RED Team's Prize - Page 46

On March 27 2013 23:56 Palmar wrote:


Except he isn't right now. Which is what worries me.

As marv himself recognized I'm taking the "sit back but watch" approach to looking at him, but we're closing in on lynch time and he doesn't really seem to care how the lynch goes.

On March 27 2013 23:57 prplhz wrote:
@Palmar Why isn't Acrofales scum?

On March 28 2013 00:01 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Palmar why did you think the vigi-shot was surely from mafia without thinking it out properly? It looks like you wanted the shooter to claim if they are town which would be dumb, as already pointed out, if it's a JOAT and not a one shot vigi.

On March 27 2013 23:59 marvellosity wrote:


I've made it pretty clear who I want to lynch, and your response "I'm ignoring that player" doesn't help.

I'm going to say this only once, so you guys can take it or leave it. I had a horrible experience in Personality where I spammed way too much, got overemotional, got tunnelled, and got blinded. So much so that I barely read more than a couple of filters that game. This game I'm trying to turn my back on all that and take a bird's eye view. Is this a possibly convenient excuse for an uninvested mafia-marv? Sure. But it's not the case. Anyway, I'm not going to mention it again.

On March 28 2013 00:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:
And what makes you so sure Oats is town?

On March 28 2013 00:01 Palmar wrote:


Did you read his posting so far? He's very clearly reading the thread and putting effort in his posts. Even if he is scum, which is a possibility (him realizing marv might be burned by the Personality mafia stuff and his response to my case on Grack are both somewhat strange), he is not playing scum you can catch without any information.

I cannot say he isn't scum, but I can say I'm not lynching him right now.

On March 27 2013 09:36 Palmar wrote:

That question is so stupid, just like your claim. Since I think you're town, yet you're playing like an idiot I'm just going to ignore you for the rest of the game since you're clearly not capable of playing well.

On March 28 2013 00:05 prplhz wrote:

Well, actually you said in this post



that you think he's town. So you can say that you think he is town but you cannot say that he isn't scum or what exactly are you saying?

On March 28 2013 00:02 Palmar wrote:


That's a stupid question.

On March 28 2013 00:07 marvellosity wrote:


I'm going to answer for Palmar because this is silly. Very rarely are things binary in mafia. Having a town-read on someone doesn't mean you 100% think they're town.

How about that Nisani meta you promised me?

On March 28 2013 00:13 prplhz wrote:
"I can fight my own battles"

"I'm going to answer for Palmar"

On March 28 2013 00:12 prplhz wrote:

My problem is that in Palmar's reasonable for why Acrofales is town, he's actually spending more time explaining why he could be scum. I don't see what it is that you all see in Acrofales. I get that we're not lynching him today because he's reasonably active and there's probably nothing damning about him, but I'm still interested in why you actually all think he's so townie because I'm getting more of a Personality 2 feeling about him.

On March 28 2013 00:03 marvellosity wrote:
Acro is my strongest townread out of Hapa/Palmar/Acro. In addition to investment blabla, some of his posts are craycray, like at points in the first half of Duel, and MTG2. The Acro-mafia I played with in Personality was way more measured.

On March 28 2013 00:24 cDgCorazon wrote:
Bleh all I know is that this lynch is not going to come easy. Too many scum candidates and too little time.

I do think Palmar's reasoning for why Grack's shot does not make him scum is valid. It really does not make sense to tie yourself to voting for a person and tunneling them, then go on to shoot them. Doesn't make sense.

Acro is a bit of a harder read. I really cannot tell what he is playing right now, so I won't vote for him on D1. Too much confusion to risk a vote there. I'm worried that Marv is his top scum read, yet he only gave superficial reasons as to why Marv is scum. Marv's defense seems in line with him trying to play a better game, plus his stupid mini-tunnel of me feels way too much like Personality for me to be suspicious now.

Smurf still needs to commit himself to actually scum hunting and not bouncing around multiple targets. Right now he's looking most likely to get my vote.

Prp, now that Grack is dead, can you stop beating around the bush and give us actual reasons as to why Acro could be scum? A vote for anything would be nice too.