Purgatory Mafia - Page 50

On January 09 2012 10:48 HarbingerOfDoom wrote:

What? Why would who flip? I was/am confused that the angel of death didn't kill anyone and think it is most likely that syllo was targeted by the angel of death.

On January 09 2012 06:41 Palmar wrote:
And when those two flip, kill risk.nuke, tyrran too. Probably bluelightz, and then find the last one. HoD is a possibility, so is Refallen, maybe Grackaroni...

Blazinghand, Cwave, Dirkzor, layabout, RebirthOfLeGenD, Spaackle, Zephirdd and Mr. Wiggles are town.

On January 09 2012 11:22 Spaackle wrote:
Well, now that we know that Palmar is scum, we should take a look at a post the he made earlier:



I'll bet we find Palmar's scumbuddies in the list of the people that he declared as townies.

On January 09 2012 11:30 Grackaroni wrote:
Yeah I wouldn't put too much importance on Palmar's list there spaackle.
Also I'm going to assume that Palmar was the person that put you in purgatory HoD. It just makes more sense for the Channeler to protect syllo.

On January 09 2012 11:37 Refallen wrote:
Corrupt only on even nights jackal

On January 09 2012 12:03 Refallen wrote:
I think it way more likely that palmar sent HoD to purgatory

On January 09 2012 12:13 Mr. Wiggles wrote:
I don't think Syllo and Palmar were team mates, simply due to the way Palmar acted towards him. At first, Palmar did his best to buddy up to Syllo, by agreeing with most of his reads, and calling him town repeatedly, and then after Syllo still said he was suspicious of him, Palmar started calling him dumb and bad, similar to what he did to me and Jackal.

@Jackal: Why do you think it's more likely the town channeler would have used his ability on HoD and not Syllo?

On January 09 2012 12:20 Jackal58 wrote:

That's exactly why I think they are.
Palmar is lazy scum. He doesn't like being scum. His actions towards Syllo are in line with his day one behavior as scum.
I've played scum with Palmar before. He interacts with his teammates like nobodies business.

On January 09 2012 12:43 Refallen wrote:
Jackal, what do you think of syllo switching to Errandor late in day 1? As he said, I find it hard how someone who first pushed risk.nuke would stay on him throughout the day only to vote switch late to errandor if they're scum buddies. Right now, I think it more likely that syllo just brainfarted, but I'll like to hear your take on the day 1 situation.

On January 07 2012 00:51 syllogism wrote:
While I consider palmar the better lynch out of wiggles/palmar, I don't think it's a good idea to lynch palmar today. We've other very good lynches available, it's a setup with 6 scum and he is very likely to become more transparent the longer the game goes on if he is scum or dead if he is town.

I'll probably narrow the list down but I would like to keep the lynch between erandorr/risk/tyrran/refallen. Out of those erandorr appears to be by far the safest lynch and the only reason I haven't been actively pushing him as the #1 lynch was to give him more time and because it's pretty disappointing if he again decided not to play due to rolling scum.

On January 07 2012 05:51 syllogism wrote:
Wiggles what do you think about Erandorr and Risk nuke and don't you think that in a 6 scum game it would be safer play to lynch one of them or Tyrran as I would estimate that they are at least as likely to flip scum and are going to be considerably more worthless even if we happen to be wrong.

On January 07 2012 08:33 syllogism wrote:
We should lynch erandorr/risk/tyrran today, regardless of how scummy you think palmar is being. The fact people don't seem to be willing to hop on those wagons despite me repeatedly giving them an opportunity to do so is suspicious. If palmar is scum, he has two scum mates who should be looking for alternative wagons by now. It's of course quite possible that his team mates are on that list but regardless lynching one of those 3 is better day 1 play.

On January 07 2012 19:26 syllogism wrote:
Wiggles: I think palmar is likely scum. It's pretty much impossible to assign probabilities to flips so I'm not even going to bother, but I guess I could say that I don't think they are particularly more likely to flip scum than palmar. The issue is where we are if they don't flip scum; losing palmar day 1 would definitely be much worse. We can probably lynch him tomorrow if he keeps playing like this.

On January 07 2012 20:14 syllogism wrote:
Do you think we should lynch him over erandorr if the answer doesn't make sense?

On January 07 2012 23:21 syllogism wrote:
Haha jackal we can only lynch one person and there are 3 or maybe 4 people who are extremely likely to all flip scum (erandorr, risk, palmar and possibly tyrran)

On January 08 2012 07:02 syllogism wrote:
Day ends in 3 hours, but within an hour or two is fine. I'm fine with lynching either erandorr/risk

On January 08 2012 08:32 syllogism wrote:
How many do we have around? I'm fine with switching to erandorr, I'm virtually certain that erandorr is scum and only very convinced that risk is

On January 08 2012 08:45 syllogism wrote:
I haven't been pushing the meta case against Erandorr, but he really wouldn't play like this as town. He even signed up for TL mafia L so he isn't burned out or busy; he just loathes playing as scum. In election mafia he hydraed with curu and refused to post at all due to rolling scum. Yesterday he lied about being sleepy, while I know he had been and still was playing dota 2 and kept playing for at least an hour after making the post (I went to sleep by that point). Such pure meta cases are annoying to push and I thought the case against risk was better in terms of it actually constituting as "playing mafia". But erandorr really can't be town

On January 08 2012 08:45 syllogism wrote:
risk was better in terms of it actually constituting as "playing mafia". But erandorr really can't be town

On January 08 2012 08:58 syllogism wrote:
No I still think risk is scum, but I'm pretty much certain that erandorr is.