EPTMy Little Pony Mafia - Page 22
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
Lucidity
South Africa603 Posts
| ||
|
Sevryn
698 Posts
On September 14 2011 22:04 tnkted wrote: Fair enough, You certainly haven't been lurking. ##Unvote My thoughts on DroneAllDay: I don't think he's posted since the day started, which means he's probably going to get modkilled. Perhaps he hasn't checked his pms in awhile? Either way, I think he's going to get himself dead without anybody's help (@Dreamflower: This is one of the main reasons NOT to lynch lurkers; they tend to get themselves modkilled anyway and we waste a lynch). [red]Talking about DaD makes a point why not to lynch lurkers(kinda fluffy if paragraph)]/red] My thoughts on lucidity: his post analyzing dreamflower was extremely interesting because it was well done. I don't know if I agree with his conclusions, but his method was very effective: It paraphrased the important aspects of dreamflower's post, and interpreted them in order to understand what dreamflower was really talking about. THIS is a good way to find scum. He likes lucidity but doesn't agree with his conclusions about dreamflower that she is playing anti town Now, why he chose dreamflower and nobody else is kind of interesting; Dreamflowers scumhunting abilities are so legendary (for me anyway) that I have a hard time believing she intended to come across as scummy as she did. I want to hear her response before I vote for her. Also interesting to note is that lucidity didn't actually vote her himself; he's also waiting for a response. For what it's worth, right now dreamflower is my #1 vote but I'll abstain until she shows up to defend herself. what what what? you dont agree with his analysis but she is your #1 vote but then you dotn acctually want to vote for her? the pinnacle of wishy washyness is right here sir. Eh, what the hell. I can always change it later. ##Vote: Dreamflower I have no self control. Now, to deal with some mindless accusations: Okay you actually vote for her but you do a bunch of disclaimers that you can change your vote later and your impulsive with no self control seems like a very week pressure vote to me Frankly, this is a complete nonsense post. "Tnkted makes a good point about forumite not being scum, which convinced me, but later, i changed my mind and now I think he's scum too!" WHY did you change your mind when what I said made sense to you? Go find me evidence where he stopped acting like an annoyed townie and more like a frightened scum, and I'll consider switching to you. Please post a case against me instead of just throwing out soft foses. You think people don't notice when you do this? | ||
|
Sevryn
698 Posts
for being wishy washy scum | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
On September 15 2011 01:06 Lucidity wrote: What is nisani/sinani's relationship? We are friends IRL. | ||
|
dreamflower
United States312 Posts
As GreyMist posted earlier here, sinani206 was actively lurking early in Day One with three very general posts about the Day post and majority lynch. He apparently also thought Forumite was our best lynch target but does not post to express his agreement or views, even though the main argument about Forumite and Greymist were happening then. He then posts about twelve hours later, when Curu replaces OriginalName and immediately votes for sinani, to place his vote on me. This is also where he says that he believed Forumite was a perfectly good lynch candidate before the lynching-lurkers idea was introduced, though he does not say why he thought Forumite was so lynch-worthy. However, sinani says that the vote on me is merely a "pressure vote" because he wants an explanation of why lynching lurkers is better than lynching a perfectly good candidate. I should point out here that I was only one of many people who thought lynching lurkers would be a good idea; Nisani and Jackal were others, yet sinani has yet to put any pressure on them for being in favor of lynching lurkers. In addition, while the discussion on lynching lurkers was actually occurring, sinani never speaks up against it, even though other people objected to lynching lurkers or had reservations on who qualified as lurking or inactive. Furthermore, the topic of lurkers actually came up much earlier (in fact, it was part of Forumite's post that started the cases against him, most notably chaos13's) and sinani206 said nothing about lurkers then, either, whether to agree with Forumite or chaos13 about what to do with them. After this, when Curu continues accusing him, he switches his vote from me to Curu, with the reason that Curu is an idiot. He does not state a concrete reason why, except that Curu is being "super scummy" and voted for him. His insisting that no one answer Curu's questions to other players about their ideas also makes it look like he was trying to stifle discussion, even though discussion is widely agreed to be a good place to find information (particularly in a no-PMs game). This struck me as particularly confusing because Curu wasn't even asking about roles, just people's thoughts and rationales for specific votes and stances, which shouldn't be all that helpful to the Mafia. The impression sinani206 gives is that he was reading the thread, but didn't post his thoughts about his "perfectly good lynch candidate" or his opposition to lynching lurkers until both Greymist and Curu voted for him and accused him. This seems like active lurking to me. In addition, sinani's "polls are scummy" posts appear to want to stifle discussion in response to Curu's questions, even though discussion is the only way the town can communicate in this game with each other. He also has yet to express any real opinions and reasoning in this thread, aside from that he doesn't like the idea of lynching lurkers and thinks Curu is an idiot. So, I will vote for sinani206 for lynching today. ##Vote sinani206 | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
I will move my vote over to wherebugsgo, because he was perfectly active until we started arguing. He has posted no opinions on it because he doesn't feel the need to; he can afford for any of us to die. He simply comments on the same things that Curu has been bringing up, which is "Sinani played horribly in Ace's game, so we should lynch him." ##Vote: wherebugsgo | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
##Vote: wherebugsgo | ||
|
Sevryn
698 Posts
| ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
9-Greymist 10-Curu 16-Forumite 22-Dreamflower Curu (2) 15-sinani206 20-DroneAllDay tnkted (2) 8-wherebugsgo 21-Sevryn Forumite (1) 17-Chaos13 Dreamflower (1) 18-tnkted Chaos13 (1) 19-Jackal58 wherebugsgo (1) 23-Nisani201 DroneAllDay (0) Greymist (0) OriginalName (0) Abstaining (Modkills) (1) Lucidity | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
On September 15 2011 03:33 Sevryn wrote: Alright guys im going to work so I will not be around for the nightpost. I think tnkted or sinani206 are the best lynches atm and since we only need 7 getting a lynch shouldnt be that hard. I am going to leave my vote on Tnkted because i think he is the best lynch. Emphasis mine. The red text might not be scummy, but it´s wrong. It´s impossible getting a lynch going when everyone votes on the candidate they want lynched, no matter if anyone else agree. Perhaps he didn´t know how the votes were, but I doubt tnkted is not going to get 7 votes before the end of the day, so that vote looks wasted. Not voting on a leading candidate is a vote to not lynch at all. | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
Perhaps he didn´t know how the votes were, but I doubt tnkted is going to get 7 votes before the end of the day, so that vote looks wasted. | ||
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
On September 15 2011 00:30 Nisani201 wrote: Can we get a votecount? One is coming as soon as I get to a computer (so in about an hour) | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
| ||
|
Curu
Canada2817 Posts
So inactive. By the power of rainbows and sunshine I summon all Ponies into the thread! | ||
|
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
Day 1 Votecount: People have no idea of how to format. Forumite(2) Lucidity chaos13 Greymist(0) DroneAllDay(0) OriginalName/Curu(2) sinani206 DroneAllDay tnkted(2) wherebugsgo Sevryn sinani206(4) GreYMisT Curu Forumite dreamflower dreamflower(1) tnkted chaos13(1) Jackal58 wherebugsgo(1) Nisani201 About 5 hours left in the day. Remember you need 7 to lynch | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
Not much has changed since the last time I posted earlier this afternoon. I think dreamflower summed up a few of my thoughts about the sinani lynch quite nicely. I still think him to be our best target today. Jackal, Tnkted, Chaos, and Nishani you are all voting for outliers at the moment. Please look over the sinani lynch, in particular my and dream's posts, and let us know why you feel lynching him is not a good idea, and why your targets are better. | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
##Unvote ##Vote: Curu If anyone else is interested in lynching wherebugsgo, just post it here, and maybe I can get some more votes on him. | ||
|
Forumite
Sweden3280 Posts
I think Curu is Town. I get a scumread from sinani206 and tnkted. I´m open to switching to tnkted if needed. | ||
| ||
