Newbie Mini Mafia XXII - Page 64

On August 09 2012 08:01 Shady Sands wrote:
Since Alan is not medic, I am comfortable voting for him. Even a mislynch would be fine at this point--it would put us into MYLO tomorrow, and with a medic, we could no-lynch tomorrow to essentially force scum to possibly waste a KP.

On August 09 2012 10:28 Shady Sands wrote:
Jingle where are you? Why are you voting Alan?

On August 09 2012 10:42 JingleHell wrote:


I'm voting for Alan for a pisston of reasons already stated, and if I had made some obscenely long post re-detailing all of those things, you would instead be nattering on about clutter, so I'll just save myself some time instead, thanks?

I mean, I'm aware you're pissed that I made a point about DP and was right with it, since you were so busy tunneling me to a mislynch based on WIFOM, because I tunneled the wrong guy based on WIFOM once too, but you could have the good graces not to be a tart about the obvious.

On August 09 2012 10:52 Shady Sands wrote:
The more you respond to legitimate requests for casework with hostility, the more you look like a scum read who's just deliberately being hostile to dodge having to give reasons for your votes.

On August 09 2012 10:54 JingleHell wrote:


And the more you talk, the more I plan to /out of any game I see you sign up for, so I guess we're even. If you could get the fuck over yourself for thirty damn seconds, you'd realize that overall, I'm the last person who owes analysis on Alan, since between me and Ange, about 60-70% of the case against him comes from two people.

On August 09 2012 11:31 Shady Sands wrote:


Alan actually posted two long-ish defenses before you cast your vote, which is what I think you should respond to.

On August 09 2012 12:03 JingleHell wrote:


If my play is as terrible as everyone wants to make it out to be, that's the last thing you should want. Would you really want me to accidentally undermine the effort with my oh so horrendous town play that everyone loves to talk shit about?

On August 10 2012 04:18 Shady Sands wrote:
So after reading through GK's and aRyuu's posts, nothing looks out of order. I read through Alan's defenses one more time as well. One thing that struck me as odd about Alan was his insistence on asking us all to consider scenarios in which he is green, but he never actually added any specifics about those scenarios. Basically, who is the scum if Alan is green? He hasn't mentioned anything about that, which just adds to my scum read on him.

On August 10 2012 04:25 aRyuujin wrote:


well, let's think about it.
The only people left would be

aRyuujin
Shady
ange
GK
Jingle

(minus whoever gets NKed)

Shady/ange I'd say are pretty much guaranteed town.
I know I'm town, and you guys really ought to be looking somewhere else, seeing as without me, Jingle would've been lynched.
So GK vs Jingle...

On August 10 2012 04:25 aRyuujin wrote:


well, let's think about it.
The only people left would be

aRyuujin
Shady
ange
GK
Jingle

(minus whoever gets NKed)

Shady/ange I'd say are pretty much guaranteed town.
I know I'm town, and you guys really ought to be looking somewhere else, seeing as without me, Jingle would've been lynched.
So GK vs Jingle...

On August 10 2012 05:37 Shady Sands wrote:


Overall, I'd say Jingle is still the clearest lynch target. He hasn't posted a thing since the night 4 post, and he's basically attempted to use "being angry" as an excuse to refrain from posting any additional analysis.

On August 10 2012 05:44 JingleHell wrote:


You know, if you're going to go crying in the TL Mafia ban thread about me being a meany poopoo head, you could try learning from the thread and realize I've actually been doing my best to ignore you when I'm not busy turning a logical case into bizarre WIFOM to convince you to vote for the guy who flips scum.

You call me out and complain about my play when it's saved the town's ass once already, and is probably about to win the game for us. And if you want to talk about "if Alan flips green" the highest lynch priority should be whoever brought it up.

I'm definitely not going to answer to someone who won't let me ignore them, and who does complain about the responses they get when they actively try to push me out of the thread and then complain about it working.

On August 10 2012 05:51 Shady Sands wrote:


I'm not sure if anyone's been trying to push you out of the thread--all of us have encouraged you to post analysis, not angrish, here.

Onto a more relevant topic: what do you mean that "the highest lynch priority should be whoever brought it up?"