Nomination Mafia - Page 78

On February 14 2013 17:10 Oatsmaster wrote:
My apologies.

Do you have any other scum reads?
Can you try and convince me?

READ MY POSTS WHERE I NAME CC AND OATS AS MAFIA

On February 14 2013 16:41 yamato77 wrote:
If Mocsta and Sloosh are town, and read town by everyone, why would mafia even try to put them up again? Um because mafia wants to kill the towniest looking townie duh

Wouldn't they try to put up different people that others read town in the hopes that they get lynched instead? Why then they make it easier to see who mafia wants to kill

Doesn't the idea of using it as an NK necessitate that people actually want to lynch the people you're putting up, a la Palmar day 1?

So why pick CC? Because they want him dead. Why? Because he's town. By the virtue of how the lynch went down day 2, there is zero reason to think that CC is actually mafia, ALL WIFOM Something called a hard bus my friend and that lynching him today is at all a good idea, EVEN IF you think all three people are town, because he is the absolute LEAST likely to be mafia of the three. You state this like its fact with out showing any evidence to back it up

So why not lynch Mocsta or Sloosh? At this point I'll take either, because I think they both might be mafia, but I prefer Mocsta because I'm more confident in him than Sloosh. We need to talk about this and not just randomly sheep our votes somewhere, because that is what mafia would want us to do in this situation.

That's why I asked jay to comment, and why him not commenting is damning evidence in my eyes. Yea god forbid I leave my computer If Mocsta and Sloosh are both mafia Rofl are you kidding me this is a giant stretch now your just grasping for straws again no evidence to back it up, jay has been pushing the same agenda as them the whole game, right up to right now. They don't want us to think about the lynch today because there is actually a chance at catching mafia if we do.More WIFOM They want us to think that all three are town, and that our choice barely matters.

BUT IT DOES MATTER. Read my analysis of the likelihood of the nomination possibilities. I don't think mafia would ONLY put up town players the whole game. Your analasis is guess what ALL WIFOM THERE IS A REASON GOOD PLAYERS DON'T SPECULATE ON NIGHT KILLS They would almost certainly take chances, especially with the first nomination. They could put up a town player EVERYONE wants to lynch and bet that he doesn't prove himself town This is just bullshit I didnt want to lynch Palmar Also if anything Sloosh would of been the person taht was afk day 1 he was the most likely to die , and then slap ANYONE next to him for a safe way to gain town cred. It especially works if everyone think they are all town anyway.

But their mistake was doing it twice, because it made it too obvious. There's no fucking way mafia would put up two guys that were clearly not getting lynched day 2 again day 4 if both of them were town.WIFOM They would if they were mafia, though.

On February 14 2013 18:30 Oatsmaster wrote:
Jay,
who is scum? Since you think that everyone up for lynch today is town?

So I instead choose to focus on someone like phagga, on whom no one has commented on.

Let's be clear with our language. I never called Phagga scum. Just because I'm interested in a person doesn't mean I think they are scum.

Additionally, be clear with your language. I don't mind you saying "I want to see more", but don't say "start contributing" as if I haven't done anything. Cause that's total b.s.

I have almost no doubt I'll be up for nomination tomorrow so I'm going to sit on my reads until dawn.
Because I'm definite that scum will always put 3 townies up - they won't bother risking putting one of their own into the group unless it is certain that someone else will get lynched. And right now, it doesn't look like that's gonna happen.

I assume I'll get put up because I tend to get shot N1 and I guess it's just ingrained into me that scum want me gone soon and fast.

If you familiarize yourself with his meta (nicely displayed in his profile and devoid of any scum games), it becomes clearer that he is new scum whose play pales to his town play.

- in this game phagga writes timidly, fluffily and without conclusions
- town phagga is capable of decent analysis, or at least confidence and clarity in his posts

On February 14 2013 19:34 Oatsmaster wrote:
I think slOosh is scum because


He says, I am so helpful to town guys. This rubs me as scummy because town doesnt care about how well they are playing, just care about finding and lynching scum.



He is really concerned about people misinterpreting his words, in other words, It means that he wants to look really townie.
Only scum care about looking townie.


They way he is so sure that he will be picked d2 as one of the nomination candidates is really odd. Especially since he justifies it as 'I always die n1, so scum want me gone soon and fast' when if he plays good enough to get shot n1, he is never gonna get lynch d2, no matter who is up with him.

And a quick summary which basically states the description of a town and a scum. No links where phagga is doing the thing he says. This at best is lazy, and at worst is slOosh trying to mislead us with a post that looks good with no substance.

slOosh says, 'Shut up, I have described the situation so I can explain why I have been chosen tomorrow. Now, dont talk so scum has an advantage due to the lack of information town has.'

He posts the phagga case and just keeps asking people to read and opinions. This is to see if he should push the phagga lynch tomorrow.

He says this, but never fully explains why VE is scum, just snipes at him and basically asks Palmar to make his case for him.

Random defense of Jay for basically slight pressure. Scum want to defend someone so that they can buddy them subtly by 'helping' them.

Really weird post where he says, 'I am bad and you guys are totally better at the game as me' Town wouldnt want to say that because no one will take his reads seriously anymore. Scum would because they seem apologetic and cooperative.
So much buddying of CC here.

Keeps going with the self-depreciating attitude, and tries to buddy me too.


Again, 2 really cooperative and 'helpful' posts. And again self-depreciating

At this point, I would assume that slOosh has really strong reads.

And a totally lazy case which he does NOT back up at all with anything, and in fact
Pushes phagga as an association case.
I saw scum doing this too.

On February 15 2013 00:21 phagga wrote:
prplhz: What is your stance on Mr. Cheesecake now after yesterdays events?

Also:



There is no reason as a townie to ask for your mislynch, and you should know it. What the hell are you trying to achieve?

On February 15 2013 00:55 phagga wrote:
If you look at the nomination for D1, you see a lurking Palmar, a sloosh that just got heat for his low activity on the end of D1 and a Mocsta who has established himself as town. Therefor, if any of the three are mafia, Mocsta is your best bet, as the chances at start of D1 look pretty good for him. However, in that case the scum team would have known that sloosh and Palmar are town. They must have seen slooshs post that he will be more active D2 and prove that he is indeed town. Also, Palmar could come back any time, bring out his best play and rape the scum team (noone knew why he was lurking at that point). Do you really think that with this knowledge, the scum team would risk a player that has established himself successfully as town?

I personally doubt it.

On February 15 2013 00:55 phagga wrote:
If you look at the nomination for D1, you see a lurking Palmar, a sloosh that just got heat for his low activity on the end of D1 and a Mocsta who has established himself as town. Therefor, if any of the three are mafia, Mocsta is your best bet, as the chances at start of D1 look pretty good for him. However, in that case the scum team would have known that sloosh and Palmar are town. They must have seen slooshs post that he will be more active D2 and prove that he is indeed town. Also, Palmar could come back any time, bring out his best play and rape the scum team (noone knew why he was lurking at that point). Do you really think that with this knowledge, the scum team would risk a player that has established himself successfully as town?

I personally doubt it.