and probably scum... I'm not following his plan, I'll just rig my own vote to prove I have it. No need to fuck with the rest of the votes. | ||
|
Vivax
22290 Posts
| ||
|
strongandbig
United States4858 Posts
On April 14 2013 05:53 sinani206 wrote: Wait snb is dumb and probably scum... I'm not following his plan, I'll just rig my own vote to prove I have it. No need to fuck with the rest of the votes. this works too | ||
|
strongandbig
United States4858 Posts
On April 14 2013 04:49 Keirathi wrote: RO can't frame himself. But the better question is, who is he using his frames on? Just not using them? Why not at least throw one on his teammate BillMurray? I mean, no one said we were checking BM; I kinda just made that decision at the last minute because BM wasn't cooperating and said he was "fishing for reactions". RO being scum is not impossible, but RO being scum AND framer seems quite unlikely. oh i didnt realize that he couldnt frame himself. well who do you think we should lynch today? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On April 14 2013 05:50 sinani206 wrote: ##Vote: Sinani206 I will kill whoever town agrees on with the rig to prove I have it. Why are you martyring? We dont want you dead. We want Vivax dead. Pls organise his death. | ||
yamato77
11589 Posts
Ugh. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Why vote himself regardless. wats the point. Its pretty clear who the town wants dead; so why bother to make this. just do the fucking action. | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
On April 14 2013 13:01 Mocsta wrote: Ugh? Why vote himself regardless. wats the point. Its pretty clear who the town wants dead; so why bother to make this. just do the fucking action. It doesn't fucking matter who he votes if he's just going to rig the lynch anyway. Come on. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Stop wasting my time. I asked him clearly to rig Vivax | ||
|
yamato77
11589 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
| ||
|
Shelvocke
Grenada70 Posts
| ||
| ||
