|
On October 06 2012 12:09 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On October 06 2012 12:07 Coagulation wrote: anyone else see a scummy post above me? why because the post says absolutely nothing? yes i don't like it either.
LoL. People saying nothing/ sheeping cases. Welcome to half the players in this game.
Care to provide a reason for your town read on Kush? or are you just going to ignore me?
|
On October 06 2012 12:23 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On October 06 2012 12:18 DarthPunk wrote:On October 06 2012 12:09 iamperfection wrote:On October 06 2012 12:07 Coagulation wrote: anyone else see a scummy post above me? why because the post says absolutely nothing? yes i don't like it either. LoL. People saying nothing/ sheeping cases. Welcome to half the players in this game. Care to provide a reason for your town read on Kush? or are you just going to ignore me? yes i will. i have very good reason if you were paying attention i said my view hinges on the fact of my observation (redacted because of ongoing game). I dont know how much clearer i can be because of that so if you have patience i will be clear. Or you can continue to waste time and not hunt scum choice is your. also i dont really care what you think. i don't even care if i contradict myself i will say what i want if i think someone might be scum.
Wow, Way to promote an anti town atmosphere. I completely disagree with the fact that you do not have to give more reasoning than a 'gut read' which by definition is unclear. I get it. You do not give a fuck about anyone and will do what you want. Fine. But don;t expect people to actually listen to you if you won't do us the courtesy of being clear and transparent about stuff like Why you give one of the scummiest players in the game a town read.
You know what? FoS: Iamperfection Clearly anti town attitude. Difficult and refusal to be transparent.
|
On October 06 2012 12:55 austinmcc wrote: Any strong reads I have are still the same except:
Upon rereading, Z-BosoN asked a question about Coag, which Node answered. Z-BosoN referenced Node hours after that, but no longer convinced they HAVE to be same alignment, because Z-BosoN could remember node's post because it was a direct answer to Z-BosoN's question.
BC this game feels entirely different from BC in LVII. That doesn't mean he's scum BC, I haven't nailed done exactly what I think he is, but marv may have been honest when naming BC most likely to be 3P. Also, remember the claimed protect. Watch medic numbers and scum kill numbers to see whether it was likely he actually got protected or was just covering being bulletproof/having an extra night life.
kush has actively shat up the thread for a lot of this game. The meta argument for him being town was already a little weak because it had been pointed out exactly what made him look townie/scummy. The argument is FURTHER weakened by the fact that marv was scum, and could have partially coached kush as to "here's how you play disruptive and still look like your town meta."
Iamperfection. Read this please. Digest it. and then realise that your unexplained town read on Kush is bullshit. as is getting all riled up over being asked to explain it.
|
EBWOP: that goes for HAPA also.
FoS: Hapa
|
Looking through Mkfuba's filter for breadcrumbs.
|
On October 06 2012 13:00 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On October 06 2012 12:57 DarthPunk wrote:On October 06 2012 12:55 austinmcc wrote: Any strong reads I have are still the same except:
Upon rereading, Z-BosoN asked a question about Coag, which Node answered. Z-BosoN referenced Node hours after that, but no longer convinced they HAVE to be same alignment, because Z-BosoN could remember node's post because it was a direct answer to Z-BosoN's question.
BC this game feels entirely different from BC in LVII. That doesn't mean he's scum BC, I haven't nailed done exactly what I think he is, but marv may have been honest when naming BC most likely to be 3P. Also, remember the claimed protect. Watch medic numbers and scum kill numbers to see whether it was likely he actually got protected or was just covering being bulletproof/having an extra night life.
kush has actively shat up the thread for a lot of this game. The meta argument for him being town was already a little weak because it had been pointed out exactly what made him look townie/scummy. The argument is FURTHER weakened by the fact that marv was scum, and could have partially coached kush as to "here's how you play disruptive and still look like your town meta." Iamperfection. Read this please. Digest it. and then realise that your unexplained town read on Kush is bullshit. as is getting all riled up over being asked to explain it. i think ive told you twice now i cant talk about because of an ongoing game. o nope this is the third time. also you shouldn't worry about kush even if I'm wrong he will slip. Don't understand why your getting so worked up about this.
Because I feel you are being irrational and it annoys me.
|
|
On October 06 2012 13:19 BroodKingEXE wrote: ##Vote: hapa You guys are doing a good job of teaching me about breadcrumbing. LVII was terrible for me.
Yeah. Breadcrumbs are great. Good work by risen and Fuba. I think Fuba's was less obvious though. lol
|
On October 06 2012 14:05 BroodKingEXE wrote:Show nested quote +On October 06 2012 11:03 Hapahauli wrote: @ DP
I disagree. Kush drops WIFOM bombs as either alignment. The one thing that could be interpreted as scummy is him semi-trolling you, but it looks more like a joke than something you should take at face value. He's much less angry than the scumplay I'm used to seeing out of him. He could've learned, but I'm leaning town on him unless there's something really egregiously scummy in his filter that I haven't seen (like him knowing you were town in XXVIII). What do you think of Hapa's response DP? Personally I find his constant soft defense of Kush pretty damning considering Kush's play this game.
Yep. Marv and Hapa both defending kush? seems like a pretty large coincidence. Iamperfection and Kush both looking pretty bad right now.
|
|
On October 06 2012 18:50 Kreb wrote: Well this is getting a bit silly. I feel I havent really done much useful stuff last 3days due to the obvious marv lynch, and now we have to wait another almost 5days before we get to (what could be!!!!) the next real lynch. I guess we're a bit lucky we have caught two seemingly strong scum players (I had a pretty towny read on Hapa although I was suspicious of marv). The lives of Risen and mkfuba shall not be forgotten! The fact that austin got shot also makes it look like he was telling the truth last night and was targetted. Still no claims for this night yet though....
Yeah. It is great that we caught marv and hapa (marv especially) and all that but lt's pretty boring when the lynch is a forgone conclusion for almost 6 days in a row.
|
On October 06 2012 19:19 Kreb wrote: Oh, and we've now had both scum kinda putting Kushs meta on the towny side lol. Dont know if thats indicative of a scum-Kush or the scum team just wanting to make Kush look scummy. Or maybe they're just trying to keep him alive as town so town mislynches other "more useful" players. Anyway, not gonna regard that as an indication of Kushs aligment either way as of yet.
Look at in conjunction with all the other scummy shit and it looks really bad.
|
Hi all. I would love to talk about my case on Keir or the one on Kush. or the one on Shiao. But it seems kind of impotent when they are in no danger of being lynched for 3 days. HEHE.
|
On October 07 2012 09:04 Hapahauli wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2012 08:54 DarthPunk wrote: Hi all. I would love to talk about my case on Keir or the one on Kush. or the one on Shiao. But it seems kind of impotent when they are in no danger of being lynched for 3 days. HEHE. Hi DP. I would love to talk about my case on Thrawn. HEHE.
Go away.
|
On October 07 2012 09:09 kushm4sta wrote: dp im not scum. Sorry for mindfucking you I know it wasn't helpful to town but I did it anyway.
Or you and Iamperfection are both scum. But seriously. You can't just say sorry and pretend you didn't troll/shit up the thread and lay a WIFOM wind fuck on to me. I am not convinced by either of you.
Furthermore. Toutestchaos was Night Killed. He was a very good player from what I can tell and his top scum read was you. and then he died.
Both Shiao Pi and yourself look pretty bad right now. As does the 'perfect one' but mainly by association so I would like to see you flip first.
|
On October 07 2012 09:13 Z-BosoN wrote: Hey guys.. been busy IRL, but will try to keep up the forum over the last two days. On another note, what a bad role, removes some of the elements that actually make mafia fun. Here we go again... ##Vote Hapahauli
FOS: Z - Boson
Reason: Don't prioritise your other game over this one.
I am having a sense of Deja vu.
P.S. <3
|
On October 07 2012 09:17 Hapahauli wrote:Show nested quote +On October 07 2012 09:07 DarthPunk wrote:On October 07 2012 09:04 Hapahauli wrote:On October 07 2012 08:54 DarthPunk wrote: Hi all. I would love to talk about my case on Keir or the one on Kush. or the one on Shiao. But it seems kind of impotent when they are in no danger of being lynched for 3 days. HEHE. Hi DP. I would love to talk about my case on Thrawn. HEHE. Go away. I will not go away until you acknowledge our undying love. Where the hours we spent in the mafia QT caressing sweet nothings? The walks along the moonlit shores - holding hands as we stared into each other's eyes lost in thought and love... I THOUGHT WE HAD SOMETHING SPECIAL!!! Or you can acknowledge my case on Thrawn. Whichever works.
Fine. But how about we keep it in the QT and not shit up the thread with our sordid affair.
|
On October 07 2012 09:22 Kreb wrote: I never really liked touteschaos's (spelling?) case on Shiao. I didnt see the scummy part in it and I think he made too big of a deal of an, at best, very minor tell. So I dont really see any reason to consider Shiao as a target as of now.
I know it is WIFOM. But he died. after having two clear suspects. Isn't it worth considering that he died for a reason? Especially considering Austin died the same night after calling out hapa that same night?
it is WIFOM. So take it with several grains of salt. But to me it is worth looking into.
|
On October 07 2012 09:24 kushm4sta wrote: @darth why exactly do you find my "wifom mind bombs" as you call them scummy? Anti town yeah sure (more specifically anti you). that they were. But I dont see what I would gain from it as scum?
Because the way you employed it sought to make all your scum meta tells useless to me as they were dripping with WIFOM. Making you harder to read by far. Survival instincts > Scummy. Using WIFOM to aid Survival > Scummier
|
On October 07 2012 09:25 kushm4sta wrote: Also @darth what do you think of all the other people prom brought up? You suspect me and iamp and shiao, but what about his scum reads? Dont they seem even scummier to you?
I like his pressure on Kier. It matches my own concerns with him. Coag looks bad also.
But lets be honest here. Most of the players in this game are scummy as shit. And all the vets are disappointing. Inactive/ don't really give a fuck. BC/Matt/VE all not involved at all. And they can't all be scum right?
|
|
|
|