|
On November 19 2011 00:30 risk.nuke wrote:Show nested quote +On November 19 2011 00:23 xsksc wrote:
Well Palmar, here's my thoughts.
I think the Kenpachi/Sinani lynches were silly. The only real scum read I have right now is on Drazerk. I'm not sure about Chaoser, I don't know his meta so it's harder for me to form an opinion on his town play. There are a couple of others I'm undecided on.
People I think are town :
wherebugsgo
palmar
risk.nuke
harbingerofdoom
lanaia
forumite
People I think are scum/I'm suspicious of :
prphlz
chaoser
drazerk
lemonwalrus
That's my current opinions, I have nothing solid to go on with chaoser/prphlz/lemon though.
Also, I'm really surprised I made it onto your vig list. I actually made a case on someone and stuck with it, I didn't join those ridiculous bandwagons that got two of our blues killed day 1.
Okey I think I just specifically said I don't want to see lists without reasoning. So xsksc your next post better explain that list with arguments.
Sure.
People I think are town :
wherebugsgo
His posts seem very pro-town to me, he made a convincing case on chaoser, he didn't join the silly lynches. I don't think he's scum.
palmar
Same as wherebugsgo basically. I agree with most of his reads, he's made some pretty strong cases imo. His posts seem townie to me.
risk.nuke
I could definitely be wrong here, your agressiveness towards people I think are scummy makes you look town. However you voted in BOTH of the lynches, so I'm not too sure about you.
harbingerofdoom
Already said it in my other post. He was pretty agressive to drazerk early on, before he got a lot of votes, and if I'm correct and drazerk is red, HoD looks pretty town to me.
lanaia
I wasn't sure before kenpachi flipped, but I think she just made a mistake in revealing her role day 1.
forumite
He made some pretty weird cases early, I don't think scum would make such blatantly obvious attempts at starting a bandwagon, I think he was just trying to get information. He also seemed eager for a drazerk lynch, which makes me think he's town.
I don't have solid cases on my scum list apart from Drazerk, and if you want to see my case on him just filter me. A lot of my list is just general vibes and feelings at the moment, some of the townies could be scum, and vice versa.
|
I don't think my case on him is weak Palmar. What reason could a townie possibly have to be posting like drazerk is? His defence of "I'mbadtownlol" and "I'm not gonna get lynched" is pretty appalling.
|
I gave my scum reads a page back Grey :p. I'm pretty suspicious of chaos. Wherebugsgo and Palmar made a pretty good case on him. LSB I haven't looked too closely at yet, but I'll filter him later when I have time. Going out to a party now and I probably won't be back till mid-morning.
|
Does this mean that we don't have vigis or is it more likely they didn't shoot?
|
##Vote: Drazerk
Not sure why we didn't lynch him day 1 tbh.
|
If you really are town drazerk then give me a good answer to this. Why are your posts so useless and anti-town? Just doesn't make sense to me.
|
##Unvote: Drazerk
Unless we got a reason to doubt his mason claim, I guess there's better lynch targets now.
Risk, why are you acusing me of bandwagoning? Drazerk has been my vote since the beginning. My day 2 vote on him was contentless because I already made my case on him day 1.
Prphlz has been on my list of suspicions for a while now, though I don't think the current case on him is strong enough to lynch him with, yet.
Palmar and wherebugsgo, do you still want chaoser lynched? How do you feel about prphlz?
|
Just woke up and skimmed the thread, got to run for work now.
Just realised I hadn't voted yet, I'll post explanations for these later, hopefully during lunch.
##Vote: Prphlz
##Vote: Nisani201
|
##Vote: prplhz
I voted him earlier, but it didn't seem to count.
|
Hey, sorry for hardly being on yesterday, I had a rough day.
I'm up for killing DCLXVI tomorow, his medic softclaim is bullshit.
|
I'm sorry again for my inactivity, had a shitty couple of days at work. I'll try and be more active today.
My vote on prplhz was really dumb, I know. When I was online it seemed to be a choice between him/Nisani/Palmar so I went with my instincts, cause I'm definitely not going to lynch Palmar. I should probably have just voted Nisani.
Looks like I got some votes on me as a result and some people think I'm scummy, fair enough.
Think back to day 1. If I am scum, why the hell did I not join those bandwagons on Kenpachi and Sinani that were filled with town and were super-easy for scum to blend in? I didn't vote for either of them. Sinani came very close to NOT being lynched, but then gets hammered in, iirc by Hyshes (now confirmed town). Not voting on him would be a stupid risk to take for pretty much no reward.
I'm with you Palmar, but I won't fistpound just in case it's connected with abilities. Will a ##Highfive suffice?
|
Also, why the fuck does everyone misspell my name? It's 5 fucking letters ._.
|
Wtf Coagulation...
Isn't there supposed to be some sort of mechanic in the game to prevent us lynching everyone in one go?
|
Lanaia, I'm kinda curious about you. You claimed blue very early on, why are you still alive?
|
I believe Palmar's claim but that doesn't mean that DCL is 100% scum, there's a small chance we could have some kind of 3 medic setup.
I'm going to agree that Nisani looks like the best lynch today, better than DCL anyway. He's been constantly going after the people who are generally accepted as town and his posts are shady.
##Vote: Nisani201
I'm also prettty suspicious of Lanaia. She says she never claimed blue, but when she blatantly anti-voted day 1 and her name appeared next to it, it's the same outcome. I'm really surprised she hasn't died yet.
|
Doesn't nisani have 10 votes now forumite?
|
On November 24 2011 23:57 Lanaia wrote:Show nested quote +On November 24 2011 23:53 xsksc wrote:
I'm also prettty suspicious of Lanaia. She says she never claimed blue, but when she blatantly anti-voted day 1 and her name appeared next to it, it's the same outcome. I'm really surprised she hasn't died yet.
I never OUTRIGHT claimed it. That was what I meant.
I re-read your post about the claim and I must have misunderstood it earlier. My bad, sorry.
I'm still curious that you're alive, have you been notified of any hits?
|
You're a townie who wanted to get lynched, so someone you've been arguing with gets lynched and you can spend more time in another game? Surely that's going against your win condition...
|
##Vote MrZentor
Can you be a bit more clear about this? Not going to unvote unless you give a much better explanation.
On November 25 2011 05:14 MrZentor wrote:I think we need to kill a mafia badly and I am mostly if not entirely partially vanilla town. 
|
In a few hours? Isn't there another day and a half until the deadline?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
