|
On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2012 15:07 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 07:20 Toadesstern wrote:On August 22 2012 06:47 HiroPro wrote:
Whoever made Meowth should tell us what that role is. There is no reason for a townie to not have claimed the shot. Why do you want that? More importantly why do you want to know this during the nightphase? What information would you gain from knowing meowth's full role other than "dude shot someone d1" ? Would it somehow help figure out mafia? Would it somehow help figure out who's really likely town? Would it somehow help figure out who to shoot / protect / DT / whatever else you got tonight? I honestly don't think any of those questions would be answered with a yes, yet you asked for role-information rather than who meowth is. I just can't see a motivation in the question you just asked that is NOT mafiaagenda. At all. Sad thing I bluffed with my KP power earlier the day, or did I ? I'd probably shoot you right now lol I wanted it now because people are going to die during the nightphase; it's entirely possible that the creator of meowth will be shot. The point is that it gives us information on a role that scum likely has and it prevents that person from making a fakeclaim with whatever their other abilities are. I didnt really consider the possibilities that Drazerk did for not claiming and the role that says he's made makes anything like that pointless anyway. The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed? Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia. Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like: a) Meowth b) VE That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other.
Can we know what Toad knows?
|
On August 22 2012 20:59 strongandbig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:On August 22 2012 15:07 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 07:20 Toadesstern wrote:On August 22 2012 06:47 HiroPro wrote:
Whoever made Meowth should tell us what that role is. There is no reason for a townie to not have claimed the shot. Why do you want that? More importantly why do you want to know this during the nightphase? What information would you gain from knowing meowth's full role other than "dude shot someone d1" ? Would it somehow help figure out mafia? Would it somehow help figure out who's really likely town? Would it somehow help figure out who to shoot / protect / DT / whatever else you got tonight? I honestly don't think any of those questions would be answered with a yes, yet you asked for role-information rather than who meowth is. I just can't see a motivation in the question you just asked that is NOT mafiaagenda. At all. Sad thing I bluffed with my KP power earlier the day, or did I ? I'd probably shoot you right now lol I wanted it now because people are going to die during the nightphase; it's entirely possible that the creator of meowth will be shot. The point is that it gives us information on a role that scum likely has and it prevents that person from making a fakeclaim with whatever their other abilities are. I didnt really consider the possibilities that Drazerk did for not claiming and the role that says he's made makes anything like that pointless anyway. The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed? Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia. Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like: a) Meowth b) VE That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. I interpreted that as "you can talk about the role you made once any role has flipped" not "you can only talk about the role you made after that specific role has flipped"
Oh right my bad
|
I'll do this post Mattchew style:
I think Mattchew is scum
lets kill him
|
The only reason I don't think Mattchew is scum is because he didn't reveal his scum team yet.
|
On August 22 2012 21:36 Mementoss wrote:
The only reason I don't think Mattchew is scum is because he didn't reveal his scum team yet.
try and get me lynched.
SnB what do you think of me?
|
This game you're lurky and scummy as fuck. As usual. Except when you decide to be active but I've only seen you do that as scum.
I don't see much to convince me you're town but I also don't see anything that makes me want to lynch you straight off, as opposed to (for example) wiggles or drazerk.
also of note: it's interesting that every post you've made of more than one line has been a response to VE.
Do you still think Dirkzor is scum?
|
i still think dirk is scum yes.
Also, i was enhancing my read of VE, which I find/found to be important in this game
also, you are town, good job
|
On August 23 2012 01:33 Mattchew wrote:
i still think dirk is scum yes.
Also, i was enhancing my read of VE, which I find/found to be important in this game
also, you are town, good job
You seem awfully convinced for this early in the game. Where you getting the information?
|
On August 23 2012 01:36 JingleHell wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 01:33 Mattchew wrote:
i still think dirk is scum yes.
Also, i was enhancing my read of VE, which I find/found to be important in this game
also, you are town, good job You seem awfully convinced for this early in the game. Where you getting the information?
on what
|
SnB's alignment. Treating anyone's alignment as definite based off of the minimal info we have is ridiculous for a townie.
|
On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other.
It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it.
Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role.
Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting.
|
On August 23 2012 01:58 HiroPro wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it. Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role. Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting.
drazerk's thing doesn't hit you if you claim the role you received, it hits you if you claim the role you created.
|
On August 23 2012 02:20 strongandbig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 01:58 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it. Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role. Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting. drazerk's thing doesn't hit you if you claim the role you received, it hits you if you claim the role you created.
I'm talking about this:
On August 22 2012 07:15 Drazerk wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2012 06:47 HiroPro wrote:
Whoever made Meowth should tell us what that role is. There is no reason for a townie to not have claimed the shot. I can think of a few - Multi shot compulsive day vigi Linked to another player (Lovers/Siblings (although more likely for Nidoran)) The fact there are roles out there that need names to kill people The fact there are roles out there that need names to turn them green There is probably more I can't think of right now but those are the ones that stick out in my head
|
United Kingdom31255 Posts
On August 23 2012 02:20 strongandbig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 01:58 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it. Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role. Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting. drazerk's thing doesn't hit you if you claim the role you received, it hits you if you claim the role you created.
Yes it does sorry if that wasn't clear
|
On August 23 2012 01:56 JingleHell wrote:
SnB's alignment. Treating anyone's alignment as definite based off of the minimal info we have is ridiculous for a townie.
snb gets hella confused about me when he's town cause whatever he thinks is normally wrong. if he was scum i think he would be more definitive in his assertions of my alignment, therefore i believe he is town
|
On August 23 2012 01:56 JingleHell wrote:
SnB's alignment. Treating anyone's alignment as definite based off of the minimal info we have is ridiculous for a townie.
also, you act like things can't change my reads.
Does anyone else think this post is hella scummy, and a cop out for not scum hunting?
|
On August 23 2012 02:29 Drazerk wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 02:20 strongandbig wrote:On August 23 2012 01:58 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it. Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role. Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting. drazerk's thing doesn't hit you if you claim the role you received, it hits you if you claim the role you created. Yes it does sorry if that wasn't clear
so wait the hosts let you make a role that instantly de-role-ify anyone who roleclaims? I... don't think that's true.
|
On August 23 2012 02:38 Mattchew wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 01:56 JingleHell wrote:
SnB's alignment. Treating anyone's alignment as definite based off of the minimal info we have is ridiculous for a townie. also, you act like things can't change my reads. Does anyone else think this post is hella scummy, and a cop out for not scum hunting?
How is asking you to explain a possible town motivation for something that's generally scummy "a cop out for not scum hunting"?
|
On August 23 2012 02:59 strongandbig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2012 02:29 Drazerk wrote:On August 23 2012 02:20 strongandbig wrote:On August 23 2012 01:58 HiroPro wrote:On August 22 2012 20:56 Toadesstern wrote:
The creator of a role is not allowed to talk about it until the role has flipped according to a mod-statement. Are you trying to get someone mod-killed?
Why is it a role scum likely has? There has been a lot of talk about Meowth so far. Just picture him being some crazy shit like dayvig + bulletproof. Noone in their right mind would claim something like that because it would help mafia.
Besides: I shot our lovely hosts a PM and I'm totally not going to talk about what a host told me or publish a host-pm but I guess asking the right question might shed some light on some things like:
a) Meowth
b) VE
That being said. I like both VE and Meowth right now, which may sound quite strange but I doubt any of those two is actually mafia although one shot the other. It's not the fact that Meowth didn't claim their role - it's the fact that they didn't claim the shot. It shows that they likely don't want to take responsibility for it. Even the role you suggested would have no problem announcing that they fired a shot. Its not like that would force them to claim their full role. Now if they thought like Drazerk did, then maybe I could see why they wouldn't claim shooting. drazerk's thing doesn't hit you if you claim the role you received, it hits you if you claim the role you created. Yes it does sorry if that wasn't clear so wait the hosts let you make a role that instantly de-role-ify anyone who roleclaims? I... don't think that's true.
Could be something like AC.
Remember that game had Batman, Catwoman the Joker and whoever was the 4th guy.
Batman had to kill the Joker, Catwoman had to kill the other guy, maybe there's 3rd parties who have to kill certain pokemon rather than having the usual wincons.
Maybe we've got something like we had in holyroman with Igrok. He was 3rd party and had to kill everyone who had additional voting-power.
Anyone claiming anything without a second of a thought should be considered mafia and so should people asking for claims right now.
We don't know what's out there unnless of course you have more insight on that matter Jinglehell?
|
So could they have vanilla-lasered zephirdd when he claimed his role? What if someone fakeclaims? What if they claim part of their role and not a different part?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
