A Game of Thrones Mafia

On March 21 2012 22:54 Acrofales wrote:
Okay seriously WTF. I know I'm new to this game, but voting me for that reason alone makes no sense. In fact, it seems quite a scum move to cast suspicion on people right at the start of the game.

Or am I going overboard and it's just a way of getting people to post at the start of the game? Either way, I'm watching you and risk.nuke. Voting off the bat seems fishy.

As for the rest, I've calmed down a bit, with later people talking about the random votes. It is my first game (ever) and I was hoping to live past the first day. People instavoting for me got me a bit upset. I am happy to unvote Matthew when a better candidate comes up, the ghost of High Heart is kinda cryptic when it comes to her prophecies It was more of a "if you vote for me, then I'll vote for you"-thing anyway.

On March 22 2012 01:20 GreYMisT wrote:
Guys I say we lynch Wherebugsgo, just to be certain.

Sand/Syllo can you guys sign you posts? It makes it a lot easier for the rest of us to keep track of who thinks what.

Xatalos, I'm interested on what you think about Wherebugsgo/littlefinger. How do you think we should go about interacting with him now that we know he is 3rd party?

Also i would like to assure everyone that even though I am hosting Aperture Mafia, the science will not keep me from being active here.

Explain to us why he is.

On March 22 2012 03:48 GreYMisT wrote:
Has ON even posted?

On March 22 2012 18:01 Acrofales wrote:
Lurkers
Yes, you: Nicolas, Layabout, Zealos, Sinensis, Evantrees, Lyter and Risen. Why should we not lynch you, you're clearly not contributing anything.

Also do we want to elect a mayor?

Also can we keep the Hodor's to a minimum?

Acrofales seeing as your lynch is getting to be pretty likely maybe you should role claim?

On March 23 2012 02:36 DoYouHas wrote:
My vote is doing nothing where it is so I am going to sheep Samuel on Oberyn until I read a more convincing case or I write one myself.

##Unvote: Acrofales
##Vote: Oberyn

oh so your his scum teammate?

explain to me why you are not scum.

you have 90 minutes

then MrZentor, bad reading comprehension in hand, makes a terrible post with his lead point of his slippery slope theory being untrue because Mattchew (who is awesome, sexy and lover of all townies) never even voted for Acrofales!

i say we lynch acrofales and everyone that has defended him

I would be all about a Xatalos lynching today. He posts reek of "I want to look like the rest of you"

We should lynch Oberyn

Mods when I reach majority can we prematurely end the day? Will speed this game up.

On March 25 2012 13:46 Risen wrote:


Because when I flip detective you'll know I've checked him.

On March 26 2012 04:22 Mattchew wrote:
can someone tell me why we would want to take a risk of lynching the guy who claims dt first?

for the most part it sounds like people are saying something along the lines of "i wouldn't do that as DT" or "he must be an idiot to do that as DT" or "This way of playing DT doesn't help town"

2 of these say nothing about alignment. playing stupid or different from how you would play it dont mean scum. and there are a ton of examples of townies playing in a not pro-town manner.

If we flip acro first and he flips scum or miller, we save the life of a townie and save a lynch.
if we flip acro first and he flips town, we get to see what happens to risen at night, and then lynch him.
if we flip risen first and he flips scum, we don't learn anything about acro BUT HURRAY WE LYNCH SCUM
if we flip risen first and hes town DT, we waste a lynch on a confirmable townie, and acro gets lynched the next day


I feel it is a lot safer to lynch acro first

On March 26 2012 05:56 Risen wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +

I'm just confused, I didn't think my play wasn't pro-town since my claims were so easy to check. We lynch acro and you get guaranteed scum on day 3. That isn't bad, is it? In a game with only 4 scum dropping them to 3 by the end of day 3 is decent positioning imo, and tbh I really am having a hard time understanding why people are voting for the guy who openly claimed and told everyone what his check was instead of the guy who hasn't claimed anything.

In a normal game without the third party threatening to shoot me I wouldn't have panicked. It's my fault we're in the position we are in, and I acknowledge that.

On March 26 2012 05:38 Risen wrote:


You should stop posting. When I flip town DT you're going to be in some hot water if you're a townie...

On March 24 2012 07:25 Risen wrote:

I'm almost positive Acro is scum, and Mattchew needs to be checked tonight. VOTE ACROFALES

On March 23 2012 23:08 Risen wrote:


Unfortunately it does not, we don't know his sanity. If someone were to check you tonight and confirm then maybe it would.

On March 26 2012 06:39 wherebugsgo wrote:

Sounds more like, "before I had the foresight to plan a DT claim I tried directing DTs into Mattchew and now I'm grasping at straws trying to make the statement make sense in retrospect"

On March 26 2012 21:50 Mattchew wrote:
wut?

On March 27 2012 02:23 Mattchew wrote:

I'll put it this way. I am sure that Xatalos is scum, and if I was a DT I would check him to confirm. Nothing is 100% in this game and there is never too much information. Confirming your beliefs is the most important thing you can do

Risen could be DT and acro could have checked out as scum?

On March 24 2012 07:25 Risen wrote:

I'm almost positive Acro is scum, and Mattchew needs to be checked tonight. VOTE ACROFALES

On March 23 2012 23:08 Risen wrote:


Unfortunately it does not, we don't know his sanity. If someone were to check you tonight and confirm then maybe it would.

On March 26 2012 07:32 chaoser wrote:
Not to mention even if there was a rolechecker it is a flawed argument, as summed up here by chaoser:
This isn't a good excuse even IF rolechecker WAS a role. Why would you take a risk and depend on someone else to do your job? Why not do it yourself? That doesn't even make any sense. That's like saying, I want to check this guy, but oh well, I won't. I'll check this other guy that I already am sure is mafia and hope that 1) someone else checks the guy I want to know about and 2) they then out themselves somehow to give us that information. WTF?

##vote: risen

On March 26 2012 06:39 wherebugsgo wrote:


herp derp I wanted a rolechecker to check Mattchew herp derp without even checking that there was a rolechecker herp derp my logic makes sense no matter what you say herp derp despite the fact that you just showed it's complete shit herp derp herp

Sounds more like, "before I had the foresight to plan a DT claim I tried directing DTs into Mattchew and now I'm grasping at straws trying to make the statement make sense in retrospect"

On March 26 2012 06:12 Zealos wrote:
Even if you flipped DT, there is no reason that puts me into a scum position. You are just using threats as an attempt to stop me from pressing my case. Give us a good reason to believe you're DT, before I roleclaim as Godfather and claim you're one of my mafia buddies, as your reasoning is that roleclaims are always truthful.

On March 26 2012 05:29 Risen wrote:


EBWOP: And he solidifies his "really dumb townie" position well here (If I didn't make it clear in my previous post I think he's scum, I think Mattchew is scum, and I think Greymist is scum). He'll OMGUS me once I'm lynched and be in the clear. He deserves looking into tonight, imo.

On March 27 2012 03:26 Mattchew wrote:

Once again, if you are DT and you think someone is scum you check them. You always confirm them. He could have checked me the next night.
-You're argument "He did the wrong thing"

The rolechecker thing is the only thing I don't understand. The desperation of explaining himself is a little scummy. Also, for giggles


This all reads "I'm mad."

On March 22 2012 00:25 Mattchew wrote:
lolololololol

im going to assume this is sandroba?

oh so your his scum teammate?

explain to me why you are not scum.

you have 90 minutes

where you at homeslice and why should i think you are not scum

wut?

OMG 5 WHOLE POSTS ABOUT HIM 3 OF WHICH ARE NOT EVEN SERIOUS? NO WAYYYYY

wbg you know better than that, I thought you wanted to help town

i said it here too herpderp speaking in absolutes is not scum slipping herpderp

my first game ever where I was scared to post.

me and SLG <3 vague posts.

btw defense is completely overrated. I do it cause i have too much fucking time to hawk the thread

I'm down with ignoring risen wbg acro And mr zentos completely

Welcome to TL Mafia.

wut?

you have to be joking

On March 27 2012 18:40 risk.nuke wrote:
We don't need a case, we got a redcheck. Acro. Sit down shut up.

Mods can we have a 24 hour day today if town agrees on it? There won't be or well you don't know with the ratio of morons in this city but there shouldn't be much confusion about who we're lynching.

On March 28 2012 01:59 Mattchew wrote:

Missed this piece of shit post.
i am posting it before a night deadline... giving people 48 hours to read and discuss.

On March 28 2012 06:32 Mattchew wrote:
My Scum (aka to-lynch) List = Acrofales, Zealos, Xatalos, Lyter, Evantrees
But Mattchew, there are 5 names and only 4 scum. WTF?
I believe if we lynch this list we get the scum team.

---

Acrofales has a red-check on him from a confirmed DT, he needs to be lynched tomorrow no matter what. Thats all, end of story.

---

Zealos This is my strongest scum read.

First we have his contradictions with how to interact with WBG. He seems to be selectively deaf to WBG using him only to his personal benefit as seen here.
+ Show Spoiler +
Then we have Zealos arguing in absolutes about Risen flipping scum. This feels like him trying to blend in with the majority opinion. Also, if Risen wasn't lynched its a backhanded way of saving Acro from lynch by discrediting Risen's DT claim.
+ Show Spoiler +
He also constantly flirts with the topic of getting me lynched but never actually pushes it. He is waiting for it to actually gain momentum before he pushes it.He also constantly flirts with the topic of getting me lynched but never actually pushes it. He is waiting for it to actually gain momentum before he pushes it.
+ Show Spoiler +
I quoted this in there but i would love to point out this scum-slip. He somehow knows he will be alive after the night post

Furthermore he tries to do the trendy townie thing of pressuring people by way of vote. Man does he really get swayed quickly
+ Show Spoiler +
This case is farrrrrrr from hinging on Acro flipping scum, but if he were to, tell me these posts don't scream of an attempt to coach a teammate while "pressuring" him
+ Show Spoiler +
Finally we have these 2 quotes which are just so bad they actually look like scum agenda.
+ Show Spoiler +

---

Xatalos I have been calling him scum and asking for opinions on him all game. Ald also did a pretty nice post on him

*click me*My First case

*click me*Ald on Xat

I'll try to not be redundant.
+ Show Spoiler +
Funny because Xatalos has yet to make a case on anyone. He took the retarded WBG "lynch Risen" logic of "He is playing too bad to be scum" and translated that into 2 lengthy contentless posts and threw in some thread observations (no real opinions on anything just recaps)
+ Show Spoiler +
He is wishy washy while coming to obscure conclusions. Even I will entertain the thought that Acro is vanilla town but Xatalos seems convinced he's a blue? This is bizarre and looks like he has been hunting for blues breadcrumbs all game. (Townies should only care about who is town and who is scum, not who has a role.)


Also, if you take the time to read through his filter you can see he is still blaming things on this being his first game. This smells of scum trying to compensate for slipping up by saying "oh I didn't know any better".

---

Alas I have ran out of time (6:00PM EST Class) Lyter and evantrees are lurking and scummy. HA!

On March 29 2012 21:46 GreYMisT wrote:


I voted for risen....

On March 30 2012 03:43 Mattchew wrote:

So he has been "active, contributing and created a pro-town atmosphere." 2 of these have literally 0 to do with alignment. And his dumbass argument with me about Risen was actually disruptive as fuck to the thread during that day.

"If you guys start to vote risk.nuke i will too because he's town and I like lynching townies" - this paraphrased

Wish-wash no firm stance

meh idk. I haven't seen a decent case against greymist and it looks like risk.nuke's relentless pushing (without much content) is snowballing up.


barring unforeseen circumstances I cannot see this being a good decision.

Your lynch system is awfully scummy in my opinion. It looks like you are trying to blend in with opinions but don't want to take a firm stance anywhere but Greymist.

I completely agree with GreYMisT. You have had next to no solid opinions and seem to want to ride the coattails of others while only fighting over opinions that you knew others agreed with you on. I think you are scum. I will be voting for you.

On April 02 2012 11:04 chaoser wrote:




nothing "useful" yet lol.

##vote risk.nuke

BTW, we're at LYLO. It's 5 v 3 right now. If WBG is voting with scum, we CAN'T afford to make a mistake.

It's pretty clear zealos is mafia due to his...everything. Mattchew posted a great post on him and I have a post on him as well. Risk.nuke has been misrepresenting people all game and has yet to shown zealos posting "good useful things", diverting the lynch onto greymist. I'm ok with a lynch on either. gumshoe is probably the last mafia I think.

On April 02 2012 11:38 chaoser wrote:


It's fucking day 5, not day 1. That excuse no longer works. Whatever, no use arguing with mafia.

On April 02 2012 11:04 chaoser wrote:




nothing "useful" yet lol.

##vote risk.nuke

BTW, we're at LYLO. It's 5 v 3 right now. If WBG is voting with scum, we CAN'T afford to make a mistake.

It's pretty clear zealos is mafia due to his...everything. Mattchew posted a great post on him and I have a post on him as well. Risk.nuke has been misrepresenting people all game and has yet to shown zealos posting "good useful things", diverting the lynch onto greymist. I'm ok with a lynch on either. gumshoe is probably the last mafia I think.

On April 06 2012 03:54 VisceraEyes wrote:
Zealos you blew your load early. If you could have waited one more day before using your power, you could have won it for town. Scum were still speculating the last blue could be a PGO at that point ^^