No because I think a lot of acro's logic theories, like the one that cleared prome, went out the window when DP claimed blue.

So if DP is telling the truth, I think there is also a real possibility of prome scum.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 19:52 GMT

#1702

kush the prob with taking a "safe" option and voting for sk is because we don't know who is sk... based on past setup speculation we've pretty much narrowed it down to either you/risk/release. so how are we supposed to distinguish between choosing you or release for sk?

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

November 11 2012 19:53 GMT

#1703

On November 12 2012 04:52 thrawn2112 wrote:
kush the prob with taking a "safe" option and voting for sk is because we don't know who is sk... based on past setup speculation we've pretty much narrowed it down to either you/risk/release. so how are we supposed to distinguish between choosing you or release for sk?

ya i get that but it;s easier for me because I know my alignment lol

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 20:02 GMT

#1704

so the thing that most people think makes kush the sk was the vt hunting... but that whole flavor theory was based off the fact that kush was comparing claimed vt flavor names against his "own." so if we collectively decide that shooting for sk is a better option than lynching risk then I might be persuaded to vote for release.

Release

United States4397 Posts

November 11 2012 20:05 GMT

#1705

If the scum had fakeclaims, then why not the SK?
Surely, Kush's "own" name, to which he could be comparing the other VT names, could be his fakeclaim

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 20:08 GMT

#1706

I've never rolled scum but I have rolled sk. When I rolled sk, I actually did notice that I was playing a little differently than normal... I spent more time worrying about the scuminess of my posts and fearing that people would call me out. It's that same mindset that I've recognized in release's play.

But kush, what is your main reason for not thinking risk is a safe lynch? The massive amount of blue claims? I've been thinking about it, and it's not as if we have 6 real blues. I'm a 1 shot and fuba claimed 1 shot. zealos was also 1 shot.

The only problem I have with voting for risk is because I think there's probably a scum roleblocking type role, which imo would either be dp or fuba. But roleblocks can stack and we don't have full information so I'm not comfortable just lynching both fuba/dp hoping that one of them fakeclaimed.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 20:09 GMT

#1707

On November 12 2012 05:05 Release wrote:
If the scum had fakeclaims, then why not the SK?
Surely, Kush's "own" name, to which he could be comparing the other VT names, could be his fakeclaim

Yeah I guess so. Yet another reason why I still want to lynch risk based on behavior.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

November 11 2012 20:09 GMT

#1708

Nvm I don't suspect DP anymore. Read his filter and it's not realistic to think of his draz case as a bust.
Also I realize now I misrepresented his play quite a bit He's playing fine.
.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 20:13 GMT

#1709

I also think dp is town, just from reading his filter without considering a fake claim. He may not like this reasoning, but my impression of town dp is a stubborn angry guy who likes his cases and likes yelling at people who disagree. And lol, that's what I've seen this game. What I saw from scum dp in LC was a toned down version of dp who was not that stubborn.

+ Show Spoiler +

sorry dp <3

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

November 11 2012 20:14 GMT

#1710

yeah if you read his filter with an Australian accent in your mind it seems way more town. I think this is the key to reading dp.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 21:28 GMT

#1711

##unvote
##vote mkfuba

HiroPro

United States2624 Posts

November 11 2012 21:38 GMT

#1712

Day 4 Vote Count

risk.nuke (5): ~~thrawn2112~~, Release, Promethelax, mkfuba07, DarthPunk, kushm4sta

kushm4sta (0): ~~Release~~

Release (0): ~~kushm4sta~~

DarthPunk (1): risk.nuke

mkfuba07 (1): thrawn2112

risk.nuke set to be lynched. Deadline in 1.5 hours at 23:00 GMT (+00:00).

mkfuba07

United States1151 Posts

November 11 2012 21:46 GMT

#1713

Care to share your reasoning? Because I am what I've claimed to be.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 21:50 GMT

#1714

1: This game has a ridiculous amount of blues
2: I thought you were convinced that I was scum. You changed you mind citing that my breadcrumb was good but in your original case against me, the breadcrumb was something you had major issues with
3: You're voting risk based off of process of elimination
4: You claim/breadcrumb was... not good.
6: The game's more interesting this way

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 21:52 GMT

#1715

7: You have a tiny filter and your biggest posts have been defenses of yourself, or a case against me which you went back on.. I'd like to hear more about your read on me