|
On November 27 2011 15:27 Mattchew wrote:
I honestly do not know what to say in this thread. I have no feelings as to who is scum and who is town, I don't want to point fingers and end up being wrong because I don't truly understand what I am reading.
Indeed, WBG has created an anti-town atmosphere that discourages posting/contributions by being aggressive towards everyone.
imo we should lynch him D2.
|
I'm drunk right now, but that was a boneheaded move lynching YM and not voting for me palmar. If you don't vote for double lynch tonight I'll consider you auto scum. The double lynches purpose is to actually provide information really fast for blues to act upon, and the lack of information we have right now is the exact reason you should use it as early as possible, not the contrary. I'm pretty sure BC is scum. Other people I think are scum are anul, decon, wbg and serejai. Kitaman after sugesting the double lynch thing I'm removing him from my suspect list even though he is known for sugesting pro-town moves as scum in the past I just have a feeling this was an genuine honest thought.
I'll post more coherently agter I wake up.
|
also protect syllo he is townie as fuck.
|
Ugh. I originally thought Palmer to be a little scummy, what with his massive (worthless) flavor post and n00b appeal, but kinda lost that when he accepted a logic-based "plan" rather than just "trust me I am good".
After that mislynch...
I don't know where I stand. I can see the reasoning behind it: he was being disruptive. Might as well lynch him. But, compared to some solid scum reads and/or good targets for information, I'm not sure it was worth it.
I'm nowhere near the "OMG MISLYNCH THEREFORE SCUM" camp. But, if at any point he goes against any plans or promises, there will be more than a little red flag.
|
On November 27 2011 14:56 bumatlarge wrote:
I don't know, YM over kenpachi or supersoft? What's up with that palmar.
Poor Heir going against the grain. Rock on little man. Before I give my scum reads, I'd like to see the modkills first. 8KP sounds brutal by the by.
what the fuck. Since when am I considered as a suspect? If you base this on the shit this sinanidouble posted earlier, I am going to ignore you aswell.
I fully agree with sandroba. Syllogism and him are 100% town. As I predicted, there was a huge voteshift from everywhere to BC. Based on the votepatterns, I think he's scum. I am going to sleep now, and reevaluate everything when I wake up.
|
mislynches themselves do not mean a mayor is red. a town mayor still has slightly better than 20% to get a red using random chance alone. it takes a lot to turn that % higher.
palmar is red because of the way he played once i subbed in and started to call him out. especially his OMGUS early day 1 (AND how he actually followed through on it!!!) remember YM did nothing but call palmar out and palmar put his sights on him since then...
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
|
On November 27 2011 15:56 Nisani201 wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2011 15:27 Mattchew wrote:
I honestly do not know what to say in this thread. I have no feelings as to who is scum and who is town, I don't want to point fingers and end up being wrong because I don't truly understand what I am reading. Indeed, WBG has created an anti-town atmosphere that discourages posting/contributions by being aggressive towards everyone. imo we should lynch him D2.
On November 27 2011 15:56 Nisani201 wrote:[/B]
imo we should lynch him D2.
![[image loading]](http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100828054703/uncyclopedia/images/b/b5/Exploding-head.gif)
On topic though, what do people think of the 10 player list I posted earlier?
No one really commented on it. Who should be there, and who should not?
Palmar said he'll post his own "tomorrow" (real life tomorrow I guess?) but nothing so far.
|
On November 27 2011 12:17 Serejai wrote:
I told you Palmar was a bad idea. So many sheep this game...
because of 1 mislynch? wtf for reasoning is that?
|
On November 27 2011 16:09 sandroba wrote:
I'm drunk right now, but that was a boneheaded move lynching YM and not voting for me palmar. If you don't vote for double lynch tonight I'll consider you auto scum. The double lynches purpose is to actually provide information really fast for blues to act upon, and the lack of information we have right now is the exact reason you should use it as early as possible, not the contrary. I'm pretty sure BC is scum. Other people I think are scum are anul, decon, wbg and serejai. Kitaman after sugesting the double lynch thing I'm removing him from my suspect list even though he is known for sugesting pro-town moves as scum in the past I just have a feeling this was an genuine honest thought.
I'll post more coherently agter I wake up.
Yes, I hope you really are drunk sandroba.
I lynched YM with plenty of reasoning. Turns out he was just an asshole and not scum. Well I can't really do much about that.
I did vote for you, and publicly claim my support for you as sheriff..
as I said, the earliest a DT can have any information about his sanity is day 3. I do agree that using the double lynches early is good, but I think they should be used day 3 and onwards. Unless you can provide excellent reasoning for doing so. I thought you were against flipping a lot of people early?
|
On November 27 2011 18:22 Palmar wrote:
I lynched YM with plenty of reasoning. Turns out he was just an asshole and not scum. Well I can't really do much about that.
apparently criticizing your campaign makes someone an asshole, go figure
|
Finland5948 Posts
In case it's not immediately obvious to our newer players; even if WBG happens to be town, he isn't capable of producing a useful list of scummy/good targets and as such you shouldn't be paying any attention to his suggestions, unless of course you filter the players in question and also find them scummy. The list remains an awful idea; if everyone follows it, scum will not shoot into it then it will likely take all our KP and probably several days to even flip the list, thus nullifying the main point. Palmar why aren't you producing a list? What do you think about WBG? Why are you not cooperating with me and sandroba
I'm not good at reading WBG as even his town play is scummy due to always being slightly off with his reasoning, however he certainly hasn't given me a reason to think he is town in this game.
|
Finland5948 Posts
It would be easy to recommend lynching palmar tomorrow if that didn't waste our double lynches, so maybe on day 5 then
|
double lynch annul and serajai tomorrow
|
On November 27 2011 19:02 syllogism wrote:
In case it's not immediately obvious to our newer players; even if WBG happens to be town, he isn't capable of producing a useful list of scummy/good targets and as such you shouldn't be paying any attention to his suggestions, unless of course you filter the players in question and also find them scummy. The list remains an awful idea; if everyone follows it, scum will not shoot into it then it will likely take all our KP and probably several days to even flip the list, thus nullifying the main point. Palmar why aren't you producing a list? What do you think about WBG? Why are you not cooperating with me and sandroba
I'm not good at reading WBG as even his town play is scummy due to always being slightly off with his reasoning, however he certainly hasn't given me a reason to think he is town in this game.
simply because I haven't had the time yet, I went to sleep 3am last night, and I'm just waking up.
Expect it in the next few hours.
|
On November 27 2011 18:38 annul wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2011 18:22 Palmar wrote:
I lynched YM with plenty of reasoning. Turns out he was just an asshole and not scum. Well I can't really do much about that. apparently criticizing your campaign makes someone an asshole, go figure
Only when it's done with no thought whatsoever. Remember, there are a ton of people who opposed my campaign. I ignored them or responded for the most part.
|
|
|
On November 27 2011 19:09 syllogism wrote:
It would be easy to recommend lynching palmar tomorrow if that didn't waste our double lynches, so maybe on day 5 then
palmar already said he isnt using double lynch tonight.
this is absolutely atrocious on a common sense and logic standard... if he was town.
|
Finland5948 Posts
On November 27 2011 19:28 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2011 18:38 annul wrote:On November 27 2011 18:22 Palmar wrote:
I lynched YM with plenty of reasoning. Turns out he was just an asshole and not scum. Well I can't really do much about that. apparently criticizing your campaign makes someone an asshole, go figure Only when it's done with no thought whatsoever. Remember, there are a ton of people who opposed my campaign. I ignored them or responded for the most part.
It makes no sense a lone scum to criticize your campaign in a game with 16 scum and you should know this. There was little effort by anyone else to keep you from office. Again, he could have just been careless scum, but his fearless criticism made him more likely to be town.
|
Finland5948 Posts
If Palmar doesn't use double lynch tonight we'll lynch him
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
