Newbie Mini Mafia VIII - Page 2

funcmode

Australia720 Posts

April 19 2012 20:23 GMT

#934

On April 20 2012 05:12 Xatalos wrote:

So you rather believe Willz - whose case against me is completely WIFOM and based on connections - than me and Acrofales, who have both made a good case against Willz (without relying on WIFOM or connections). Unless you're just trying to bait Mafia into voting for me (which is very risky and could possibly lose the game right now), you must be Mafia (considering you were praised for your logic in the previous game).

So, extending your point, if KB is mafia, then Dittert really is DT and your mafia 'read' on him is wrong? Which would mean you're currently voting for a townie to be lynched?

I'm still hesitant, but Willz's theory is making more and more sense to me.

funcmode

Australia720 Posts

April 19 2012 20:39 GMT

#939

On April 20 2012 05:32 Xatalos wrote:
So, the current situation is:

Xatalos (3): Willz, KharadBanar, imallinson
Dittert (2): Xatalos, yomi
KharadBanar (1): Dittert

vonKlaust and funcmode have yet to vote.

I'm guessing Dittert won't change his vote anymore, since he has always been away(?) at the deadline. imallinson also said he would be away at the dealine (with a pretty weird reason).

I'd assume both funcmode and vonKlaust will vote for me in the end (vonKlaust has been ignoring Willz&Dittert and just accusing me with some WIFOM, and funcmode is probably Mafia).

This means that if nothing major happens, the vote will be like this:

Xatalos (5): Willz, KharadBanar, imallinson, vonKlaust, funcmode
Dittert (2): Xatalos, yomi
KharadBanar (1): Dittert

Does this really look like I, Dittert and imallinson are the Mafia team? It looks more like Mafia wants to lynch me now and win the game outright.

What else do you suggest, Willz, Dittert and me? I obviously can't possibly agree with that. You keep suspecting me even when I'm one of the few people who could possibly save your ass right now. So, if you want to appeal to me, under the assumption that I'm town, who else do you suggest? How can you back that up?

funcmode

Australia720 Posts

April 19 2012 21:51 GMT

#976

If there's one thing I've come as close as possible to convincing myself of tonight, it's that Dittert can't have been telling the truth with his DT claim.

If Dittert was telling the truth and he was town, and if Willz is scum would have known Dittert was town, and would have been happy for Dittert to be lynched (especially so if he was DT). The fact that he didn't, and went to all this effort to instead get people to switch to vote you instead (citing he'd still be happy for a Dittert lynch) suggests to me that Dittert can't possibly be telling the truth.

I might even vote for Dittert right now but I'm unsure of any implications this might have in regards to other people switching votes and what might result.

funcmode

Australia720 Posts

April 19 2012 22:00 GMT

#984

On April 20 2012 06:54 Xatalos wrote:

Show nested quote +

If Dittert was lying, then Willz and Dittert are Mafia. If Dittert was telling the truth, then Willz and KharadBanar are Mafia. The only logical conclusion is to vote for Willz right now.

What? If Dittert was lying, we can't automatically assume Willz is mafia, and as I said if Dittert was telling the truth, I'd find it hard to believe Willz is mafia cause he wouldn't have tried to persuade the vote away from Dittert.