We could have 2 blues that are both not doctors and neither one could counterclaim, but he would still be fake claiming. Even if we can counterclaim, doing so gives scum a really easy target and we trade Oats for our doc.

I'm not sold on this idea at all.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

November 29 2012 16:15 GMT

#902

On November 30 2012 01:14 Kickstart wrote:
Now I am pissed at Oats and SDM so I can't make sense of shit atm.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

November 29 2012 16:16 GMT

#903

OR I COULD BE TELLING THE FUCKING TRUTH ABOUT ME BEING A DOCTOR.
anyone who thinks otherwise is clearly scum because then want to get blue roles lynched.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

November 29 2012 16:16 GMT

#904

On November 30 2012 01:14 yamato77 wrote:
We could have 2 blues that are both not doctors and neither one could counterclaim, but he would still be fake claiming. Even if we can counterclaim, doing so gives scum a really easy target and we trade Oats for our doc.

I'm not sold on this idea at all.

Oh yeah cop jailkeeper... (I would assume we have two blues) a mass role claim would probably be a bad idea at this point as well.

yamato77

11589 Posts

November 29 2012 16:16 GMT

#905

Whatever guys. You play this setup game with Oats to figure out if he's really claiming or not and I'll go actually scumhunt.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

November 29 2012 16:17 GMT

#906

But! If they have a role blocker then they can block oats assuming he is doc.

yamato77

11589 Posts

November 29 2012 16:17 GMT

#907

Just realize that you're playing right into his hands if he's really scum.

yamato77

11589 Posts

November 29 2012 16:20 GMT

#908

Also SDM you need to explain why you think kick's posts imply scum thinking,

Sonic Death Monkey

Sweden991 Posts

November 29 2012 16:22 GMT

#909

My head is hurting. Is there any way we can counterclaim this shit? We need to figure this out.

I'll explain after this have settled. We need to figure this counterclaiming hassle out. It was kind of an emotional comment but yeah, to me it seems like scum mindset. Not an "OMG scumslip", just a way in his thinking that really didn't resonate with how I was thinking.

Sonic Death Monkey

Sweden991 Posts

November 29 2012 16:24 GMT

#910

The only way counterclaiming can backfire is if we have both JK and doc. True or false?

Chromatically

United States1700 Posts

November 29 2012 16:24 GMT

#911

Looking at the scenarios, we pretty much have to ask for a counterclaim...

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

November 29 2012 16:25 GMT

#912

I am going to sleep now, will be back like 2 hours before the lynch, hopefully you guys can find some scum: :D
About counterclaiming, its not going to happen. So town shouldnt counterclaim because it gives more targets for the scum to hit. I am a doctor not a mafia goon or gf or framer or roleblocker.