EPTLSB's posts so far seem very meek to me, always answering something or clarifying something. It really feels like he is actively avoiding pissing off people and he is making bullshit conclusions out of other players' posts. Doesn't feel like the confident townie LSB, it looks exactly the opposite. The points about his response regarding chezinu and the sk thing don't really tell me much though.
Responsibility Mafia! - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
LSB's posts so far seem very meek to me, always answering something or clarifying something. It really feels like he is actively avoiding pissing off people and he is making bullshit conclusions out of other players' posts. Doesn't feel like the confident townie LSB, it looks exactly the opposite. The points about his response regarding chezinu and the sk thing don't really tell me much though. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
@L I see you included us on your arbitrary "list" of I don't even know what (people who can read roles?) but I'm pretty sure neither me or curu has ever played with you before and seeing that you are gone for a long time you don't strike me as someone that reads recent games. Care to explain your reasoning to posting such list? You also jump to the conclusion that there must be 1-2 mafia in that arbitrary list of nothingness. Any particular explanation for that? @palmar/syllo I don't know if I'm just biased but I didn't like any of wiggles posts. What do you guys think of them? /sandroba | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
| ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
| ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
I disagree entirely with a Palmar lynch. He has not posted anything that I would not expect from him as Townie Palmar and his points have made sense. I understand where his point comes from about day 1 Mafia lynches as there were a series of games back around when I started where Town nailed scum day 1 of almost every single game (Palmar was in all of them as well). GM's play looks just like Some Mafia Game as scum where he made a terrible case day 1, neglected to respond to any of the criticisms of the case, promised activity constantly but never delivered. Jackal's posts are giving me the exact same careful scum feeling they did in that infamous annul Jack game. Jackal where are you? Wiggle's posts are extremely cautious and neutral, something that's notably absent from his town play. Looking at LotR (Town) he has a ton of posts boldly stating his opinions and reasoning. In this game he's constantly bringing stuff up and asking people "what do you think?" Brings up stuff but seems more curious about what other people think of it than what conclusions he draws from it. L besides Palmar do you have anyone else you suspicions of? /Curu | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
/sandroba | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
Also you comment on LSB's lack of confidence as being suspicious then call me out for voting LSB for that exact reason. You are not making any sense from a townie perspective GM. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
On December 22 2011 07:37 wherebugsgo wrote: sandro was it you or curu who initially agreed with the LSB case I made? Can you explain your current thoughts on the game? What do you think of Palmar/L? RoL? Foolishness? It was me. I think I signed that post. I don't want palmar/L lynched. I don't like how foolishness is playing, but I've seen him play like this as town. Even in this roster he is likely to get shot if he is town night 1, because he usually engages turbo mode day2 onwards, so I don't agree with lynching him today either. Whoever is here day 2 should hold foolishness to a high standard day 2 though if he survives. RoL isn't doing shit and I wouldn't mind seeing him gone. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
| ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
| ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
| ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
Palmar seems okayish to me, the only thing that is bothering me a bit is that he is focusing too much on arguing with people for no real benefit. Right now I feel the best move is to go ahead and lynch LSB, because any quick bandwagons we can come up with this late have very little chance of actually hitting scum. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
I am a bit concerned about LSB's lack of any sort of comment or realistic effort to swing the lynch off him. If that sort of play came form someone like Palmar or syllogism it would be a sure scum sign since they are heavily involved as Town and much lazier/careless as Mafia, something I can definitely relate to but I don't know if LSB shares that sentiment. Realistically though I don't think there is another viable candidate at this point. As sandro said GM could probably throw something up quick to defend himself if he was Mafia or just sheeped one of the existing wagons harder. VE raises good points in GM's apparent confidence then turnaround thorough lack of when actually pressed to give real content. But I feel better about LSB than GM. /Curu | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
Likewise LSB's claim makes no sense for scum either unless he has a night role that he want to use before death. That their role names are different should absolutely not be factored in as you can be sure Ver would have named identical roles different things especially after the debacle of the previous Incognito game where people were using role names and abilities to try to determine alignment. What they've both claimed is a role that is impossible to fulfil as scum. At this point I'd rather lynch Chezinu or Foolishness, both of whom have shown that despite prodding neither is posting with Town's interests at heart. Chezinu is being blatantly anti-Town with his posting still under the disguise of "Chezinu is Chezinu." 10 minutes to lynch, are any of you willing to consolidate on one or the other? | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
On December 22 2011 13:53 wherebugsgo wrote: did you forget that mafia are told about the blue roles? How can we be sure about the claims with that in mind? I agree that GM would probably not CC if he was scum. But, this is tricky because mafia know the blues. It has nothing to do with the roles. Do you understand what GM is claiming? It is not like DT or Medic, it is impossible for scum to fulfil the role he is claiming. Sure he can fake RB every night but unless there's more than one RBer that means scum can only really RB their kills (and if one is Medic saved they're screwed doing that) and when the RBer dies GM is screwed. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
It's past lynch deadline now, all we can do is wait for LSB's flip. | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
We will be entering day 2 soon. Absolutely no more lazy half assed posting from anyone is acceptable. Im indicating RoL, BC, Foolishness, Chezinu, GM, kita. I have issues with bums posts as well which have been largely useless. Curu | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
On December 23 2011 01:15 kitaman27 wrote: Post-lynch thoughts: Chezinu or Foolishness obviously wasn't going to get lynched, considering your post was only 10 minutes from the deadline, but what concerns me is that you just explained why you thought LSB's claim made no sense as scum, yet you didn't move your vote off him. Surely, a no-lynch would have been better, giving him an opportunity to shoot, if this was the way you guys felt, wouldn't it? GGQ also mentions how the case against LSB is thin and that he is not confident that he is scum, but he moves his vote to him anyways. RoL puts a placeholder on Chezinu, yet disappears for the remainder of the day. The last thing we need is another Team Melee game from him, so I hope to hear from him day two. There were also several other people who disappeared from the discussion, such as L and BC. I'd rather a lynch of him than a no lynch or we just have a repeat of day 1 with no lynch information. Of course I would've preferred Foolishness or Chezinu more but unfortunately by the time I got home it was too late to solidly put something together. I wasn't even expecting to be here for the lynch since the game had started at 11:30 EST and I wasn't expecting to be home until after that but the deadline was pushed back half an hour. Is Sheth still on your radar kita? What about GMarshal? /Curu | ||
|
SamuelLJackson
223 Posts
![[image loading]](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_vY8I5HvOvk8/ShxRsUL_fnI/AAAAAAAAGVs/IACJsJ9hltk/s400/deep-blue-sea1.jpg) Ver's a liar, this is what really happened. | ||
| ||
